Please log in or register. Registered visitors get fewer ads.
Clattenburg: Law Needs Changing
Monday, 31st Aug 2026 11:07

Former Premier League referee Mark Clattenburg believes the law relating to handball needs changing following Manchester United’s controversial second goal against the Blues at Old Trafford yesterday.

Harry Maguire clearly handled the ball in the build-up but because his shot was off target and Jacob Greaves inadvertently diverted it into his own net, the law dictates that the handball - if accidental, which in this instance is debatable given Maguire’s raised hands - should be disregarded.

“The key point is that the ball which was not goal bound went in off Ipswich defender Jacob Greaves, rather than directly off Maguire. So it was ultimately treated as an own goal, not a Maguire goal,” Clattenburg told United in Focus.

“Under the handball law, an accidental handball by an attacking player isn’t automatically an offence in the build-up unless the player himself scores directly (or immediately after the hand/arm touch, depending on the circumstances).

“Since the final touch was by Greaves, VAR judged there wasn’t grounds to disallow it.

“So, basically, Maguire’s hand may have touched it, but because Greaves supplied the final touch, the goal could stand.

“And yes – it looks bizarre, because if Maguire’s touch had been the final touch, the outcome could have been different.

“The law needs changing because this seems unfair and not in spirit of how the law is written.”

Photo: IMAGO/Sportimage via Reuters Connect



Please report offensive, libellous or inappropriate posts by using the links provided.



Len_Brennan added 11:13 - Aug 31
Turns out that my understanding of the word 'accidental' has been wrong for the last 50 years.
51

muccletonjoe added 11:13 - Aug 31
It is completely laughable for a professional sport
32

chorltonskylineblue added 11:24 - Aug 31
Clattenburg exemplifying what is wrong with the direction of refereeing. He focuses on the wording of the law and it being a goal because it was a deflection, which is what VAR focused on as well. Watch the highlights back and you will see that Craig Pawson has a clear sight of Maguire handling the ball, but decides not to penalise it. Any unbiased viewer will judge that the handball was not accidental. The game should have been stopped at that point.

To be clear, we were already losing our defensive shape at that stage, but it definitely put the wind in United's sails.
21

Stato added 11:30 - Aug 31
If Greaves had handled the ball in exactly the same manner a penalty would of been given because his hands were in an unnatural position. Regardless of law being right or wrong why has there been no challenge to the narrative that it was accidental handball. In reverse its a pen and Gary Neville would of gone made at VAR if pen not given. Very unlucky for town and for Greaves
13

peckam added 11:31 - Aug 31
Dermot Gallagher on Sky this morning said it wasn’t even a deliberate handball in his opinion!!??!!
Old boys club of refs again.
That would be given a handball all day if it was the visiting team to Old Trafford. 1000%
Shocking decision.
14

Global_Blue added 11:33 - Aug 31
"Hang on lads, that ball is going over my head so let me just bang the ball down from chest height with both my arms so that it falls into the path of my feet and I'm able to score easily. Obviously, it's not handball as I always run around with my hands in front of my chest like that, so they're in a completely natural position!"

Ref and VAR "yeah, OK, that sounds totally fine to me given you're a Man U player and obviously the established big 6 deserve the benefit of the doubt".

It's an utterly ridiculous decision and completely indefensible. I may have drunk too much from the keg of conspiracy, but I remember the Conor Chaplin incident when we played Leicester in the PL a couple of years ago. The Leicester player barged into Chappers without even attempting to play the ball and it was as clear a penalty as you'll ever see. But the ref said it was a "coming together". That and a few other dodgy decisions led to Mark Ashton soeaking to the head of the Match Officials about unfair treatment. I hope we're not going to see a repeat of those decisions that 'unfortunately' go against the smaller/newer PL teams. They cost us too many points last time and we can't afford a repeat.
10

Bluemike31 added 11:34 - Aug 31
Anyone thinking that goal should stand is a fool.
12

RIPbobby added 11:35 - Aug 31
I think this can be simplified completely when asking the question "when is handball, handball?"

The answers "always"

F@ck off to did he intend to do it? Who cares handball is handball always.
7

grow_our_own added 11:35 - Aug 31
Agreed Len_Brennan. Maguire knew what he was doing. Yes hands were within his body silhouette, but he put them out in front of him bc he knew if ball hit his chest instead it would have skidded over his shoulder, and Akpom would have had the break-away. Maguire effectively patted the ball downwards with his hands to create the chance. Goal should have been disallowed under the current rules bc it was deliberate.
8

Trequartista added 11:36 - Aug 31
There is still no clarity at all regarding if VAR looked at the handball and decided it was accidental (i.e. not a foul) or if it didn't look at the handball and took the referee's verdict.

