| VOTE CHAMBERS 22:26 - Mar 14 with 9120 views | SitfcB |
For supporters POTY |  |
| |  |
| VOTE CHAMBERS on 10:14 - Mar 15 with 3859 views | Championship |
I like this idea. A thank you for his off the pitch work. |  | | |
| What has happened to you?! on 10:19 - Mar 15 with 3850 views | Meadowlark |
| What has happened to you?! on 07:59 - Mar 15 by SitfcB |
No one deserves it.
Chambers should get it for holding the club together. |
I see where you're coming from. I'll think about it. |  | | |
| What has happened to you?! on 10:34 - Mar 15 with 3829 views | chicoazul |
| What has happened to you?! on 07:59 - Mar 15 by SitfcB |
No one deserves it.
Chambers should get it for holding the club together. |
This is, in fact, an excellent argument. He should get it on that basis. |  |
| |
| VOTE CHAMBERS on 11:07 - Mar 15 with 3800 views | DebsyAngel |
Trevoh for me as well. With Judge as a close second. |  | | |
| VOTE CHAMBERS on 11:43 - Mar 15 with 3779 views | maccyd9 |
Jeez, some of the mentions on here for POTY are truly ridiculous.
Bishop? Edwards? Sears? Trev?
In reality, nobody deserves the award. Our best player (whoever that is) has probably been slightly better than poor.
I'd go Chambo though but change the award title to Club man of the Season or something like that because unquestionably he has been an excellent captain and leader throughout a thoroughly miserable time. I'd be happy for him to be recognised. |  | | |
| VOTE CHAMBERS on 11:54 - Mar 15 with 3758 views | TractorCam |
| VOTE CHAMBERS on 11:43 - Mar 15 by maccyd9 |
Jeez, some of the mentions on here for POTY are truly ridiculous.
Bishop? Edwards? Sears? Trev?
In reality, nobody deserves the award. Our best player (whoever that is) has probably been slightly better than poor.
I'd go Chambo though but change the award title to Club man of the Season or something like that because unquestionably he has been an excellent captain and leader throughout a thoroughly miserable time. I'd be happy for him to be recognised. |
Trev has been our most consistent performer throughout the season bearing the few slip ups, understandably as he's an 18/19 year old in his first season as a professional.
Too me it's clear as day him, but I might lean towards Chambers for the reasons outlined. |  |
| |
| VOTE CHAMBERS on 11:58 - Mar 15 with 3755 views | maccyd9 |
| VOTE CHAMBERS on 11:54 - Mar 15 by TractorCam |
Trev has been our most consistent performer throughout the season bearing the few slip ups, understandably as he's an 18/19 year old in his first season as a professional.
Too me it's clear as day him, but I might lean towards Chambers for the reasons outlined. |
Trev's done ok imo, but no more than that.
Started very slowly, got better as the season has gone on but still a long way off being a good championship performer.
It's about opinions though. I thought he was poor midweek but got MOTM. It depends on what you like I guess. | | | |
| VOTE CHAMBERS on 12:02 - Mar 15 with 3747 views | itfcjoe |
| VOTE CHAMBERS on 11:58 - Mar 15 by maccyd9 |
Trev's done ok imo, but no more than that.
Started very slowly, got better as the season has gone on but still a long way off being a good championship performer.
It's about opinions though. I thought he was poor midweek but got MOTM. It depends on what you like I guess. |
No one is deserving of it for on pitch contributions - had Sears stayed fit and got 11 or 12 goals then would have been fairly easy case to make, but he didn't. |  |
| |
Login to get fewer ads
| VOTE CHAMBERS on 12:16 - Mar 15 with 3729 views | PJH |
| VOTE CHAMBERS on 12:02 - Mar 15 by itfcjoe |
No one is deserving of it for on pitch contributions - had Sears stayed fit and got 11 or 12 goals then would have been fairly easy case to make, but he didn't. |
I think that if this seasons POTY is voted for purely on on field performances it will end up with whoever has been the least poor, in the opinion of the person voting.
Nobody has had a good season but some are having an 'ok' season based on the fact that they have occasionally been good,often been average and sometimes been poor.
Using the above criteria I will probably still end up with selecting Pennington as I would have done had voting been done in January or whenever the POTY was discussed on here previously. |  | | |
| VOTE CHAMBERS on 12:39 - Mar 15 with 3708 views | Superblue95 |
| VOTE CHAMBERS on 08:01 - Mar 15 by Meadowlark |
Bishop or Edwards.
