Nydam 14:25 - Jul 11 with 3443 views | Bluefish | Please can we try and get him a decent loan move this year. I tried saying we should have loaned Dozzell last season and Hurst clearly wanted to but I believe the fan reaction led Evan's to intervene. Both of their careers have gone backwards last year, it is hard to know when a loan move is right and Nydam didn't seem to do a lot wrong at SJ he just wasnt given the chances. I am a big fan of Nydam but bit part utility player will not help him this season. Just like bit part anywhere in midfield didn't help Andre last season. | |
| | |
Nydam on 14:30 - Jul 11 with 3426 views | itfcjoe | I'd have him in as left back, ahead of Kenlock. No way into the midfield here even if he has a great loan season, which would be unlikely with the way that system works anyway. He has a much higher ceiling as a footballer than Kenlock, get him in. Note - I have seen the Garbutt news and think it's a bad move | |
| |
Nydam on 14:41 - Jul 11 with 3382 views | chicoazul | We should loan him out yes, but let's remember he couldnt get in a Scottish side last season. Still time I suppose, but hard to see where he fits in with 3 in midfield. | |
| |
Nydam on 14:42 - Jul 11 with 3377 views | Bluefish |
Nydam on 14:30 - Jul 11 by itfcjoe | I'd have him in as left back, ahead of Kenlock. No way into the midfield here even if he has a great loan season, which would be unlikely with the way that system works anyway. He has a much higher ceiling as a footballer than Kenlock, get him in. Note - I have seen the Garbutt news and think it's a bad move |
I realised afterwards that I didn't mention the post is off the back of the Garbutt story | |
| |
Nydam on 14:43 - Jul 11 with 3368 views | chicoazul |
Nydam on 14:30 - Jul 11 by itfcjoe | I'd have him in as left back, ahead of Kenlock. No way into the midfield here even if he has a great loan season, which would be unlikely with the way that system works anyway. He has a much higher ceiling as a footballer than Kenlock, get him in. Note - I have seen the Garbutt news and think it's a bad move |
Why? Isnt Garbutt any good? I have no idea. | |
| |
Nydam on 14:45 - Jul 11 with 3362 views | itfcjoe |
Nydam on 14:41 - Jul 11 by chicoazul | We should loan him out yes, but let's remember he couldnt get in a Scottish side last season. Still time I suppose, but hard to see where he fits in with 3 in midfield. |
The problem with loans is they are so hit and miss. He effectively went to St J to back up their captain (Youth Cup winning captain Liam Craig), but Craig played every game so he never got a chance. Similar to Jack Marriott's 'failed' loan spell at Gillingham, he went to replace a striker who was having a hernia op and after move dcided to delay it until end of season so chance gone. Loan looks a failure. It's a really poor system, especially now the big boys have such clout they can dictate that a player plays or there are severe financial penalties. Now we are in L1 we are almost too far down the pyramid to have loans out and them be worthwhile | |
| |
Nydam on 14:50 - Jul 11 with 3343 views | itfcjoe |
Nydam on 14:43 - Jul 11 by chicoazul | Why? Isnt Garbutt any good? I have no idea. |
He looked good a few years back but his career seems to have just stalled. Oxford fans last year thought he was awful at left back and he ended up dropped before coming in and doing well as a left midfielder. 26 now and not established himself in top 2 tiers and still living off about 50 England youth caps. He probably is an upgrade on Kenlock but he's not a long term solution in any way. Be better off trying to develop someone or sign someone permanently | |
| |
Nydam on 14:53 - Jul 11 with 3322 views | ITFC_Forever |
Nydam on 14:50 - Jul 11 by itfcjoe | He looked good a few years back but his career seems to have just stalled. Oxford fans last year thought he was awful at left back and he ended up dropped before coming in and doing well as a left midfielder. 26 now and not established himself in top 2 tiers and still living off about 50 England youth caps. He probably is an upgrade on Kenlock but he's not a long term solution in any way. Be better off trying to develop someone or sign someone permanently |
He's another one like Pennington. Been tied to a top 10 Prem club for too long to be classed as a promising youngster, will never break in to their first team and has not been good enough for someone to come in and buy him. Pennington is 24, Garbutt is 26.... their careers are wasting away. | |
| |
Nydam on 14:57 - Jul 11 with 3301 views | TractorJack |
Nydam on 14:45 - Jul 11 by itfcjoe | The problem with loans is they are so hit and miss. He effectively went to St J to back up their captain (Youth Cup winning captain Liam Craig), but Craig played every game so he never got a chance. Similar to Jack Marriott's 'failed' loan spell at Gillingham, he went to replace a striker who was having a hernia op and after move dcided to delay it until end of season so chance gone. Loan looks a failure. It's a really poor system, especially now the big boys have such clout they can dictate that a player plays or there are severe financial penalties. Now we are in L1 we are almost too far down the pyramid to have loans out and them be worthwhile |
Agreed, not fair to judge him on that at all. This is why it's a great idea to have a Loan Manager. Norwich have seen a lot of success for this reason. | | | | Login to get fewer ads
Nydam on 14:58 - Jul 11 with 3291 views | FPL_Tractor |
Nydam on 14:50 - Jul 11 by itfcjoe | He looked good a few years back but his career seems to have just stalled. Oxford fans last year thought he was awful at left back and he ended up dropped before coming in and doing well as a left midfielder. 26 now and not established himself in top 2 tiers and still living off about 50 England youth caps. He probably is an upgrade on Kenlock but he's not a long term solution in any way. Be better off trying to develop someone or sign someone permanently |
