Please log in or register
Forum
Reply
So this player in addition to Pringle
at 14:36 11 Feb 2016

I'll go for Neil Kilkenny or Dean Whitehead
Forum
Reply
pep guardiola conflict of interest
at 15:56 9 Feb 2016

indeed, If anything Pep will want to prove just how good a manager he is and get City fans licking their lips at the prospect of him becoming manager (more so if Bayern end up knocking out City).

City understand Pelligrini is still under contract, as is Guardiola so I don't really see where a problem would lie.
Forum
Reply
Derby boss gone
at 19:15 8 Feb 2016

What's a football club to most owners nowadays. Just a toy. Look at Charlton. No one has a strategy.
Forum
Reply
Derby, wow! (n/t)
at 19:10 8 Feb 2016

His biggest mistake came after the game against Reading. They drew 1-1 after going on a great winning run and Clement was scathing about his players.

Saying how they were second to everything, lacked motivation, were weak ect. They lost 3-0 to Birmingham the next week and things went downhill from there.
Forum
Reply
Friday Music Thread - Queens, Parks, Rangers & Larndon
at 20:58 5 Feb 2016

Forum
Reply
Who is the most out-and-out target man we've had?
at 16:49 3 Feb 2016

Shefki? Or is that doing a disservice?
Forum
Reply
Wolves fans on Foley
at 11:22 2 Feb 2016

I was thinking this when I saw him join, I think he's a solid acquisition. He was one of the standout players for Mick at Wolves and scored a couple of goals too. Him and Stephen Ward both did quite well around that time from full back. I think its more a case of him arriving at a time when everyone's a bit fed up of our transfer policy.
Forum
Reply
Popular wedding songs!!!!
at 01:10 2 Feb 2016

Forum
Reply
Everyone is entitled to their opinion on MM / ME
at 21:11 28 Jan 2016

Exactly what I was thinking. Well put.
Forum
Reply
James Alabi's contract mutually terminated
at 17:29 28 Jan 2016

Points taken, but by the same token you have to give a bit of Leigh way to players, particularly when they're younger and not as quite as developed as others. When a first team player is injured or suspended its rare the younger/fringe player will get picked by Mick.

I can only think of Emmanuel for about 2 games albeit we hardly had any defenders fit. Also Bishop who unfortunately has been out. I know its hindsight, but would we have done much worse by playing a McDonnell instead of Coke, or even instead of Douglas at times?

As for the Pompey game, Mick knew who he would play against Birmingham regardless of who played well at Pompey. Its easy for a manager to say 'chance to impress' and all of us to buy it. We need to take our fans hat off at times, some players must feel demoralised.
Forum
Reply
James Alabi's contract mutually terminated
at 16:51 28 Jan 2016

Well true, but you cant deny that MM doesn't exactly take risks in terms of giving a player a run of games. Most players who are fringe or young only really get a chance for about 2 games and if they do badly they don't get a chance for months on end.

I'm not saying its all MM's fault but how can you do well when only given a game or two to shine. I'd imagine if you constantly play u21 football and then just get drafted in for cup games to rest first teamers you would lack a bit of motivation. Thinking from a players perspective you'd feel a bit used.
Forum
Reply
James Alabi's contract mutually terminated
at 16:42 28 Jan 2016

I'm not saying this to be controversial in any way, just asking the question. But do you think with Oar leaving, other players have less of a reluctance to speak to MM about wanting to leave, and that some players are getting a bit disgruntled that they only really get picked for cup games?
Forum
Reply
4-4 - buggar (n/t)
at 14:49 23 Jan 2016

Not sure they would care about the match statistics when the game had 9 goals
Forum
Reply
4-4 - buggar (n/t)
at 14:39 23 Jan 2016

That ones on the old football classics on skysports in 5 years time
Forum
Reply
Yay, scousers taken lead at Carrot Rd :)
at 13:48 23 Jan 2016

I know, which is pretty puzzling. Perhaps its just a confidence thing.
Forum
Reply
Yay, scousers taken lead at Carrot Rd :)
at 13:45 23 Jan 2016

I would be astonished if Mingolet is their first team keeper next season, very indecisive.
Forum
Reply
M'boro in for Matt Philips and McCormack
at 19:11 21 Jan 2016

Burnley didn't spend much, Brentford went very close but didn't spend much, Hulls main signing when they tried to go up was Prochwitz and he wasn't the best. What about Rhodes £12m McCormack £11m or whatever it was, Assombalonga £8m?

Teams like Southampton signed Lambert from Bristol Rovers, Adam Lallana came through the youth system, Schneiderlin played for them in League 2. Harry Arter cost £6k.

If were speaking historically then we have to mention how smart some of these clubs have been with their purchases and youth system and not just signing people for big money.

Middlesbrough spent a lot when Strachan was their and that didn't go well. Its too simplistic to say what you're saying.
[Post edited 21 Jan 19:17]
Forum
Reply
M'boro in for Matt Philips and McCormack
at 18:38 21 Jan 2016

Fair points but then comparing the likes of Palace and Leicester for me is unfair on them as they spent very wisely. Middlesbrough, Derby ect is a different argument as they have spent much more and are difficult to compete with on a financial level.

I wouldn't say Palace or Leicester spent the type of money to get out of the league they just spent it more efficiently than other clubs vying to go up. Palace also went up because of how good their youth system is and their ability to bring talent into their first team squad. Something we don't do particularly well.

I bet if you went down the league other clubs would have spent similarly to Palace and Leicester but bought players who didn't do well. This debate is a two sided coin, neither of us are wrong.
Forum
Reply
M'boro in for Matt Philips and McCormack
at 16:57 21 Jan 2016

Its different, if you have the money to buy a Cabaye for a workmanlike side on £60k a week your generally bound to improve it.

The Championship is a different kettle of fish, you can buy a player on a small fee or free transfer and they can prove to be great assets and really improve the team. Birmingham have hardly spent anything and they're achieving good things.

This could go on all night really, Leicester spent nothing on Mahrez and Vardy but they've been outstanding whilst Liverpool have spent £32m on Benteke who cant get in the side. Sterling, Suarez and Sturridge only cost £35m between them which is hardly excessive and Southampton's net profit for incoming transfers cant be a lot.

Are Man Utd having success giving what they've spent on Di Maria, Mata ect. Not really.
Forum
Reply
I'd like to see on sat
at 16:42 21 Jan 2016

Thats going to work playing how we play?
Please log in to use all the site's facilities

Edmunds5


Site Scores

Forum Votes: 609
Comment Votes: 13
Prediction League: 8
TOTAL: 630
About Us Contact Us Terms & Conditions Privacy Cookies Advertising
© TWTD 1995-2016 hosted by FastHosts