3-5-2 21:45 - Aug 19 with 3403 views | Ipswich24 | I would like to see us go with 3-5-2 now we appear to have wing backs who can get up and down, think we have the players plus Doncien and Kenlock need to be dropped. can then get Skuse as the sweeper and get Downes and Huws together in midfield. Can then get Judge/Rowe in their favored position. What do we all think? GK- Holy CB- Chambers CB Skuse CB Woolfenden RWB Vincent-Young LWB Georgiou CM Downes CM Huws AM Rowe CF Norwood CF Jackson Subs Norris Judge Dozzell El Mizoni Wilson Edwards Roberts | |
| | |
3-5-2 on 21:48 - Aug 19 with 2745 views | StokieBlue | You've based an entirely formation around two wing-backs you've not seen, one of whom isn't universally accepted as a wing back I believe? You've dropped Skuse, arguably our best player thus far this season. You've played Rowe as a central midfielder when he's a winger and never played there for us I believe and you've left Judge on the bench when that's his apparent best position. Why do we need to change everything given we've started reasonably with a depleted squad against other promotion contenders? SB [Post edited 19 Aug 2019 21:49]
| |
| Avatar - IC410 - Tadpoles Nebula |
| |
3-5-2 on 21:48 - Aug 19 with 2738 views | Herbivore | Nope. | |
| |
3-5-2 on 21:49 - Aug 19 with 2738 views | Marshalls_Mullet |
3-5-2 on 21:48 - Aug 19 by StokieBlue | You've based an entirely formation around two wing-backs you've not seen, one of whom isn't universally accepted as a wing back I believe? You've dropped Skuse, arguably our best player thus far this season. You've played Rowe as a central midfielder when he's a winger and never played there for us I believe and you've left Judge on the bench when that's his apparent best position. Why do we need to change everything given we've started reasonably with a depleted squad against other promotion contenders? SB [Post edited 19 Aug 2019 21:49]
|
He hasnt dropped skuse. Chill out bro, he just made a suggestion. | |
| |
3-5-2 on 21:50 - Aug 19 with 2730 views | StokieBlue |
3-5-2 on 21:49 - Aug 19 by Marshalls_Mullet | He hasnt dropped skuse. Chill out bro, he just made a suggestion. |
True - I didn't even notice him in defence because removing him from CM given how he has played was just odd. SB | |
| Avatar - IC410 - Tadpoles Nebula |
| |
3-5-2 on 21:51 - Aug 19 with 2720 views | StokieBlue |
3-5-2 on 21:49 - Aug 19 by Marshalls_Mullet | He hasnt dropped skuse. Chill out bro, he just made a suggestion. |
<Doubled> SB [Post edited 19 Aug 2019 21:51]
| |
| Avatar - IC410 - Tadpoles Nebula |
| |
3-5-2 on 21:51 - Aug 19 with 2717 views | Marshalls_Mullet |
3-5-2 on 21:50 - Aug 19 by StokieBlue | True - I didn't even notice him in defence because removing him from CM given how he has played was just odd. SB |
He has also been suited at CB in a three on occasions. Not saying I agree with his personnel, but I do like 3-5-2, and think it could work for us. | |
| |
3-5-2 on 22:00 - Aug 19 with 2661 views | Herbivore |
3-5-2 on 21:51 - Aug 19 by Marshalls_Mullet | He has also been suited at CB in a three on occasions. Not saying I agree with his personnel, but I do like 3-5-2, and think it could work for us. |
Has he ever even played a full competitive game at CB? I don't think it's the system for this squad. | |
| | Login to get fewer ads
3-5-2 on 22:01 - Aug 19 with 2656 views | Marshalls_Mullet |
3-5-2 on 22:00 - Aug 19 by Herbivore | Has he ever even played a full competitive game at CB? I don't think it's the system for this squad. |
Not sure he has, but when he has played there he has played very well. It wasnt my suggestion, I am just saying I can see where the OP was coming from. ...and I like 3-5-2. Happy to agree to differ. | |
| |
3-5-2 on 22:07 - Aug 19 with 2643 views | Herbivore |
3-5-2 on 22:01 - Aug 19 by Marshalls_Mullet | Not sure he has, but when he has played there he has played very well. It wasnt my suggestion, I am just saying I can see where the OP was coming from. ...and I like 3-5-2. Happy to agree to differ. |
I think he played there once for part of a competitive game and then once for part of a preseason game. That's scant evidence of him being a CB really. Why move him out of position when he's started the season well? I don't get the obsession with 3-5-2, it seems to be based on us using it well 20 years ago. | |
| |
3-5-2 on 22:08 - Aug 19 with 2634 views | Marshalls_Mullet |
3-5-2 on 22:07 - Aug 19 by Herbivore | I think he played there once for part of a competitive game and then once for part of a preseason game. That's scant evidence of him being a CB really. Why move him out of position when he's started the season well? I don't get the obsession with 3-5-2, it seems to be based on us using it well 20 years ago. |
Agree to differ bro. Dont have a heart attack. | |
| |
3-5-2 on 22:10 - Aug 19 with 2632 views | PJH |
3-5-2 on 22:00 - Aug 19 by Herbivore | Has he ever even played a full competitive game at CB? I don't think it's the system for this squad. |
Yes, and very well at Sheffield United last season. (I assume we are talking about Skuse). | | | |
