Please log in or register. Registered visitors get fewer ads.
Reading 2 v 2 Ipswich Town
Carabao Cup
Tuesday, 29th August 2023 Kick-off 20:00
Reading 2-2 Ipswich Town (1-3 on Penalties) - Match Report
Tuesday, 29th Aug 2023 22:19

Town progressed to the third round of the Carabao Cup for the first time in eight years following a 3-1 on-penalties victory over Reading after a 2-2 draw at the Madejski Stadium. Brandon Williams scored a second-minute full-debut own goal to give the Royals an early lead but Cameron Humphreys equalised in first-half injury time, the Freddie Ladapo put the Blues in front on 59 before Kelvin Ehibhatiomhan levelled three minutes from time but his teammates missed three of their penalties to see Town through.

Recent loan signing Williams was handed his full Blues debut having come on as a sub at the weekend as boss Kieran McKenna made the expected 11 changes to the team which lost 4-3 at home to Leeds in the Championship on Saturday.

Cieran Slicker, named in the Scotland U21s squad earlier in the day, was in goal with Williams at left-back, Dom Ball on the right and George Edmundson and Elkan Baggott the central defenders.

Lee Evans skippered from central midfield alongside Jack Taylor with Omari Hutchinson on the right, Marcus Harness in the centre and Cameron Humphreys on the left of the three behind striker Freddie Ladapo.

Town named a strong bench featuring Vaclav Hladky, Sam Morsy, Harry Clarke, Wes Burns, Luke Woolfenden, Kayden Jackson, Conor Chaplin, Nathan Broadhead and former Royal Sone Aluko.

Reading, who won 4-0 away against Millwall in the previous round, made eight changes from the team which lost 2-1 at Exeter in League One on Saturday with only Matty Carson, Amadou Mbengue and Caylan Vickers keeping their places.

The Royals’ starting XI had an average age of only 20 years and seven months.

Despite their youth, the home side went in front within a minute and a half of the kick-off.

Basil Tuma flicked on a Carson cross from deep on the left towards the path of Vickers eight yards from goal. Keeper Slicker dived but his outstretched arm could only push the ball onto teammate Williams and it looped into the net behind the former Manchester City man.

To some degree it was a freakish own goal but equally Williams, Slicker and Baggott, who was marking Tuma, should all have done better.

Town, in their orange away kit, quickly looked to get back on terms, Evans striking a shot from just outside the box after a corner had been cleared to him which was too close to home keeper Coniah Boyce-Clarke.

The Blues, despite one or two more shaky moments, began to take charge and on 13 Ladapo worked himself space before hitting a shot which Boyce-Clarke batted away to his left. Hutchinson subsequently wafted the ball back over from the right but past the far post.

Town continued to push and in the 22nd minute, Evans’s attempted volley was punched away by Boyce-Clarke. Taylor’s overhead kick, which was flying well wide, reached Ladapo, who looked to flick towards goal but only succeeded in catching Mbengue with a boot, causing the Reading defender to require treatment and eventually a new numberless shirt.

The Blues were seeing most of the ball but just after the half hour, Reading broke quickly - although Evans had appeared to been fouled early in the build-up, far from the first time referee Lewis Smith had surprisingly ruled against Town - and Williams did well to slide in ahead of Tivonge Rushesha to stab Vickers’s pass back to Slicker.

Within a minute, Town went close. Harness stood up a cross from the right and the ball scuffed off Ladapo’s head, taking it away from Williams at the far post.

On 37, a headed clearance dropped to Taylor 20 yards out and the former Peterborough man’s volley looped not too far wide of Boyce-Clarke’s right post.

Two minutes later, Evans was shown the first yellow card of the match for a foul on Tuma as the Royals looked to break following a Town attack. Seconds later, Humphreys joined him for a mistimed challenge on


In the 43rd minute, Hutchinson picked up possession on the right after a poor touch and played into the area to Humphreys, who probably should have had a shot but instead failed to find Ladapo with a pass.

In the final scheduled minute ahead of six added on, Hutchinson unleashed a powerful strike from just outside the box which pole-axed Carson, who after treatment was able to continue.

Reading had a spell of possession and Slicker was required to punch clear a cross, which he did, before the Blues levelled in the fifth minute of injury time.

Hutchinson skipped away from his man on the right before his cross struck first defender, looped to the far post where Humphreys chested over the line to claim his first goal of the season.

There was just time for Vickers to break into the left of the Town box and hit a shot but Edmundson stood firm and blocked.

While never at their most fluent, with the ball given away cheaply far too often, the Blues deserved to be on terms at the break having been in control for most of the half and having been the only side to manage shots on target.

The own goal was an unfortunate way to start his full debut for Williams, but the on-loan Manchester United youngster had grown in confidence as the half wore on, getting into good positions when going forward and making some important tackles.

