Please log in or register. Registered visitors get fewer ads.
Forum index | Previous Thread | Next thread
Summer signings so far 20:43 - Nov 12 with 648 viewsitfc1108

Just for a bit of fun. I thought I would rate and put in order how I think our summer signings have done so far, out of ten.
There seems a few too many who seem to have done about average, or below.

1. Bonne 8.5/10
2. Burns 8/10
3. Chaplin. 7.5
4. Aluko. 7
5. Morsy. 7
6. Edmundson. 6.5
7. Walton 6
8. Edwards 6
9. Celina 6
10. Evans. 5.5
11. Penney. 5
12. Fraser. 5
13. Burgess. 4.5
14. Harper. 4.5
14. Coulson 4
15. Pigott. 4
16. Hladky. 3
17. Carroll. 2
18. Barry. 2
0
Summer signings so far on 20:46 - Nov 12 with 608 viewsJ2BLUE

Really harsh on some of those. This isn't like the Evans era where we signed the likes of Coke out of desperation. Pigott, Carroll, Barry all being kept out of the team by genuinely good players.

Penney should be rated higher. Many were underwhelmed but he has gone well. Celina only now fully fit. Burgess 4.5? Harsh.

Poll: How will you feel if Neil Harris is appointed manager? 1=gutted 10=ecstatic

1

Summer signings so far on 20:49 - Nov 12 with 585 viewsitfc1108

Summer signings so far on 20:46 - Nov 12 by J2BLUE

Really harsh on some of those. This isn't like the Evans era where we signed the likes of Coke out of desperation. Pigott, Carroll, Barry all being kept out of the team by genuinely good players.

Penney should be rated higher. Many were underwhelmed but he has gone well. Celina only now fully fit. Burgess 4.5? Harsh.


I was trying to take into account transfer fee etc, but I probably have been a bit harsh there, even though I stand by the order of players.
[Post edited 12 Nov 2021 21:03]
0
Summer signings so far on 20:51 - Nov 12 with 577 viewschrismakin

I couldn't be bothered to reorder them but my ratings are below

1. Bonne 9
2. Burns 9
3. Chaplin. 8
4. Aluko. 7
5. Morsy. 8
6. Edmundson. 8
7. Walton 7
8. Edwards 5.5
9. Celina 7
10. Evans. 7
11. Penney. 7
12. Fraser. 7
13. Burgess. 5
14. Harper. 5
14. Coulson 3
15. Pigott. 7
16. Hladky. 2
17. Carroll. 2
18. Barry. 1

Never be afraid to share your thoughts.
Poll: As TWTD polls influence Ashton.. what should he have for breakfast tomorrow?
Blog: We Need to Go Back to the Past to Go Forwards

0


Please log in or register. Registered visitors get fewer ads.
About Us Contact Us Terms & Conditions Privacy Cookies Advertising
© TWTD 1995-2022