By continuing to use the site, you agree to our use of cookies and to abide by our Terms and Conditions. We in turn value your personal details in accordance with our Privacy Policy.
Please log in or register. Registered visitors get fewer ads.
Fairytale of New York (contains naughty words) on 12:36 - Nov 19 by The_Romford_Blue
Fair point.
‘Faggot’ was used as an insult in the song though. The context is a deliberate insult to the bloke in the song. To remove the word, when it’s being used as an insult deliberately just seems unnecessary.
Again though, if it is any other word that is effectively on the 'banned' list, whatever the context it's going to go - whether it be bleeped out or a differnt version used
Fairytale of New York (contains naughty words) on 13:02 - Nov 19 by Bluefish
A fair argument? It is a horrendous argument
As in fair enough that someone could say a song written in the 80s where the narrative is two people having a slanging match which includes a derogatory word was justifiable at the time it was written.
I'm not saying 'it's fair enough that that word is included', I'm saying it's fair enough to make that argument.
Just because I don't care doesn't mean I don't understand.
Fairytale of New York (contains naughty words) on 13:06 - Nov 19 by LankHenners
As in fair enough that someone could say a song written in the 80s where the narrative is two people having a slanging match which includes a derogatory word was justifiable at the time it was written.
I'm not saying 'it's fair enough that that word is included', I'm saying it's fair enough to make that argument.
Indeed. In fact if you wanted to accurately represent a slanging match between slightly unhinged alcoholics/drug addicts even in more modern times then it's a word you might use in that context. I rewatched Whiplash the other day and the amount of times the lead character gets called the 'F' word is eye watering and that was made less than a decade ago. I have no issue with the word being censored from radio play of the song, but I don't know how I feel about a blanket ban on certain offensive words in all contexts. I'm not sure you could make a film like American History X without using the 'N' word.
Fairytale of New York (contains naughty words) on 12:52 - Nov 19 by Herbivore
This is true, but in some respects I'd find it more problematic if the song just used the word "gay" as an insult. Faggott is a nasty and offensive word, but is the insult meant to be that he is gay or is she just using a nasty and offensive word? I think it's a bit of a grey area, but have no issue with it being edited if it does cause offence to the gay community.
To add a bit of further context, Pogues guitarist Philip Chevron was openly gay.
I think on the one hand a character in a song making an offensive comment - and even in 1987 I can remember faggot being controversial - is different to homophobic sloganeering. But equally I can see why people wouldn't want to hear a homophobic word every 10 minutes on the radio for the whole of December.
0
Fairytale of New York (contains naughty words) on 13:17 - Nov 19 with 1985 views
Fairytale of New York (contains naughty words) on 13:12 - Nov 19 by Herbivore
Indeed. In fact if you wanted to accurately represent a slanging match between slightly unhinged alcoholics/drug addicts even in more modern times then it's a word you might use in that context. I rewatched Whiplash the other day and the amount of times the lead character gets called the 'F' word is eye watering and that was made less than a decade ago. I have no issue with the word being censored from radio play of the song, but I don't know how I feel about a blanket ban on certain offensive words in all contexts. I'm not sure you could make a film like American History X without using the 'N' word.
We are a million miles away though by comparing historically sognificant films and Christmas tunes. Again the bigger issue is not the word being in there, the bigger issue is people getting upset about it being removed. I don't really mind either way. If the word f*** was in an old song it would be removed today
Fairytale of New York (contains naughty words) on 13:15 - Nov 19 by PhilTWTD
To add a bit of further context, Pogues guitarist Philip Chevron was openly gay.
I think on the one hand a character in a song making an offensive comment - and even in 1987 I can remember faggot being controversial - is different to homophobic sloganeering. But equally I can see why people wouldn't want to hear a homophobic word every 10 minutes on the radio for the whole of December.
Fairytale of New York (contains naughty words) on 13:15 - Nov 19 by PhilTWTD
To add a bit of further context, Pogues guitarist Philip Chevron was openly gay.
I think on the one hand a character in a song making an offensive comment - and even in 1987 I can remember faggot being controversial - is different to homophobic sloganeering. But equally I can see why people wouldn't want to hear a homophobic word every 10 minutes on the radio for the whole of December.
Fairytale of New York (contains naughty words) on 12:29 - Nov 19 by itfcjoe
It's a word that is now offensive, there is a version of it without that word in it - why not just use that one?
If a Xmas song had the N word in it from years ago you surely wouldn't expect it to go out in the day on the radio?
It's a fckuing good song. Leave it at that. Jesus 2020, what a time to be alive. Get a blo0dy life. People on this site, just looking for the next PC thing to jump on.
-4
Fairytale of New York (contains naughty words) on 13:25 - Nov 19 with 1943 views
Fairytale of New York (contains naughty words) on 13:17 - Nov 19 by Bluefish
We are a million miles away though by comparing historically sognificant films and Christmas tunes. Again the bigger issue is not the word being in there, the bigger issue is people getting upset about it being removed. I don't really mind either way. If the word f*** was in an old song it would be removed today
I agree that anyone being upset about it being removed needs to give their head a wobble and it definitely shouldn't be in pre-watershed.
Fairytale of New York (contains naughty words) on 13:24 - Nov 19 by MonkeyAlan
It's a fckuing good song. Leave it at that. Jesus 2020, what a time to be alive. Get a blo0dy life. People on this site, just looking for the next PC thing to jump on.
It's not the people on this site. There's been no hysteria and culture warriors on here from what I've seen
Fairytale of New York (contains naughty words) on 13:06 - Nov 19 by LankHenners
As in fair enough that someone could say a song written in the 80s where the narrative is two people having a slanging match which includes a derogatory word was justifiable at the time it was written.
I'm not saying 'it's fair enough that that word is included', I'm saying it's fair enough to make that argument.
Fairytale of New York (contains naughty words) on 13:24 - Nov 19 by MonkeyAlan
It's a fckuing good song. Leave it at that. Jesus 2020, what a time to be alive. Get a blo0dy life. People on this site, just looking for the next PC thing to jump on.
Erm, you're the only person that seems angry about this.
By continuing to use the site, you agree to our use of cookies and to abide by our Terms and Conditions.