Both sides made changes ahead of the second half, the Blue swapping Harness for Aluko, while Andy Yiadom replaced Carson for the Royals, presumably due to the effects of Hutchinson’s shot.

Eight minutes after the restart, Baggott might well have scored his first senior goal for the Blues, rising high to reach a Williams cross from the left but not getting enough on it and the ball flicked wide.

In the 57th minute, Ladapo chased a Baggott ball over the top down the middle and reached it before keeper Boyce-Clarke on the edge of the area under pressure from a defender, but was unable to get enough on it to force it over the line and the danger was cleared.

However, a minute later, the Town striker was on target, this time confidently slipping his first goal of the season under the advancing Boyce-Clarke and into the net having been played in by Evans’s inch-perfect pass between the two Reading central defenders from inside his own half. Ladapo celebrated with a dance in front of the delighted Town fans.

Just after the hour, the Blues swapped Williams, who own goal aside had a decent first senior start since December, for Clarke.

On 65, Reading swapped Jack Senga and Rushesha for Charlie Savage and former Cambridge United man Harvey Knibbs.

Eight minutes later, Hutchinson, who had been a threat down the right all match, crossed for Clarke at the far post and the sub headed down but with no Town player able to get onto it.

On 74, Reading switched Tuma for Kelvin Ehibhatiomhan, then two minutes later Michael Craig was booked for a foul on Evans on halfway.

As Town prepared to take the free-kick, Jackson, Chaplin and Broadhead took over from Hutchinson, Humphreys and Ladapo. The Wales international went to centre forward with Chaplin on the left and Jackson on the right. Four minutes later, the Royals swapped Kelvin Abrefa for Jeriel Dorsett.

Reading briefly threatened, Edmundson cutting out a low cross from the right, then stabbing away between two attackers with home skipper Tom McIntyre taking a fall on the edge of the box which failed to impress referee Smith.

The Blues had been comfortably on top in the second half with Slicker having been given a quiet half, aside from confidently clearing a couple of balls played down the middle, but in the 87th minute the Royals equalised out of nothing.

From Boyce-Clarke’s long throw down the left, Edmundson was brushed off the ball by Reading sub Ehibhatiomhan, who brought it into the area and shot across Slicker and inside the post.

The goal woke up the home fans, those that hadn’t already left, and soon afterwards Slicker was forced to tip Knibbs’s shot wide. Then, in the final scheduled minute, Yiadom flicked Vickers’s cross just wide.

Town began regain some control as the game moved into six additional minutes but with the Royals continuing to look a threat on the break.

On 94, Baggott appeared to pull up when chasing Ehibhatiomhan with what looked like a calf injury. The Indonesia international hobbled off but soon returned.

Shortly before the end, McIntyre was booked for a wild lunge on Broadhead on the touchline on the right. Evans’s free-kick was too close to Boyce-Clarke, who claimed, and referee Smith’s whistle indicated that the tie would go to penalties.

Town will be frustrated to have allowed the Royals back into it with the game looking dead and buried at 2-1, indeed, the Blues support were cheering and ole-ing their players’ passes at that stage.

But it took only one error and a clinical finish to see Reading back into the game and the home side might well have converted again following their goal.

Referee Smith opted to take the penalties at an empty end of the ground rather than in front of the Town support with Chaplin taking the first kick for the Blues and finding the corner of the net to the keeper’s right.

Knibbs took the first penalty for Reading and hit it straight down the middle to level at 1-1.

Evans netted Town’s second, belting it into the top corner beyond Boyce-Clarke’s right hand, before Slicker saved Savage’s kick to his left to put the Blues’ noses in front.

However, ex-Royal Aluko’s spot-kick, which was hit down the middle, was saved by Boyce-Clarke’s trailing leg, but Vickers, after taking an age and changing his angle of approach, blazed his penalty deep into the empty stand to keep the scores at 2-1.

Taylor confidently netted Town’s fourth kick to Boyce-Clarke’s left as the keeper dived in the other direction, before Ben Elliott sent his ball into the stand after Vickers’s to see the Blues through on penalties 3-1.

While the Blues will be delighted to go into the hat having won a rare penalty shoot-out victory, they will feel they made harder work of the tie than they ought to have done.

The win was only Town's fourth ever in a penalty shoot-out, the most recent at Peterborough Papa Johns Trophy in December 2019. Prior to that, there was a League Cup victory at Shrewsbury in 2009 and a Zenith Data Systems success in October 1991.

The draw for the third round will take place on Wednesday evening live on Sky Sports Football following the Doncaster-Everton tie from around 10.15pm.

Town are next in action against Cardiff City in the Championship at Portman Road on Saturday.

