| The curious case of Jack Taylor 11:01 - Jul 21 with 2716 views | _clive_baker_ |
Not that curious to be fair, just sounded like an appropriate thread title.
What do people make of his future here? Couldn't get in the side in the Championship, couldn't get much of an opportunity last season either. In fact he's only started 11 league games in his town career so far, and 3 of those were after the PL season was done.
I'm not really sure what he is, he's not a 6, he's been used at times in a more advanced 10 role but I'm not convinced he's suited to that for us. On paper he's a box-to-box conventional #8, but not in our system.
We're talking about an Ireland international (yeah, I know) in the prime years of his career. One that seems to threaten to break through and is generally neat and tidy, but never really stakes a big claim when he does play. I wonder if he'll move on this summer if the recruitment goes to plan? Or maybe stick around and see more of the same in terms of opportunities until he leaves on a free next summer? |  | | |  |
| The curious case of Jack Taylor on 12:30 - Jul 21 with 472 views | Nutkins_Return |
| The curious case of Jack Taylor on 12:02 - Jul 21 by itfcjoe |
27 year old international who doesn't really fit with how we play or has been able to make a mark here - all things being equal you don't let him run his contract down so probably sell him now.
But Morsy's unexpected departure may have scuppered that as leaves us too much to do in CM so he ends up a casualty of that and we lose out on a few million quid we could have potentially got for him |
I could see him signing a new contract. If we go up I think he'll move on. He's an excellent squad CM for us. Doesn't cause a manager any problems and has the ability to come on and get us a goal. |  |
| |
| The curious case of Jack Taylor on 12:43 - Jul 21 with 436 views | BarcaBlue |
| The curious case of Jack Taylor on 12:30 - Jul 21 by Nutkins_Return |
I could see him signing a new contract. If we go up I think he'll move on. He's an excellent squad CM for us. Doesn't cause a manager any problems and has the ability to come on and get us a goal. |
I think that's pushing it a bit. He's scored 3 league goals for us in 2 seasons. Admittedly he's been limited in starts but that's not a great return for a player considered "box to box" even if we don't exactly play him that way.
Maybe it's because of his style, preferred position or midfielders ahead of him but it's been an underwhelming couple of years really. As with the op I'm not sure where he fits in here. |  | | |
| The curious case of Jack Taylor on 13:28 - Jul 21 with 384 views | Durovigutum |
| The curious case of Jack Taylor on 11:06 - Jul 21 by Blue_Moses |
To me a 6 is a defender and a 10 is a striker |
I’m glad it’s not just me. 5&6 are centre backs and 4 is your holding midfielder. |  | | |
| The curious case of Jack Taylor on 14:55 - Jul 21 with 319 views | Juggsy |
Taylor plus cash for Hackney anyone? |  | | |
| The curious case of Jack Taylor on 15:10 - Jul 21 with 280 views | Kieran_Knows |
I think it's unfortunate for him as he came in that summer where we all expected him to start alongside Morsy given the money we paid for him, and yet Morsy & Luongo kicked on again in the Championship and didn't look back.
I like him as a player, but have always felt he doesn't particularly suit our number 8 role, neither does he suit the 10 role.
Similar to Broadhead, going in the last year of his deal and do we view them both as long term solutions should we go back up again? Either get relatively decent money for them this summer, or see them go for nothing next summer. |  |
| |
| The curious case of Jack Taylor on 17:31 - Jul 21 with 172 views | Nutkins_Return |
| The curious case of Jack Taylor on 12:43 - Jul 21 by BarcaBlue |
I think that's pushing it a bit. He's scored 3 league goals for us in 2 seasons. Admittedly he's been limited in starts but that's not a great return for a player considered "box to box" even if we don't exactly play him that way.
Maybe it's because of his style, preferred position or midfielders ahead of him but it's been an underwhelming couple of years really. As with the op I'm not sure where he fits in here. |
It's not pushing it really is it. He's always had a goal in him. 22 for Peterborough including 10 in his final season and anyone with eyes can see he's a threat. That's not the issue with him. He's technically not as strong as we need to hold down a starting birth.
Think he's worked on his game though and will be interesting to see how he's goes this season. Certainly toward end of the season he was talking like he was staying and wanted to force his way as a starter this year.
Just think he's a good squad player and rather will save us spending. If we got a good offer I'm fine with it either way. | |
| |
| The curious case of Jack Taylor on 19:12 - Jul 21 with 105 views | Smoresy |
As a conventional #8 on paper he brings some versatility. He was first choice sub midfielder in a team that won automatic promotion. He overtook Luongo in the pecking order last season, coming on from the bench most games again.
Put the above together and I don't think we've been short-changed for our £1.5m, but maybe it is curious how McKenna monitored and chased him for as long as he did. Was it a misstep or did we identify someone who would improve the 16 or 20, rather than the starting 11?
Whatever the answer to that, we definitely need a deep squad to do positive things this year. As long as Jack's happy to continue helping from the bench, I don't see a great argument for shifting him on. I can see us offering him an extension next year. | | | |
| The curious case of Jack Taylor on 19:25 - Jul 21 with 80 views | HungryLikeTheWoolf |
| The curious case of Jack Taylor on 11:12 - Jul 21 by _clive_baker_ |
Yeah I think it'll go 1 of 2 ways, 1) we recruit well and he moves on towards the end of the window. Or 2) we still need his presence, he sticks around and continues to not get many opportunities.
Bit of a shame for him, on the plus side he can say he's achieved back to back promotions and played in the premier league. On the downside I would've thought he would want to be playing every week at this stage of his career. Can't see that with us. |
He joined us in June 2023 so only(!) got one promotion with us, but he still played his part! |  | | |
| |
By continuing to use the site, you agree to our use of cookies and to abide by our Terms and Conditions.
