Please log in or register. Registered visitors get fewer ads.
Town 1-0 Birmingham - Match Report
Saturday, 5th Aug 2017 17:02

Joe Garner got his Town career off to a goalscoring start as the former Rangers man netted a second-half debut goal to see the Blues to a 1-0 victory in their opening game of the season at Portman Road. Garner turned in a Jonas Knudsen cross five minutes after the break to win the game, however, the victory was marred by what appears to be a serious knee ligament injury sustained by Andre Dozzell just before the break.

Garner and Dominic Iorfa were given their Blues debut as Town lined-up in a surprise 3-5-2 formation.

Iorfa, on loan from Wolves for the season, started at right wing-back with Knudsen on the left and Jordan Spence, skipper Luke Chambers and Tommy Smith the central three.

In central midfield, Cole Skuse was joined by Dozzell and Grant Ward with Garner and Sears up front.

David McGoldrick and Bersant Celina were both on the bench having been ill for last week’s 6-1 friendly defeat at Charlton, while midfielders Flynn Downes, 18, and Tristan Nydam, 17, were also among the subs.

Birmingham, who lined-up 4-4-2, handed debuts to former Town loan keeper David Stockdale, who joined after turning down a new deal with Brighton, Marc Roberts, who signed from Barnsley, and Cheikh Ndoye, a recruit from Angers.

A torrential downpour preceded kick-off and rain continued to fall persistently as the game got under way.

Birmingham made most of the early running but without creating an opportunity until left-back Jonathan Grounds, a scorer in the 1-1 draw between the sides at Portman Road in April, hit a weak shot through to Bartosz Bialkowski in the fourth minute.

Soon after, as the sun broke through the clouds, Dozzell brought the ball forward from midway inside the visitors’ half but hit his effort well wide.

The Midlanders weren’t far from going in front on 10 when a long throw from Grounds on the left reached Michael Morrison, whose header was too close to Bialkowski who saved. A couple of feet either side of the keeper and Harry Redknapp’s side would have been in front.

Birmingham continued to have the better of it and just after the quarter hour right-back Emilio Nsue hit a low shot which Bialkowski claimed comfortably.

Town threatened for the first time from a Ward corner on the right. The ball eventually fell to Garner, whose shot deflected off a defender through to Stockdale.

The Blues began to get more into the game and in the 21st minute Ward, a debut hat-trick hero on the opening day a year ago, exchanged passes with Garner and broke into the area but put the ball wide from a very tight angle on the left of the area as Stockdale advanced.


On 26, following the latest in a succession of long throws from the right, Bialkowski saved Marc Roberts’s low shot from the right.

A minute later there was a further scare for the Blues when Iorfa looked to head a cross from the right behind and Knudsen, as he sought to avoid a corner, nodded the ball back to a Birmingham player on the right. Eventually it reached Che Adams on the left just outside the box, from where he curled a shot just over.

The visitors continued to look the more dangerous team and on 33 David Davis hooked a ball over as Bialkowski advanced having got in behind the backline, although Smith had looked to be fouled earlier in the build-up.

Bialkowski had to be on his mettle again in the 40th minute when Clayton Donaldson was played in on goal following a swift interchange of passes around the edge of the area, the Pole claiming at the former Crewe and Brentford striker’s feet.

Two minutes later, Dozzell played in Sears on the right of the box and the striker’s shot deflected wide.

From the corner, Dozzell went to ground clearly in pain as he battled for the ball with Adams, Birmingham keeper Stockdale immediately calling for medical staff to be allowed on to the pitch.

The midfielder underwent lengthy treatment for what's understood to be cruciate knee ligament damage - with Stockdale continuing to him morale support - before being stretchered off.

The 18-year-old, who had previously been treated for a knock a few minutes earlier, had been behind Town’s more threatening moments going forward and had been becoming more influential.

Downes replaced the England U19 international in the centre of the three-man midfield, making his senior debut.

There was just time for Donaldson to shoot wide past an empty goal with Bialkowski well off his line - an offside Adams having blocked off a Town defender as he looked to get back - before referee Tin Robinson ended the half.

The visitors had been on top for the most part and had created the half’s better opportunities.

Town had threatened only rarely with Dozzell having been behind their few chances. Concerns regarding the extent of the academy product’s injury dominated the half-time chat around Portman Road.

Birmingham created the first chance of the second half from a freekick on 49, Spence having been booked for a foul on Donaldson as they chased a ball down the middle. Craig Gardner’s ball into the box was volleyed across the face of goal by Davis.

A minute later the Blues took the lead through debutant Garner. Ward fed the overlapping Knudsen down the left and the Dane sent in a low ball beyond Sears but which the summer signing from Rangers met as he ran in from wide on the right at the far post and hit low across Stockdale before celebrating in front of the Sir Bobby Robson Stand.

The goal gave Town a boost and on 58 Downes began a move which ended with Knudsen sending over a ball towards Sears which a defender did well to divert behind.

For the first time the Blues were putting the visitors under pressure and a minute later Sears saw another effort well blocked with Stockdale off his line following a corner. From subsequent flag-kicks Skuse hit a shot which deflected wide and Garner headed wide at the far post.