Reading: Boyce-Clarke, Abrefa (Dorsett 78), Carson (Yiadom 46), Mbengue, McIntyre (c), Craig, Senga (Savage 65), Elliott, Rushesha (Knibbs 65), Vickers, Tuma (Ehibhatiomhan 74). Unused: Button, Dean, Azeez, Harris.

Town: Slicker, Ball, Edmundson, Baggott, Williams (Clarke 61), Humphreys (Chaplin 74), Evans (c), Taylor, Harness (Aluko 46), Hutchinson (Jackson 74), Ladapo (Broadhead 74). Unused: Hladky, Woolfenden, Morsy, Burns. Referee: Lewis Smith (Wigan). Att: 7,867 (Town: 2,214).


Photo: Matchday Images



Please report offensive, libellous or inappropriate posts by using the links provided.



Kilterums added 22:23 - Aug 29
Fingers crossed for a great end to the week!
1

itfckenty added 22:26 - Aug 29
Great for the guys, bouncing back and getting some pens experience. Onto the next! COYB.
3

DerryfromBury added 22:31 - Aug 29
That was a hard listen, I'm sure it wasn't as bad to watch as it came across on radio Suffolk. Never mind its the result that counts.
6

herfie added 22:33 - Aug 29
Good to progress - but made had work of it. Far too many misplaced passes, sloppy play and poor decision making. Ball and Edmomson not first team quality.

But we won - so let’s hope for a ‘big team’ next. Failing that, NCFC!
0

ArnieM added 22:36 - Aug 29
Same problems isn’t it? Can’t finish our chances ….. can’t defend. God knows what the score would have been if Reading had actually mustered any real shots on goal.

Cardiff next : let’s gets this show back on the road….
-7

Tractor_Boy_Tommy added 22:36 - Aug 29
Great to get through but not the most convincing of wins
1

Bluearmy_81 added 22:37 - Aug 29
GE looks a total liability these days, God knows what’s happened to him. I hope we ship him out and get a quality CB in, we can’t be carrying make weights…
6

TimmyH added 22:45 - Aug 29
Reserve team playing Reading (and on paper a good one)...that's the reality so to go through even on penalties I'll take but not sure too many in the starting 11 tonight has shown they should be starting on Saturday.
2

VanDusen added 22:47 - Aug 29
Derry - it was pretty hard to watch for much of it too. But lovely to see us win a penalty shootout. Hutchinson looks like he's starting to get into gear. Lesson at the end that we can't do too much showboating when trying to run down the clock.
2

TractorfactorSteve added 22:48 - Aug 29
DerryfromBury. If you think it was a hard listen on Radio Suffolk, count your lucky stars you weren't listening to TownTV's commentary. Someone needs to sort out some radio commentating training sessions.
2

Cadiar added 23:10 - Aug 29
TractorFactorSteve, it was pretty awful, need a professional as it sounded more like hospital radio. Continuity poor, pre KO was crowd noise as at half time. Who was the ex player giving expert opinion? Very poor.
2

JCTractorboy added 23:11 - Aug 29
Should really have been out of sight tonight before we suddenly weren’t! Fridge does not look like the player he was, personally I’d keep baggott and get another cb in plus a striker (although delighted for Freddie today) and then thank god I don’t have to make the hard decisions with who we let go!
Let’s be honest though, 9 points from 12 league points and 2 cup wins, everyone would’ve taken that before season. We also went toe to toe with a strong Leeds team and on another would’ve taken something.
Roll on Saturday if you ask me.
4

MickMillsTash added 23:19 - Aug 29
What have we learnt ?
Clarke isn't a left back, Baggott looks promising, Humphries probably not best suited to left mid/wing
Some stereotypes reinforced - Evans spends too long on the ball, Edmundson has a mistake in him, Ball not the answer, Ladapo's movement....
I wanted more from Taylor and I hoped for more from Williams, but we've got another game for them to show something in
Those penalties were so poor - from the murky depths of a Papa Johns game
Great Turn out
FO Reading - no programme w@nkers.
2

churchmans added 23:32 - Aug 29
Sutton utd at home would be good
1

algarvefan added 23:47 - Aug 29
Wasn't there and didn't see the game, interested to know how was Slickers performance? Hladky made mistakes on Saturday, who in your opinion should start in Waltons absence?
1

Fat_Boy_Tim added 23:57 - Aug 29
Our second 11 go through to the 3rd round, for most (all?) of them it’s just their 2nd start this season. They came back against a team who got an own goal bonus after 74 seconds. Reading only had 4 shots all evening, when they scored their second it was only their 2nd shot (not on target, just shot!). This was a good performance and we were unlucky not to win before the pens.

