x

Milne: A Move in the Right Direction - Ipswich Town News

Town managing director Ian Milne believes the recent amendments to the Financial Fair Play rules when coupled with a reduction in Premier League parachute payments and an increase in solidarity payments to Football League clubs are a “move in the right direction”.

Milne said: "The club has taken note of the amendments to the Financial Fair Play rules which we understand coincides with a decision by the Premier League to reduce the number of years of parachute payment to relegated clubs and an increase in payments to Championship clubs.

"Whilst still leaving a huge gap between parachute and non-parachute clubs, it is a move in the right direction.

"In return, the Championship have increased the amount of allowable losses which will assist relegated clubs in balancing their books as they transition from Premier League to the Championship.

"The rules still commit clubs to, in effect, caps on squad expenditure and Ipswich Town will continued to work prudently in the developments of its squad to work within the rules.”

Town were amongst the six clubs to vote against the amendments, which will allow clubs to record losses of up to £39 million over three seasons from 2016/17, but Milne says this was more as the club was happy with the current arrangements rather than hostility towards the new proposals.

"We like the existing rules and we wanted to see them through and we think that’s the right way to go ahead, so we were against it,” he said.

"But I think we can say that we were a weak no. We would have preferred the other rules but we go ahead with these.”

He doesn't believe the increase in allowable losses will make a significant difference to clubs’ recruiting power: "It’s gone up another £7 million. Over the past two or three years, and certainly this year, you look at the price of Championship players, how much can you buy for that sort of money?

"Also considering that on average a Championship player’s salary was £400,000 or £500,000 a year.

"If you put all these sums together, you’re not going to buy a new squad out of £7 million. In your analysis you’ve got to look at how much extra it does mean."

He added: "There is a point of view, which was expressed to me by one chief executive, that because of this increase a player that you’re paying £7,000 a week, their agent will come round and say ‘You’ve got more money, you can afford to pay him £14,000 a week’. There is that risk of that happening.”

The amendments have also seen FFP renamed Profitability and Sustainability, although Milne isn’t sure that’s an entire appropriate title: "They talk about sustainability, that’s the new phrase. Is increasing your losses a sustainable idea? I think the terms cut across one another.”

He believes one of the main reasons some clubs voted in favour of the changes was that for the first time they are guaranteed receiving the annual solidarity payments from the Premier League, which are currently worth £2.3 million a season to Championship sides.

"A lot of clubs wanted this to be put in place primarily because they wanted to stop the ‘gift’ element of the solidarity payment,” he said.

"It was always a gift that the Premier League could take away if they wanted to or if they felt that we were doing things that they didn’t want us to do. This will make it contractual.

"A lot of clubs find it financially difficult and they need that solidarity payment to make ends meet, we’re talking some in the Championship. And we mustn’t forget League One and League Two.

"It makes it certain that when they look at next year’s budget they are going to get that money. It’s not a case of them not knowing whether they are going to get that money.”

He continued: "And the other thing that a lot of the clubs wanted is that that payment will be pegged to how much media income the Premier League gets.

"So, if in the next round of talks with Sky or BT or whoever else, it goes up, this payment will increase.

"We aren’t talking extra mega-bucks, it could be from £2.3 million to £3 million. But it all depends on what the media payments will be.

"Everybody thinks that media money will go up, it normally does, but if BT pull out, I don’t know what effect that will have. But the point for clubs is the contractual solidarity.”

He says the increase in allowable losses may make Championship clubs more attractive to potential buyers: "The old FFP rules meant you would get investors who would want to come in and want to just spend, spend, spend and if it was too low an allowable loss then those investors wouldn’t be interested.

"That probably releases that a bit but not a lot with the way prices in the transfer market are going.”

Milne says the Premier League clubs’ agreement to reduce parachute payments - currently worth £60 million over four seasons - is also a significant step, although with the details of the changes yet to be confirmed: "The agreement has still got to be put into place, as I understand it from the last announcement.

"But they have voted on that. I don’t think they’ve actually put pen to paper on the detail, the Football League and the Premier League.

"The plan is to move it from four years to three years and if a club goes up and then the next season comes down they only get two years’ parachute payments.”

Town and all the other Championship clubs file their accounts for 2013/14 with the Football League at the start of December with the Blues’ results inside the required parameters.

"We’ll be within FFP. We won’t face any embargoes,” Milne confirmed. "I think there’s another story in the Championship about FFP in December once we hear from the Football League what they’re going to do.

"The big story is how they’re going to impose the fines. We’re very interested in that, and the embargoes as well. That’s the bigger story.

