| Do the Exeter match ratings tell us anything? 14:39 - Aug 17 with 1185 views | WarkTheWarkITFC |
Looking at the ratings given by our fans to players in the Exeter match on Tuesday, a pattern emerged.
Bartosz Bialkowski 6.31
*Kayden Jackson 5.66
*Aristote Nsiala 5.10
*Tayo Edun 4.65
*Jon Nolan 4.62
*Trevoh Chalobah 4.07
Grant Ward 3.62
Jonas Knudsen 3.42
*Janoi Donacien 3.32
Luke Chambers 3.27
Freddie Sears 2.90
The previous two matches saw some higher ratings given to some new players and some of the old guard, but this match was markedly different. 6 new signings started the match and of the 10 outfield positions, 5 of those 6 were our highest rated players. Leaving the 4 old members of the squad in the bottom 5.
This was a match when Hurst's system was evident. My initial thought, until I looked at the other match ratings, were that people were being too harsh on the old guard, but why would they be? We have no loyalty to the new guys and so our tendency would be the favour the likes of Chambers surely?
I, like many, don't consider that we should change too much too soon, but what do you do if you are Hurst and these ratings really do reflect the performance? The players likely to be dropped on the back of this are the old players and those waiting to come into the side are the new ones. Edwards will come back in, Harrison probably will too.
So how much of this is system and how much is attitude? Chambers should not struggle in this system. His position is basically unchanged. Sears shouldn't look worse than he did last season in the same unflavoured role.
Are we seeing players struggling with the system, are we seeing the new signings stepping up to impress or is it that the old mentality of Mick's players was that you don't really have to lift yourselves for a League Two team in the cup.
It cannot be coincidence that the new players appear to be massively outperforming the old ones. So what do we think is at the heart of why that is? |  |
| |  |
| Do the Exeter match ratings tell us anything? on 14:46 - Aug 17 with 1156 views | PJH |
Or the ratings could be totally meaningless in relation to actual performances just as they have been for the last two years. |  | | |
| Do the Exeter match ratings tell us anything? on 14:47 - Aug 17 with 1149 views | Mullet |
No. |  |
| |
| Do the Exeter match ratings tell us anything? on 14:47 - Aug 17 with 1148 views | SWGF |
No. |  |
| |
| Do the Exeter match ratings tell us anything? on 14:48 - Aug 17 with 1144 views | Illinoisblue |
jesus christ. |  |
| |
| Do the Exeter match ratings tell us anything? on 14:50 - Aug 17 with 1136 views | PJH |
| Do the Exeter match ratings tell us anything? on 14:48 - Aug 17 by Illinoisblue |
jesus christ. |
i thought he might have got MOTM. | | | |
| Do the Exeter match ratings tell us anything? on 14:53 - Aug 17 with 1117 views | Mullet |
| Do the Exeter match ratings tell us anything? on 14:50 - Aug 17 by PJH |
i thought he might have got MOTM. |
Given he's the Father, Son and Holy Ghost you'd have thought he was more likely to play for Norwich. | |
| |
| Do the Exeter match ratings tell us anything? on 14:57 - Aug 17 with 1100 views | LankHenners |
FFS after every game someone starts a pointless thread like this. The player ratings should not be given one iota's attention. People who don't go to the game just click away at the numbers based on the final score and which players they like/don't like. |  |
| |
| Do the Exeter match ratings tell us anything? on 14:59 - Aug 17 with 1080 views | SWGF |
| Do the Exeter match ratings tell us anything? on 14:57 - Aug 17 by LankHenners |
FFS after every game someone starts a pointless thread like this. The player ratings should not be given one iota's attention. People who don't go to the game just click away at the numbers based on the final score and which players they like/don't like. |
Whisper it, but I don't really see the point of the match ratings. | |
| |
Login to get fewer ads
| Do the Exeter match ratings tell us anything? on 15:02 - Aug 17 with 1059 views | PJH |
| Do the Exeter match ratings tell us anything? on 14:59 - Aug 17 by SWGF |
Whisper it, but I don't really see the point of the match ratings. |
I certainly do not see the point of anyone taking the slightest bit of notice of them so yes I agree, there is no point to them. | | | |
| Do the Exeter match ratings tell us anything? on 15:02 - Aug 17 with 1059 views | Stenvict |
| Do the Exeter match ratings tell us anything? on 14:57 - Aug 17 by LankHenners |
FFS after every game someone starts a pointless thread like this. The player ratings should not be given one iota's attention. People who don't go to the game just click away at the numbers based on the final score and which players they like/don't like. |
Exactly, hence why Bart was given the highest rating despite making another mistake for their goal. | |
| |
| Do the Exeter match ratings tell us anything? on 15:11 - Aug 17 with 1032 views | LankHenners |
| Do the Exeter match ratings tell us anything? on 14:59 - Aug 17 by SWGF |
Whisper it, but I don't really see the point of the match ratings. |
I'm sure Gav's penciled it in to be sorted in the next update. | |
| |
| Do the Exeter match ratings tell us anything? on 15:11 - Aug 17 with 1031 views | TractorCam |
Nope, they never have and never will |  |
| |
| Do the Exeter match ratings tell us anything? on 18:00 - Aug 17 with 885 views | CBMTOBWMMBG |
Your first post, earlier this week, was one of the best posts in years. Lots of people said so.
This is not of the same standard! | | | |
| |
By continuing to use the site, you agree to our use of cookies and to abide by our Terms and Conditions.