Gardner volleyed wide for Birmingham in the 65th minute with Town starting to lose some of their immediate post-goal impetus, although with the visitors by no means putting them under pressure.

However, on 71, Nsue forced Bialkowski to tip over his well-struck shot from a tight angle on the right.

Three minutes later, the Blues switched debutant Iorfa, who was warmly applauded off by his new fans after an all-action display, for Adam Webster.

Town should have doubled their lead in the 76th minute. After Knudsen’s cross from the left reached Spence, who broke into the area on the right and cut the ball across to Sears, who turned the ball wide when he seemed certain to score.

Ndoye headed straight at Bialkowski from a corner as the game moved towards its final five minutes.

But Town didn’t look too uncomfortable and for spells passed the ball around confidently as they sought to see out the game.

On 87, with Smith off the field receiving a bandage to the head, Sears scraped a shot through to Stockdale from a cross from the right by the excellent Ward.

In the final minute of scheduled time Roberts was booked for pulling back Skuse after the Blues midfielder caught him in possession on the left a few yards outside the penalty area.

Town defended a corner, striker Garner making two important challenges inside the box, before referee Robinson blew his final whistle to confirm a winning start for the Blues.

Having been second best before the break, Town deserved their win based on the balance of the second and probably should have won more comfortably given the spell of pressure after the goal and the chance Sears will feel he should have taken.

There were impressive performances throughout the side, debutants Garner and Iorfa impressed their new home supporters, while Ward also caught the eye in central midfield.

Downes made a lively debut from the bench in the second half, putting in a battling display and passing tidily.

Dozzell's injury, which if as serious as feared seems certain to keep him out for most if not all of the rest of the season, was the only minus on what was otherwise a day with plenty of pluses for the Blues.

Town: Bialkowski, Spence, Chambers (c), Smith, Iorfa (Webster 74), Ward, Skuse, Dozzell (Downes 45), Knudsen, Sears, Garner. Unused: Gerken, McGoldrick, Celina, Nydam, Kenlock.

Birmingham: Stockdale, Nsue, Grounds, Morrison (c), Roberts, Davis, Gardner, Ndoye, Maghoma (Keita 79), Donaldson, Adams. Unused: Kuszczak, Shotton, Kieftenbeld, Brock-Madsen, Harding, Gleeson. Referee: Tim Robinson (West Sussex). Att: 18,153 (Birmingham: 2,012).


Photo: TWTD



Please report offensive, libellous or inappropriate posts by using the links provided.



The_Romford_Blue added 17:47 - Aug 5
Fantastic performance Town.

Second half we were superb.

Skuse fantastic, Garnee MOTM, Downes looks excellent.

Chambo and smith very good. Brum wouldn't have scored in 5 years.

Bad news about Dozza.

Brilliant atmosphere throughout.

All in all, buzzing with that. Roll on Barnsley away next Saturday
6

milliem added 17:50 - Aug 5
Good evening Budgies, north Essex nonentities and all the other diddies who hang about on a website devoted to arguably the most famous team the world has ever seen.

As you can see the team the you amusingly all pretend to follow have won whereas your shower of kack haven't.

I'll leave you losers with this: Mick McCarthy, Bobby Robson and Alf Ramsey have all managed their respective national teams whereas Norwich had Mike Bassett.

-4

trevski added 17:52 - Aug 5
Great start to the season. Clean sheet, debutantes making a great start and especially to Garner for getting on the score sheet, the whole team played well (especially our home-grown youngsters). Shame to hear about Dozzell, let's hope it is not as bad as it seems so he can actually have a season this year
5

Surco72 added 17:53 - Aug 5
With the players available to MM this is a fantastic result against a well drilled defensive outfit , so we'll done to MM and TC today for 3 points and a good start to the season , keep it going with the cup game and some fitness for players
5

StokeHigh97 added 17:54 - Aug 5
Encouraging performance: First half the Back 3 looked shaky we moved the ball too slowly & we didn't give sears or garner any support or service other than in the air which both it's not there game: Dozzell injured looks bad I thought ACL straight say I hope not as that would be his season over: Second half we passed highly & when we got behind them we caused them problems: Garner worked hard nice goal in the long term he needs a better partner to link with but we all know that: Iorfa was solid & plenty second half as he saw the ball far more: he is better than Spence in a wing-Back role: for me MOTM was Downes composed on the ball loves a tackle & keeps the ball moving & looks to create, he will every game other than injury or suspension: we certainly looked to play along the ground & no where near as many hit & hope: we still need more bodies: Striker Right winger Top of the list: It was better than last season for sure: only downside Spence is poor with the ball at his feet, & Skuse is too slow:
4

midastouch added 17:54 - Aug 5
3 points in the bag, can't argue with that! Gutted for Dozzell though. I just hope this isn't the highest position we reach in the league all season! Hopefully not!
And very sorry to learn of the news of BATTYBLUE leaving this mad world behind. While I didn't know him personally I have still read and enjoyed many of his comments on here and his contributions will definitely be missed. I'm glad to hear he was ripe enough in years to have hopefully seen the good times under Sir Bobby first hand at Portman Road which some of us (me included) sadly didn't have the good fortune to experience in the flesh. RIP Battyblue.
7

