Forum |

Forum index | Previous Thread | Next thread

"Umpire's Call" 13:24 - Jul 11 with 826 views

Given that most of the controversy with VAR surrounds the highly-marginal decisions such as in the Cameroon and USA matches in the Women's World Cup, and the Netherlands game in the Nations League, is there a case for allowing these sort of decisions to stand based on the original decision?

Poll:

Predictions for tonight?

"Umpire's Call" on 13:28 - Jul 11 with 806 views

cvillageblue

Don't be silly - that makes too much sense!!

Blog:

Was It Worth It?

"Umpire's Call" on 13:33 - Jul 11 with 788 views

Steve_M

It doesn't quite work because the tendency will be to let marginal offsides, in particular, go knowing that the technology will pick up any error if a goal is scored. Which is surely right because it is better to err in favour of an attacker and still allow the chance than a defender in those situations.

Cricket has the advantage of the ball going dead regardless so the game can stop.

Poll:	When are the squad numbers out?
Blog:	Cycle of Hurt

"Umpire's Call" on 17:47 - Jul 11 with 679 views

Wickets

Yer i agree but stop talking sense when your talking about the powers that run football !

Forum index | Previous Thread | Next thread