| Anyone not have sympathy for Neil Warnock? 14:31 - Apr 1 with 3881 views | No9 |
His comments about the oficials is right but it isn't confined to the PL.
The officiating at the Cardiff Chelsea games was appalling.
But that isn't the only game
Time for the FA/EFL to do something |  | | |  |
| Anyone not have sympathy for Neil Warnock? on 14:33 - Apr 1 with 3853 views | tractorshark |
He’s absolutely right but he wouldn’t give a toss if it was the other way round.
Warnock has a short temper and a short memory. | | | |
| Anyone not have sympathy for Neil Warnock? on 14:36 - Apr 1 with 3832 views | Wickets |
What goes round comes round ! |  | | |
| Anyone not have sympathy for Neil Warnock? on 14:39 - Apr 1 with 3825 views | Steve_M |
| Anyone not have sympathy for Neil Warnock? on 14:33 - Apr 1 by tractorshark |
He’s absolutely right but he wouldn’t give a toss if it was the other way round.
Warnock has a short temper and a short memory. |
As was indeed the case when a refereeing decision went for them against Brighton last month.
Talking about how who should have punched the referee is great bantz for all those amateur referees far more likely to be punched by annoyed players. |  |
| |
| Anyone not have sympathy for Neil Warnock? on 14:41 - Apr 1 with 3817 views | No9 |
| Anyone not have sympathy for Neil Warnock? on 14:33 - Apr 1 by tractorshark |
He’s absolutely right but he wouldn’t give a toss if it was the other way round.
Warnock has a short temper and a short memory. |
This was a case of bad reff'ing that happens every week in football
If things aren't improved then the game won't be worth watching | | | |
| Anyone not have sympathy for Neil Warnock? on 15:34 - Apr 1 with 3719 views | Benters2 |
Warnock is the manager I’ve always wanted at Towen.
Watched that game yesterday the officials had a shocker.
End of. | | | |
| Anyone not have sympathy for Neil Warnock? on 15:51 - Apr 1 with 3644 views | Herbivore |
Sympathy for Neil Warnock - isn't that a Stones song? |  |
| |
| Anyone not have sympathy for Neil Warnock? on 16:00 - Apr 1 with 3638 views | Marshalls_Mullet |
No sympathy.
Refs have an impossible job, as they are judged to impossible standards.
Punditry is pedantry!! The pundits judge refs based on watching numerous replays, and using technology that the refs dont have.
The criticism of refs and over analysis is ruining football.
In the main, teams lose games due to their players and managers mistakes, which are far more common the refereeing mistakes.
No sympathy.
Edit..... they are also trying to run a game with at least 24 cheats involved (including managers) [Post edited 1 Apr 2019 16:07]
|  |
| |
| Anyone not have sympathy for Neil Warnock? on 16:16 - Apr 1 with 3565 views | Garv |
Sympathy for Cardiff, not really for Warnock.
Pathetic way he stared down the officials at the end. If I was the ref I would have told him where to go. |  |
| |
Login to get fewer ads
| Anyone not have sympathy for Neil Warnock? on 16:30 - Apr 1 with 3489 views | Illinoisblue |
has his club paid the transfer fee for Sala yet? |  |
| |
| Anyone not have sympathy for Neil Warnock? on 16:48 - Apr 1 with 3438 views | Marshalls_Mullet |
| Anyone not have sympathy for Neil Warnock? on 16:30 - Apr 1 by Illinoisblue |
has his club paid the transfer fee for Sala yet? |
....karma... | |
| |
| Anyone not have sympathy for Neil Warnock? on 16:58 - Apr 1 with 3421 views | christiand |
Certainly feel they have had some poor decisions recently. However, Cardiff City and Warnock unfortunately are out of their depth in the Premier League, simply not good enough for that level of football. [Post edited 1 Apr 2019 17:05]
| |
| |
| Anyone not have sympathy for Neil Warnock? on 17:03 - Apr 1 with 3407 views | factual_blue |
Not really. A manager who got a game abandoned by ensuring his team was reduced to six players loses all credibility and sympathy for ever. |  |
| |
| Anyone not have sympathy for Neil Warnock? on 17:04 - Apr 1 with 3406 views | factual_blue |
| Anyone not have sympathy for Neil Warnock? on 16:00 - Apr 1 by Marshalls_Mullet |
No sympathy.
Refs have an impossible job, as they are judged to impossible standards.
Punditry is pedantry!! The pundits judge refs based on watching numerous replays, and using technology that the refs dont have.
The criticism of refs and over analysis is ruining football.
In the main, teams lose games due to their players and managers mistakes, which are far more common the refereeing mistakes.
No sympathy.
Edit..... they are also trying to run a game with at least 24 cheats involved (including managers) [Post edited 1 Apr 2019 16:07]
|
Well said.
Also, I can't recall seeing a pundit ever who actually fully understands the laws of the game. [Post edited 1 Apr 2019 17:05]
| |
| |
| Anyone not have sympathy for Neil Warnock? on 18:23 - Apr 1 with 3277 views | tractorshark |
| Anyone not have sympathy for Neil Warnock? on 14:41 - Apr 1 by No9 |
This was a case of bad reff'ing that happens every week in football
If things aren't improved then the game won't be worth watching |
It was a shocking decision but it’s an interesting debate as to whether these mistakes ruin football or the experience.
I go to Germany to watch the Bundesliga where they have VAR. While that has improved decision making, there are still flaws, it still comes down to opinion and a lot of fans don’t like it.
It has certainly diminished the joy of celebrating a goal. Because a fair few get chalked off, fans don’t know whether to celebrate any more.