TractorBeezer added 17:54 - Aug 5
A most encouraging start aside from Andre's knee injury. I watched the iFOLLOW stream minus commentary on a small screen so not easy at first to identify some players. However I thought that we generally looked more composed keeping he ball down and not giving it away too much. Defence kept it tight and kept a clean sheet. Midfield competent and confident. Nice to see Joe on a scoring streak. We could use a bit more penetration at the sharp end. Rumour is that our targeted striker is from the Prem and is known.
UTTBs
3

dirtydingusmagee added 17:56 - Aug 5
Only listened to match ,sad situation with Dozzel, puts a dampener on a decent start to the season ,impressive performance by Downes some consolation. Wont take this result at anymore than face value, Birmingham were little threat ,but pleased we have 3 points on the board well done lads .
12

Kirbmeister added 17:59 - Aug 5
Where have all the moaners from midweek gone. I guess the majority who wanted MM gone by Xmas will have to wait till the first week in january.
-9

Brownie added 17:59 - Aug 5
Echo the thoughts of all re Battyblue. This site is here to share opinions of the team we love and he did that eloquently & passionately.
I didn't know him but condolences to his family.
9

Surco72 added 18:00 - Aug 5
Just read the news about Battyblue today's game a fitting tribute, a glass will be raised tonight
7

Taricco_Fan added 18:02 - Aug 5
Good start. I hope McCarthy puts out the same team against Luton to build some momentum.
6

algarvefan added 18:10 - Aug 5
Did anyone abroad watch on ifollow, thinking of subscribing but hoping to get others views first?
Sounded like a great win full of character, well done Town & RIP Battyblue a fitting tribute for you today.
2

GiveusaWave added 18:11 - Aug 5
Good result. Well done to the team.
6

ipswich134 added 18:12 - Aug 5
Algarvefan
Yes I did, its average . 6/10
1

BlueMachines added 18:17 - Aug 5
With 2 of our better midfielders out injured this is a good start. Well done Town
1

ChestnutSe added 18:21 - Aug 5
Well done Town. Great to see Garner score. Excellent in the air and knows where the goal is, just what we have needed for a while. Great performance from the defence, Chambo was outstanding. Downes looked very comfortable when he came on and looked sharp and combatative. Great start, just what the doctor ordered.

I fully expect a completely different 11 for Tuesdays meaningless cup game with MM using it as a chance to get some fitness into the other squad players. So I won't get too upset I feel we don't win 10-0
0

Dissboyitfc added 18:25 - Aug 5
A good result, 3 points to kick the season off. i am sure much bigger tests to come! Well done to all.

Sad news about Battyblue, I didnt know him, a valued voice on the site and a true blue. R.I.P

Wishing Andre Dozzell a speedy recovery!

One final thought, i wonder why a few of the MM lovers are trying to stir up ill feeling! We won and that on the opening day is what matters most.
10

Wonky added 18:31 - Aug 5
Not too many replies on here can only me one thing, we won a game!. Coyb!.
0

warktheline added 18:50 - Aug 5
Great to get off to a winning start! Always love a clean sheet! Very early days nonetheless ! Well said TimmyH and blue boy , very sorry to hear such sad news! I salute you battyblue👍
5

dirtydingusmagee added 18:58 - Aug 5
ChestnutSe, I disagree ,the cup match is not meaningless, turn clock back to last seasons debacle with Lincoln ,everything went totally t#ts up from that low point .We should be competing for everything in every game league or cup trying to create and maintain a winning attitude ,McCarthy in the past has not shown any serious interest in cup matches and look what has happened ,hopefully after last seasons outcome he will change his attitude ,and strive to get a winning mentality instilled in the team.That and fact that supporters pay good money to go to the matches , that should be respected.
6

martin587 added 19:01 - Aug 5
Welcome three points,Few good plus signs from some players.Great to see a big crowd get behind the team.Just hope A D is not too serious as he looked good today and was pulling the strings in midfield.Also good to see J G get off the mark.Well done lads.
2

johnno added 19:01 - Aug 5
Well that was a bonus good hard fought win ,just get our 2 midfielders back a target man alongside Garner and another wiseman and another defender we could be a surprise package you never know this time next year we could be millionaires
1

Orraman added 19:02 - Aug 5
Knudsen the weakest link today although his pass into the box for Garner's goal was worthy of his inclusion. Thought the much maligned Cole Skuse was MOM breaking up many Brummie moves and getting forward much more often. I have always been a big Skuse fan and now without the need to cover for different class Dougie and having better ball playing midfielders alongside him, we will see much more of his value to the team. Good start and definitely hope for the future if youngsters continue to get chances. Such a cruel turn of fate for Andre......hope it's not too long a recovery
4

dirtydingusmagee added 19:04 - Aug 5
RIP Battyblue .
5


You need to login in order to post your comments

Blogs 297 bloggers

Ipswich Town Polls

About Us Contact Us Terms & Conditions Privacy Cookies Advertising
© TWTD 1995-2024