They seem to be concentrating on the own goal / direct shot ruling to deflect attention from this.

Can anyone answer this? Is anyone pursuing it?
4

heavyweight added 11:39 - Aug 31
As the law is written currently, i dont understand what sort of own-goal scenario they are trying to allow a goal to stand?
2

Town1Inter0 added 11:40 - Aug 31
Just like two years ago we know that big referee and VAR decisions will favour the big clubs. Disgraceful.
2

Lightningboy added 11:44 - Aug 31
Football has tied itself up in knots over recent years what with over fussy VAR decisions and idiots running/ruining the game who don't know what stupid rule change to come up with next.

It needs to get back to where it was 30 years ago..keep it simple,let the ref,ref..and absolute minimal interference from some bloke sitting in a portacabin 200 miles away.

Am amazed that there aren't protests/chants from all fans at every ground to get rid of this var nonsense.
4

jas0999 added 11:49 - Aug 31
Absolutely laughable, but under the current laws it was a goal. However ridiculous that is. The rule needs to be changed.

Still no defending how we folded like a pack of cards after that. As GON says, much to do on the mentality side of the game. We will have lots of decisions go against us this year amd need to be mentally tough enough to deal with it. We weren’t yesterday.
3

bluesince76 added 11:53 - Aug 31
Var didnt lose us the game its the same rule for every team we played well for a newly put together team think well have enough to stay up but need 2 or 3 more.
0

TimmyH added 12:01 - Aug 31
It really is the most ridiculous rule with NO common sense attached...notice how Gary Neville always the pundit to kick off on absurd rulings or anything football hardly mentioned how ridiculous it was for that goal to stand.
6

Tedray added 12:05 - Aug 31
Not only do we have to overcome the opposing team we also have to fight the "system" just like last time.The big teams are always seemingly given a lifeline against a "smaller" team when needed .However bad mistake on our part that we could go there and play an open game against them. Should have been realistic and have had a much more defensive set up. Surprised at Gary regarding this.
2

bluebullet29l added 12:06 - Aug 31
Bloody right it does...absolutely disgusting...basically saying its not cheating to handle the ball. Especially if its man utd.
3

ThaiBlue added 12:21 - Aug 31
The decision is a joke he handball it shoots scores it's disallowed hits greatest it's a goal i just don't get it anymore, and Dermot Gallagher is a useless excuse for a former referee he's so poor to watch.
2

ThaiBlue added 12:22 - Aug 31
Greaves
-1

bobble added 12:22 - Aug 31
If it was rugby union or cricket it would be disallowed......football is behind best practice on video checks...
1

whosroundisitanyway added 12:32 - Aug 31
Hands in a natural position ???
Maguire is a T.Rex !!!
7

ITFC_1994 added 12:43 - Aug 31
In what world is it an accidental handball... he literally lifted his hands up TO CONTROL THE BALL.

Hope Ashtons on the phone again to PGMOL again...

I said after that goal went in, they'll score a few more and everyone will say it doesn't matter anyway, but that goal changed the game completely.

I am 1000% sure if it was the other end then it wouldn't have stood. We've seen enough PL football now to know the big 6 get special treatment.

On the liverpool. COYB
4

cardinaldom88 added 12:50 - Aug 31
Whether this was accidental (debatable) or not, Maguire clearly controlled the ball with his arms which then allowed him to take a shot. It should be irrelevant whether it was on target or deflected, the fact that control of the ball was gained with use of the hand should be the determining factor not that the ball hit a defender and being an own goal.

This kind of decision does have a bearing on the game and if not allowed, it might have given the players the break needed to regroup. Instead it's a psychological blow which takes time to recover.

I have seen a number of Utd fans saying that the goal should not have been given. I was under the impression after the world cup, that this sort of goal would have been ruled out because of the way the law was meant to be applied. But now, the water is muddied because of the sub clause of diverting the ball by the defender. Its ludicrous and I agree with Clattenberg that this is not the "spirit" of the law or indeed, football.

Handball used to be so much easier to define.
3

BlueSkies added 13:21 - Aug 31
And this is why I would go all out to try and win one of the cups and bollox to the Premiershit and VAR.

And Dermot Gallagher is a knobb and always has been.
1


You need to login in order to post your comments

Blogs 300 bloggers

Ipswich Town Polls

About Us Contact Us Terms & Conditions Privacy Cookies Online Safety Advertising
© TWTD 1995-2026