It dilutes the passion of the moment, which is a shame because in every other aspect German fans create the best atmosphere at football.
For me, football is a human sport with human emotion and human error.
Strikers miss open goals, defender score own goals and referees make mistakes.
On the whole, they don’t make many but every error is scrutinised and magnified.
Now I will criticise refs as much as any fan, and this was a bad mistake, but don’t get fooled into thinking it’s the reason why Cardiff will be relegated.
That is predominantly down to an inferior squad and mistakes from their players and manager, not the officials. | | | |
| Anyone not have sympathy for Neil Warnock? on 18:43 - Apr 1 with 3238 views | itfcbam |
the sympathy I have is clear. that sort of decision is next to never given in favour of a little club against one of the top 6. As the fuss and media hype, manager outcry would be ridiculas. it's unusual for this much coverage to be given to the smaller club. at the end of it the 3 points lost arguably could cost Cardiff relegation and 100mil. | | | |
| Anyone not have sympathy for Neil Warnock? on 19:50 - Apr 1 with 3163 views | Chocorange |
| Anyone not have sympathy for Neil Warnock? on 18:43 - Apr 1 by itfcbam |
the sympathy I have is clear. that sort of decision is next to never given in favour of a little club against one of the top 6. As the fuss and media hype, manager outcry would be ridiculas. it's unusual for this much coverage to be given to the smaller club. at the end of it the 3 points lost arguably could cost Cardiff relegation and 100mil. |
Agree with this, you have to look no further than us this season.
And while I appreciate we are not bottom of the table because of refs, we have had several key decisions go against us, and very few 50/50 40/60 decisions go for us.Where as the team's at the top do get the benefit more often than not.
Nsiala sending off
2 terrible decisions versus Villa
Edun sent off
Jackson last minute pen versus Forest
How many have gone for us?
Cardif and us are also not alone, Huddersfield have had some shockers, Swansea in the cup vs Man City, the list goes on , hardly a weekend goes by without one going in favour of a 'big ' team or a team near the top. |  | | |
| Anyone not have sympathy for Neil Warnock? on 10:21 - Apr 2 with 2888 views | King_of_Portman_Rd |
I listened to Glenn Murray's response which I thought was pretty much spot on (Paraphrased)
"Referee has made a big mistake that effected the game and Cardiff were very unlucky. Everyone needs to realise the magnitude of the mistakes as it impacts everyone involved in the club (not just players), but it's one of the toughest jobs around and they need support so VAR needs to be implemented asap." |  | | |
| Anyone not have sympathy for Neil Warnock? on 10:27 - Apr 2 with 2882 views | King_of_Portman_Rd |
I don't actually mind Warnock, but I've never particularly liked Cardiff.
At the beginning of the season I would have said that I wanted them to be relegated, but after the whole Sala incident where they have shown absolutely no class whatsoever I desperately hope they get relegated, are found to have been in breach of FIFA regulations and fined appropriately and exposed as the charlatans that they are.
That said, I don't think any fan (or follower) of football wants to see mistakes like the one at the weekend. | | | |
| Anyone not have sympathy for Neil Warnock? on 11:06 - Apr 2 with 2841 views | BackToRussia |
Who really gives a fvck about referees/refereeing? It's so boring. Anyone going on about it is making excuses. Even if the decision is blatantly wrong, just get on with it. Compensate by being better at football. |  |
| |
| Anyone not have sympathy for Neil Warnock? on 12:10 - Apr 2 with 2799 views | maccyd9 |
| Anyone not have sympathy for Neil Warnock? on 16:00 - Apr 1 by Marshalls_Mullet |
No sympathy.
Refs have an impossible job, as they are judged to impossible standards.
Punditry is pedantry!! The pundits judge refs based on watching numerous replays, and using technology that the refs dont have.
The criticism of refs and over analysis is ruining football.
In the main, teams lose games due to their players and managers mistakes, which are far more common the refereeing mistakes.
No sympathy.
Edit..... they are also trying to run a game with at least 24 cheats involved (including managers) [Post edited 1 Apr 2019 16:07]
|
Spot on.
I'm quite often amazed at how many close calls linesman get spot on. They are on a hiding to nothing and like you say, they aren't just having to adhere to the rules of the game, they are having to contend with 22 cheating players, 2 cheating managers, mouthy coaches and even substitutes.
Can't stand the premiership and frankly, after there behaviour towards the Sala situation, I hope they get relegated and relegated badly. | | | |
| Anyone not have sympathy for Neil Warnock? on 12:39 - Apr 2 with 2758 views | RobTheMonk |
For the Azpelecuita goa, Sky used a VR headset on Carragher last night to show what the linesman saw. His view would of been blocked by William and there's not much he could of done to change it in the split second the cross came in. VAR at the top level should be a good thing if used correctly. |  | | |
| Anyone not have sympathy for Neil Warnock? on 20:35 - Apr 2 with 2648 views | No9 |
| Anyone not have sympathy for Neil Warnock? on 14:39 - Apr 1 by Steve_M |
As was indeed the case when a refereeing decision went for them against Brighton last month.
Talking about how who should have punched the referee is great bantz for all those amateur referees far more likely to be punched by annoyed players. |
The point is that it is happening too often.
I don't agree with the pundits having hours to form a view but some of the offences are blatant and nowt gets done.
Ref's are human and we have seen in some games VAR hasn't been toe panacea to all ills
But I have posted several times about bad officials and believe the authorities have a duty to fans to improve the qality of the officials
Pushing, pulling holding, wrestling, ballroom dancing etc. in the penalty are is a starting place. | | | |
| |
By continuing to use the site, you agree to our use of cookies and to abide by our Terms and Conditions.