3-5-2 on 22:14 - Aug 19 with 2616 views | Herbivore |
3-5-2 on 22:08 - Aug 19 by Marshalls_Mullet | Agree to differ bro. Dont have a heart attack. |
How patronising. | |
| |
3-5-2 on 22:15 - Aug 19 with 2610 views | Marshalls_Mullet |
3-5-2 on 22:14 - Aug 19 by Herbivore | How patronising. |
If you say so dear. | |
| |
3-5-2 on 22:19 - Aug 19 with 2599 views | Herbivore |
3-5-2 on 22:10 - Aug 19 by PJH | Yes, and very well at Sheffield United last season. (I assume we are talking about Skuse). |
He didn't start there from memory, he moved back there during the game. And we were played off the park that day. I'm not sure that one occasion is reason to shift him to CB. | |
| |
3-5-2 on 22:22 - Aug 19 with 2591 views | TractorJack |
3-5-2 on 22:07 - Aug 19 by Herbivore | I think he played there once for part of a competitive game and then once for part of a preseason game. That's scant evidence of him being a CB really. Why move him out of position when he's started the season well? I don't get the obsession with 3-5-2, it seems to be based on us using it well 20 years ago. |
It's bizarre. I beg anyone calling for it to go back and watch the first halves of Brentford and Reading at home and Sheff United away, all absolutely awful. At least we don't get constant suggestions to play 4-4-2 anymore. | | | |
3-5-2 on 22:24 - Aug 19 with 2576 views | Marshalls_Mullet |
3-5-2 on 22:22 - Aug 19 by TractorJack | It's bizarre. I beg anyone calling for it to go back and watch the first halves of Brentford and Reading at home and Sheff United away, all absolutely awful. At least we don't get constant suggestions to play 4-4-2 anymore. |
We are no longer in the Championship playing against that calibre of team. | |
| |
3-5-2 on 22:27 - Aug 19 with 2565 views | Herbivore |
3-5-2 on 22:24 - Aug 19 by Marshalls_Mullet | We are no longer in the Championship playing against that calibre of team. |
But they were some of our worst performances last season, so why utilise that formation now? | |
| |
3-5-2 on 22:31 - Aug 19 with 2550 views | Marshalls_Mullet |
3-5-2 on 22:27 - Aug 19 by Herbivore | But they were some of our worst performances last season, so why utilise that formation now? |
Because we are in a different league, in a different position, with some different personnel. I am not saying we have to use it, I am just saying I wouldnt be against it. Thats OK. | |
| |
3-5-2 on 00:33 - Aug 20 with 2462 views | lmfcblue | not enough pace in Chambers and Skuse for 3 at the back | | | |
3-5-2 on 07:10 - Aug 20 with 2341 views | BlueBadger | We don't have enough full-backs or fit centre halves to play that system. Or, if there's any injuries, enough centre forward, either. | |
| |
3-5-2 on 07:25 - Aug 20 with 2309 views | PJH |
3-5-2 on 22:19 - Aug 19 by Herbivore | He didn't start there from memory, he moved back there during the game. And we were played off the park that day. I'm not sure that one occasion is reason to shift him to CB. |
He did start there. I remember thinking after a minute or two that Skuse was playing very deep and then realised that he was supposed to be. He had Chambers one side of him and Nsiala the other with Bree and Kenlock playing as wingbacks, it was a genuine 3-5-2 from the start. | | | |
3-5-2 on 07:32 - Aug 20 with 2294 views | Herbivore |
3-5-2 on 07:25 - Aug 20 by PJH | He did start there. I remember thinking after a minute or two that Skuse was playing very deep and then realised that he was supposed to be. He had Chambers one side of him and Nsiala the other with Bree and Kenlock playing as wingbacks, it was a genuine 3-5-2 from the start. |
And we got overrun. I thought he moved back there from the base of the diamond after Keane came off for Chalobah early in the game. I don't remember him starting there. Either way, it didn't exactly work. [Post edited 20 Aug 2019 7:34]
| |
| |
3-5-2 on 08:26 - Aug 20 with 2226 views | PJH |
3-5-2 on 07:32 - Aug 20 by Herbivore | And we got overrun. I thought he moved back there from the base of the diamond after Keane came off for Chalobah early in the game. I don't remember him starting there. Either way, it didn't exactly work. [Post edited 20 Aug 2019 7:34]
|
I did not say that it worked necessarily, I just said that Skuse personally played very well there-which he did. | | | |
3-5-2 on 08:43 - Aug 20 with 2190 views | 44_not_out |
3-5-2 on 21:48 - Aug 19 by StokieBlue | You've based an entirely formation around two wing-backs you've not seen, one of whom isn't universally accepted as a wing back I believe? You've dropped Skuse, arguably our best player thus far this season. You've played Rowe as a central midfielder when he's a winger and never played there for us I believe and you've left Judge on the bench when that's his apparent best position. Why do we need to change everything given we've started reasonably with a depleted squad against other promotion contenders? SB [Post edited 19 Aug 2019 21:49]
|
His mum has banned him from FIFA for the rest of the school holidays. | | | |
| |