If he could find his form from the first 16 games of last season I'd take him in a heart beat

I'd take him so a rival does not get him. Also, give him a contract til the end of the season, who knows!

Get him in,but only as an impact sub. Its a 16 player game, so we need the strongest bench possible for the run-in.

Not for me. We need as close to a sure thing as we can get. Not the time to take a punt. I have faith in Mark Ashton. He is a proper sound businessman and has done really well for us in previous transfer windows.

Can't believe we haven't had any contact with him, we must have been the first club his agent called. I wonder why his form dropped off last season. Too much partying with his old friends probably... If he seriously want to play and can forget the party, I'd say I great player addition if only to the end of the season..
With Wickham as well think we win the league...

Being a town fan maybe he can help jeopardise sheff Wednesday promotion push

As they say on here no point in signing anyone who's any better than we've already got. Won't be satisfied until Harry Kane walks through the door.

Surely worth a punt.

Sorry, wont be popular but not for me. We need someone who will provide an uplift in quality from what we have, and we have freddie scoring goals, on track for far more this season than MB got last. He didnt play well in KM sides last season, I cant think for a moment this would be anything more than a sentimental backwards step. QPR havent even tried to get him a club, sell him, they've just paid him off to get him off their books. We need to be bringing in people who will not only create value in L1, but have the ability to make a mark in the leagues above, like Whittaker, Taylor, yes they are going to command a premium fee but we have resources. If its isnt significantly better than we have, forget it

Spot on Bazza someone talking sense on here blimey what ever next. Im not into this he's one of our own baloney. People who want him back probably his drinking mate's.

I believe he and his wife had a very tragic event in their lives whilst he was here so maybe that's why his form dipped off. Best of luck Macauley where ever you end up, thanks for your efforts when you were here.

Linkboy13 you are the only one on here banging on about Harry Kane! Perhaps you think that you improve the team by signing players who are worse than the ones we have already? I don't agree. Or perhaps you just want to sign players for squad padding?

No, too many personal problems going on which affected his form.

Bluesteel if he was capable of finding that form again…..we would have signed in the summer.
And he'd start for QPR now.
Another one for Col U IMO.

Get him in

I thought he was ok. He was certainly a fan as well as a decent player. would be a risk to sign him rather than the proven goal scorer we need right now.

Ray Crawford is polishing his boots as we read the comments

Give me Bonne any day over Jackson. Short term contract surely a no brainer.

Steelmonkey. Yes you're correct about his dip in form coinciding with a family tragedy.
I'm glad that at least one other person remembered and mentioned this sad fact.
He wasn't out ‘drinking with his mates' as some have suggested.

Totally agree with Bazza.

Wish him well though but not to well if goes to Sheff Wed.

If they can get him for a decent wage don't pay over the odds good for squad need someone else as well not just him !

Sign him up I say . He has unfinished business here 👍

Give him 6 months, would bet on him scoring more goals then Jackson and possibly Ledapo

Sign him. Nothing to lose. Yes his form dropped but for a few months he proved that he can score regularly. His heart would be in it for sure.

Bonne & his partner went through possibly some of the worst things that can happen to any couple/human more than once during his time here. So the dross about him drinking with his mates really needs to stop. I wish Macaulay all the best & would fully back a proper tractor boy with heart & passion over most we have been rumoured with.