"All the clubs agreed it, 75 per cent is quite a big hurdle to get over. They signed up to it and from what I’ve been told by the Football League lawyers this is enforceable, and all clubs will be expecting them to enforce it. This is quite a major test for the Football League.”

Milne says clubs need to be sustainable to ensure their long-term futures and admits that the new situation isn’t ideal, although believes Town are in a better position than most: "You’ve got to have some financial stability on it. Are we there? Probably not.

"We think Ipswich Town have got it right, we’re in a good place, both in the table and also financially.”

Last year’s accounts showed Town’s debt to have risen to £82.44 million but Milne says this shouldn’t be viewed as a concern with all but a fraction owed to Evans - "This is no third party debt” - and with owners in his position well aware that they’re unlikely to see the money they have invested via loans ever again.

"We’re not selling but how much can you get for a football club?” he said. "The money that an owner has put into a club, he’s never going to see that back, unless maybe it goes up [to the Premier League]. But even then I doubt he’ll see that return.

"They’re never going to get their money back. Unless there’s a buyer who wants that particular club and is desperate for it and there’s also somebody else out there who feels equally the same and there’s a bidding war.”

He added: "Marcus really wants to see the club promoted, he’s genuinely in a good place. Great manager, great team.

"I think the performances are now showing through to attendances and that’s a great place for Mick and Marcus to be in.”

Meanwhile, Milne believes the Football League needs to sell itself better than it has in the recent past: "I think what is important now, and I and a number of chief executives are very adamant on this, the Football League has now got to get its own commercial deals in order.

"There were a number of commercial deals which were done three or four years ago which weren’t very good, the media deals.

"I think there’s a lot more money that we as a league - and as a Championship as well - can negotiate from TV companies from overseas.

"I think the Championship product has got a high value overseas and I think if they get it right this could bring a lot of money into the Championship and hopefully the contractual solidarity payment should actually be quite a small part. That would be the ideal because things have changed.

"I think we’ve got brands, both the Ipswich Town brand and a Championship brand, to sell and market.”

He says the current Football League chief executive Shaun Harvey is moving things in the right direction: "Shaun Harvey, to give him his due, has got a totally new commercial team in there and they know what they’ve got to do and quite a number of us are going to make sure that they do it.

"That’s what I call sustainability. Getting value for the product that we produce on a long-term basis.”

Milne believes the play-offs in particular have a great deal of potential: "As a number of chief executives have said, the play-offs are a fantastic tournament and there’s a lot more money we should be able to get for that, a lot more sponsorship, and I think that’s an area which we haven’t really pushed forward as a group."

What to read next:

Baggott Recalled to Provisional Indonesia Squad
Town central defender Elkan Baggott has been named in a 41-man provisional Indonesia squad ahead of the FIFA Series 2026, an invitational friendly tournament they are hosting in Jakarta on March 27th and 30th.
McKenna: We'll Have a Bit of Planning to Do Ahead of Busy Final Month
Town boss Kieran McKenna admits he and his staff have some planning to do ahead of a final month of the season which will see them play eight games in 27 days, five away from home, following the postponement of the Good Friday match at Southampton due to the Saints’ progress in the FA Cup.
McKenna: PGMOL Has Admitted We Should Have Had Two Penalties
Town boss Kieran McKenna says the PGMOL, the body which manages referees, has admitted the Blues should have been awarded two penalties during Saturday’s 1-1 home draw with Leicester City.
McKenna: Philogene Still Out, a Few Issues From Saturday
Town will again be without forward Jaden Philogene when they travel to Stoke City on Tuesday evening, while manager Kieran McKenna says there are one or two other issues from Saturday’s draw with Leicester which could impact availability.
Town Appoint Former Manchester United Man as Head of European Scouting
Town have appointed former Manchester United, Tottenham and Hannover 96 scout Peter Braund as their head of European scouting.
Town Facing Midweek Trip to Southampton
Town face a midweek trip to Southampton after the Saints progressed to the quarter-finals of the FA Cup by winning 1-0 away at Fulham in round five this afternoon.
[Podcast] Blue Monday - New Podcast Now Online
A new podcast from the Blue Monday team is now available.
Academy Trio Move Out on Loan
Academy youngsters Abube Onuchukwu, Afi Adebayo and Archie Brown have made moves out on loan.
Davis: You Could See the Spirit Between the Boys
Leif Davis believes Town have shown significant growth in character since the early stages of the Championship season.
U18s Beat Leicester
Town’s U18s beat Leicester City 3-1 on Saturday afternoon despite losing keeper Josh Bentley to injury in the first half and missing a late penalty.