Could he be an option on the left wing too then? We have a gap there too. | |
| For more ITFC chat and some fantasy football mutterings follow me on twitter @fpl_tractor. |
| |
Nydam on 14:59 - Jul 11 with 3289 views | BlueBadger |
Nydam on 14:57 - Jul 11 by TractorJack | Agreed, not fair to judge him on that at all. This is why it's a great idea to have a Loan Manager. Norwich have seen a lot of success for this reason. |
I like the idea of getting a manager in on loan, I'm not sure the current one's up to the job of first-team.... | |
| |
Nydam on 15:01 - Jul 11 with 3272 views | ElderGrizzly |
Nydam on 14:30 - Jul 11 by itfcjoe | I'd have him in as left back, ahead of Kenlock. No way into the midfield here even if he has a great loan season, which would be unlikely with the way that system works anyway. He has a much higher ceiling as a footballer than Kenlock, get him in. Note - I have seen the Garbutt news and think it's a bad move |
Garbutt is a bad move if we don’t have a permanent deal lined up. He has a higher ceiling than Nydam and Kenlock, but agree with you i’d rather see Nydam at LB than Kenlock | | | |
Nydam on 15:03 - Jul 11 with 3263 views | ITFC_Forever |
Nydam on 14:59 - Jul 11 by BlueBadger | I like the idea of getting a manager in on loan, I'm not sure the current one's up to the job of first-team.... |
You're a year late with that post. Whether it's still applicable remains to be seen. | |
| |
Nydam on 15:04 - Jul 11 with 3257 views | itfcjoe |
Nydam on 15:01 - Jul 11 by ElderGrizzly | Garbutt is a bad move if we don’t have a permanent deal lined up. He has a higher ceiling than Nydam and Kenlock, but agree with you i’d rather see Nydam at LB than Kenlock |
He's 26, and is still in League 1 - this probably is his ceiling. And no way will we have a permanent deal lined up | |
| |
Nydam on 15:23 - Jul 11 with 3206 views | judespiveyg | It's difficult to say as he hasn't got much hope of getting into our midfield, yet he looked a pretty decent, if a little raw, championship midfielder in 17/18 during the dozen or so appearances so you'd think he'd be capable enough in league 1. Maybe a loan to another league 1 club? Don't reckon he'll be back up left back if Garbutt's in. As for Dozzell, I imagine he'll be starting alongside Bishop on the opening day given Nolan and Huws' uncertain fitness. | |
| I survived Ipswich 0-0 Burton |
| |
Nydam on 15:44 - Jul 11 with 3160 views | Marshalls_Mullet | I would rather keep him and let him compete for a place. He is more than capable of playing a part in League 1. His versatility could be a real asset. | |
| |
Nydam on 15:45 - Jul 11 with 3159 views | Marshalls_Mullet |
Nydam on 14:30 - Jul 11 by itfcjoe | I'd have him in as left back, ahead of Kenlock. No way into the midfield here even if he has a great loan season, which would be unlikely with the way that system works anyway. He has a much higher ceiling as a footballer than Kenlock, get him in. Note - I have seen the Garbutt news and think it's a bad move |
Have an uppie. Not sure why this was downvoted. Agree re Garbutt, doesnt have a great CV. But people seem excited because he is from Everton. | |
| |
Nydam on 16:04 - Jul 11 with 3110 views | christiand | I reckon he’s got a chance of starting at LB this season. | |
| |
Nydam on 18:01 - Jul 11 with 2984 views | Westcountryblue |
Nydam on 15:45 - Jul 11 by Marshalls_Mullet | Have an uppie. Not sure why this was downvoted. Agree re Garbutt, doesnt have a great CV. But people seem excited because he is from Everton. |
He plays left back and left wing and we only have 2 naturally left footed wide players at the club currently. Good player, experienced at this level and will provide depth and versatility. | | | |
Nydam on 18:10 - Jul 11 with 2966 views | Keaneish | I'd rather he stayed and shadowed Alan Judge for the first half the season to be honest. Give him the carabao cup, EFL Trophy, U23s and games from the bench and send him out second half with a 24 hour recall. | |
| |
Nydam on 18:26 - Jul 11 with 2939 views | Mullet |
Nydam on 18:10 - Jul 11 by Keaneish | I'd rather he stayed and shadowed Alan Judge for the first half the season to be honest. Give him the carabao cup, EFL Trophy, U23s and games from the bench and send him out second half with a 24 hour recall. |
Why would he shadow Judge per se? Totally different players, attributes and roles thus far. Converting Dozzell to a winger and TN to an attacking midfielder seems up there with the suggestions that are most odd. | |
| |
Nydam on 20:37 - Jul 11 with 2837 views | Keaneish |
Nydam on 18:26 - Jul 11 by Mullet | Why would he shadow Judge per se? Totally different players, attributes and roles thus far. Converting Dozzell to a winger and TN to an attacking midfielder seems up there with the suggestions that are most odd. |
Roles yes but I see plenty of similar attributes all be it of different experience and quality. There's no natural back-up to Judge and Nydam is good with the ball at his feet, quick on the turn with a low centre of gravity and likes to get forward. I think this would be a good spot for him. No chance he's getting a regular run of games in those central spots and he's now third choice left back. It's hardly a big leap converting a central midfielder to a slightly more advanced attacking midfielder - think you're being a touch melodramatic. [Post edited 12 Jul 2019 6:14]
| |
| |
Nydam on 21:05 - Jul 11 with 2800 views | Nthsuffolkblue | "I believe the fan reaction led Evan's to intervene". Any reason to believe that? Why would he have let Hurst spend what he did on who he did but then told Hurst he couldn't make that call? Far more likely that, if Hurst wanted him to go out on loan and lined something up, Dozzell was the one to say no if anyone did. Up to the manager to persuade the player it is in their interests really isn't it? | |
| |
| |