I listened to the Town TV commentary and thought they were okay. Can’t see what anyone is complaining about. I haven’t yet seen any footage so I won’t comment on any specifics.

One other thing, all those ticket we sold with cynics saying it’s just because of the membership points - total BS. We packed it out because we have a lot of fans who want to see us play.
2

WalkRules added 00:02 - Aug 30
Certainly a hard one to watch although nice to get the win. Evans and Edmundson were very slow moving the ball around with the latter especially looking half a kick away from a calamity on more than one occasion. That aside it was a group of players not used to playing with each other. Ok we won and a great start to the season but can't shake the feeling we were victim of own own errors again
1

SurreyBlueGirl added 00:03 - Aug 30
Slicker started shakily but improved. Think Hladky's experience just gives him the edge
2

mow_the_lawn added 00:17 - Aug 30
Williams and Hutchinson both have the look of players who are doing us a favour by playing for us. Hutchinson isn't a winger, his delivery on the run is poor, keot checking back nearly every time (apart from the goal), so the defender could check him every time. Also sauntered across the pitch to take corners keeping everyone waiting despite us losing at the time. Williams is too cocky for a full back. Far too many unnecessary touches and step overs for a defender and then lost it. Unlucky for the own goal. Could've been sent off had the ref seen his petulant kick out at the Reading player.

Ladapo looked lazy and barely made any runs, Humpreys was wasted in the left forward position and should've swapped with Harness who was ineffective. Edmondson generally was decent with his positioning and reading of the game until the 87th minute.

Baggott looked good though, commanding in the air, read the game well, should've scored with a header.

Despite all that negativity, we controlled 90% of the game and should've easily won. Own goal aside they had nothing first half, and nothing until the last 10 mins of the second half. We just need to make better decisions in the final third. Aluko looked good when he came own, some great touches around the box, could've done with him starting.
9

Flight_of_Shefki added 03:59 - Aug 30
Sometimes a win, is just a win, and we need to take it and run. Think this was one of those.

Always positives to take away though.
5

JewellintheTown added 08:20 - Aug 30
Seemed we made it tough for ourselves , but on a positive, we scored 6 goals!
OK, one of them we didn't want to score.
Onward and upward.
2

dirtydingusmagee added 08:22 - Aug 30
pleased to progress in cup, BUT that match exposed more worrying things than most expected. Our ''second string'' could not do ''a job'' on a team of youngsters. Yes stats favoured Town but we were very uninspiring. Good that Slicker saved the penalty but it was woeful spot kicks from Reading that got us into next round. My thoughts after the match, our squad is NOT as strong as many believe and we are going to find it a very hard season ahead. Personally i have never thought of or expected us to get promoted this season, and a mid table finish is a probability.That said as long as we stay up this season and then move on from there i'll settle for that . And of course we finish above Nodger's
with window closing this week ,there are players needed and certainly a few to be moved on,Harness for a start IMO. But i remain confident that McKenna and Ashton will do whatever is possible to get things sorted. Eventually. COYB
6

Rimsy added 09:27 - Aug 30
Made hard work of despite being totally dominant. A few things I took from the game. Edmundson, Ball, Evans all not up to it, move them on. Slicker could easily be our no2, looks at least on a par with Hladky. Baggot impressed, very calm and close to a first team call. Williams looks class once he settles in. Hutchison too lightweight and over complicates everything, perhaps he'll settle down.
1

bucket99 added 11:14 - Aug 30
I'm surprised there's been no mention of the foul on Fridge for the second goal. He was taken down from behind blatantly, and the lad carried on and scored. Fridge complained to the ref so much after the goal that he was shown a yellow card before the restart.
Hutchinson looks good, but there's very little end product so far. His decision making isn't very good, but presumably that will improve over time with coaching and experience.
One little observation in support of Evans - at one point in the second half Slicker had the ball at his feet about 16yds out, looking for a pass; Evans was 20 yards in front of him and was beckoning him forwards, so that at least one Reading player would be drawn to the ball and out of position. Nice to see.
His pass for Freddie's goal was absolutely perfect as well btw, giving Ladapo a one-touch finish.
4

blueboy1981 added 13:49 - Aug 30
Granted - 9 Points on the League Board thus far - but I would think it is now evident to anyone who ‘knows’ the game, and what they are watching - as to how fragile this Squad is in terms of Championship required Standard.
Without Quality Recruitment, an awfully long Season ahead - and who needs a painful one ?
To anyone other than the deluded, the signs / evidence are already visible.
The Question is :- How many are capable of the Stepping Up that is required at Championship level, that we already have ?
1


You need to login in order to post your comments

Blogs 295 bloggers

Ipswich Town Polls

About Us Contact Us Terms & Conditions Privacy Cookies Advertising
© TWTD 1995-2024