|[Blog] Diamonds Aren't Forever?|
Written by itfcjoe on Sunday, 6th Nov 2011 13:49
Sorry for lack of recent blogs, I felt like I didn't know what I was talking about when the diamond was working so well at Boro and West Ham and against an out of form Brighton but it seems to have gone the way I predicted against Coventry - so unfortunately, as it gives me no pleasure to see Town lose, we are seriously struggling and dropping down the table like a lead weight.
The diamond is a dated formation and far too easy to play against. The only width it gives is through full-backs, and if the opposition play high wingers, as Portsmouth, Palace, Millwall and now Doncaster have - we will always struggle.
The mistakes that happen in the formation are not generally down to individual mistakes but a complete lack of shape. When one of the four central midfielders gives the ball away, it is more likely that it happens because there isn't an easy out ball to play, ie a winger in space, and it is too congested and they can't pass the ball as well as Xavi or Iniesta in tight spaces!
My main criticism of Paul Jewell is that he seems too arrogant to change this shape because we had a few good results previously with it, and when he makes changes in the game it is generally too late.
Against Southampton, Millwall and again yesterday, he has waited for us to go 2-0 down before making a change - we are then left with a mountain to climb. It was clear yesterday from the fact that we hadn't been in their half in first 10 minutes that the shape wasn't working, but yet he persisted until two goals went in.
Another major criticism of Jewell is that when he realises the formation isn't working and changes it, he still doesn't go through with it fully. Last week at Millwall, Grant Leadbitter was shifted to left midfield, then back across to right midfield - square pegs, round roles.
Yesterday, Leadbitter was again shifted out to the right hand side and doesn't know how to play this role as it isn't natural to him - so drifts inside and we are still left with no width. If Jewell is changing to 4-4-2 he has to have the conviction to do it properly and not half-heartedly, as it does no one any favours.
Jewell needs to take some responsibility and stop blaming individual errors and take a long, hard look in the mirror. The defence are hopelessly exposed, Jimmy Bullard is hardly a Makelele sitting in front of them - and to claim the goals are happening due to their individual errors is grossly unfair - you attack, and more importantly defend as a team - whereas we seem to do it as a group of individuals.
We concede far too many goals, and from next match I would like to see us work from the back forwards. A back four with two midfielders sitting in front of them, Keith Andrews does this job for Ireland and I think Leadbitter should be able to act as the second player. This should give us a solid base and make us difficult to break down, conceding goals is our main problem at the moment and needs to be solved before we can even think of anything else.
I would then personally start with a front three of Michael Chopra as the central prong, and two of either Martin, Carson or JET - most probably the former two as they are more willing to work hard and track their full-backs and drop in as wide midfielders when we don't have the ball.
This leaves one further player, at home I would be tempted to play JET as a second striker/trequartista, trying to pick out balls to the front three - but away from home I would play Jimmy Bullard. He has been poor in recent weeks and the fact him being caught in possession seems to have become a habit means that he should be played in a position where when he is getting caught it doesn't lead to a direct line to our goal.
The diamond is a dated formation, and formations evolve over time - 15 years ago 3-5-2 was the in in-vogue system, but teams then started playing only one genuine striker so that there were two spare defenders and the team with one up had an extra man in a more important area of the pitch. There is a reason why no one plays the diamond any more - and the last three (arguably four) games have shown how better players in a worse system will lose to worse individuals in a good system.
Paul Jewell, in the minute chance that you read this here is my message to you, you have assembled a good squad, are a good man manager and seem a good bloke and want to be in it for the long term, but I implore you to try and work on a shape that is from 2011 and not 1996 in the international break!'
Please report offensive, libellous or inappropriate posts by using the links provided.
Blogs by itfcjoe
Blogs 290 bloggers
Lessons to Be Learned From Last Season by BossMan
I spend a decent chunk of every day pouring over footy stats and thought I’d take a look at what if anything might be learned from the Town stats of last season.
Who Are You? Where Are You? by Pessimist
Having supported Ipswich Town for more than half a decade, my love affair with this wonderful club remains undiminished.
The Gamechanger Paradox by DanLyles
"It was the best of times, it was the worst of times, it was the age of wisdom, it was the age of foolishness, it was the epoch of belief, it was the epoch of incredulity, it was the season of Light, it was the season of Darkness, it was the spring of hope, it was the winter of despair..."
Happy Anniversary of Ipswich Winning the Top Division on 28th April 1962 by HegansDog
I cannot compete with the fine recollections of the 1961/62 season produced by Elephant-in-the-Room.
The M Word by Chickenstochurchmans
As new players and staff have arrived at Portman Road over the last year Town have frequently been described as a ‘massive’ club much to the amusement of older fans like myself.