Definitely NOT Chambers. |
Bishop  |  |
| |
| VOTE CHAMBERS on 12:41 - Mar 15 with 3704 views | braveblue |
| VOTE CHAMBERS on 08:55 - Mar 15 by artsbossbeard |
He was a great captain when we weren't doing well (have we done well this season?) and that's why he'll get my vote.
The work that Chambers did behind the scenes with the squad to make up for the shortcomings of PH proved a) that he loves this club and b) he's a bloody good bloke to have around when the chips are down.
He's got his flaws but we'll look back on him v fondly in a few years. |
What work exactly? | | | |
| VOTE CHAMBERS on 12:54 - Mar 15 with 3690 views | HarryWright |
Downes for me, nothing special but consistency and it'll mean a lot to him. |  | | |
| VOTE CHAMBERS on 13:03 - Mar 15 with 3680 views | SouperJim |
Donacien |  |
| |
| VOTE CHAMBERS on 15:36 - Mar 15 with 3633 views | TractorCam |
| VOTE CHAMBERS on 12:16 - Mar 15 by PJH |
I think that if this seasons POTY is voted for purely on on field performances it will end up with whoever has been the least poor, in the opinion of the person voting.
Nobody has had a good season but some are having an 'ok' season based on the fact that they have occasionally been good,often been average and sometimes been poor.
Using the above criteria I will probably still end up with selecting Pennington as I would have done had voting been done in January or whenever the POTY was discussed on here previously. |
In that case, Lankester! | |
| |
| VOTE CHAMBERS on 15:38 - Mar 15 with 3633 views | grimboy |
Are you soft player of the year is exactly that.chambers has been awful for most part. |  | | |
| VOTE CHAMBERS on 15:46 - Mar 15 with 3623 views | BoxerBlue |
Chalobah or Pennington for me |  |
| |
| VOTE CHAMBERS on 15:48 - Mar 15 with 3619 views | grimboy |
| VOTE CHAMBERS on 15:46 - Mar 15 by BoxerBlue |
Chalobah or Pennington for me |
Pennington has been on average our best player. | | | |
| VOTE CHAMBERS on 21:38 - Mar 15 with 3544 views | Wonky |
| VOTE CHAMBERS on 08:51 - Mar 15 by RobTheMonk |
Trev has won me over. He's been on a bit of a personal journey with regards to performances this season. I was a critic earlier in the season (rightly so in my opinion) but he's been doing really well recently and has started to cut out the silly mistakes. I just wish that we had this current Trev from the start but I guess that's why teams loan players out: for the experience and to see if they can develop which Trev now seems to be doing. |
Can't disagree with this assessment. |  | | |
| VOTE CHAMBERS on 04:17 - Mar 16 with 3492 views | BonchosBicycle |
Almost gutted to say Chalobah or Pennington. Both have been almost entirely rock solid this season and I wish we could have them next year. Chambers continues to be impressive in the "intangibles" and provides an important anchor at the back, but is limited, especially when being asked to play out. |  | | |
| VOTE CHAMBERS on 08:25 - Mar 16 with 3464 views | Superblue95 |
| VOTE CHAMBERS on 04:17 - Mar 16 by BonchosBicycle |
Almost gutted to say Chalobah or Pennington. Both have been almost entirely rock solid this season and I wish we could have them next year. Chambers continues to be impressive in the "intangibles" and provides an important anchor at the back, but is limited, especially when being asked to play out. |
Chalobah hasn’t been rock solid. You even started a thread a few months ago highlighting how his inconsistency frustrates you.
Pennington has been directly responsible for numerous goals conceded.
Both are good players and will likely have very good careers but neither deserves to be our player of the season | |
| |
| VOTE CHAMBERS on 14:03 - Mar 16 with 3436 views | BonchosBicycle |
| VOTE CHAMBERS on 08:25 - Mar 16 by Superblue95 |
Chalobah hasn’t been rock solid. You even started a thread a few months ago highlighting how his inconsistency frustrates you.
Pennington has been directly responsible for numerous goals conceded.
Both are good players and will likely have very good careers but neither deserves to be our player of the season |
"almost entirely rock solid"
Both have made errors - as has everyone this year. I think they've made fewer than most, and Chalobah has definitely become less prone to the youthful exuberance that could put your face in your hands in the last couple of months. | | | |
| |
By continuing to use the site, you agree to our use of cookies and to abide by our Terms and Conditions.
