Please log in or register. Registered visitors get fewer ads.
Forum index | Previous Thread | Next thread
USA music question 15:49 - Nov 14 with 6506 viewsSharkey

We quite often hear of UK bands (and for that matter comedians) not being able to 'crack' America, but I was having a discussion about whether there are any bands who were/are BIG in America but who are almost unheard of here, or who never sold any records here. Does EVERYTHING that's big there make it over here?


We had no good suggestions. Do you?



(p.s. To answer my own question, I guess there are some huge mainstream right-wing country artists who are largely ignored here. But in rock and pop?
[Post edited 14 Nov 2022 16:03]
0
USA music question on 15:42 - Nov 15 with 1278 viewshoppy

USA music question on 16:13 - Nov 14 by Sharkey

Yesterday I was watching a youtube clip of the drummer's mother on U.S. Antiques Road Show.


I guess it may even have been that that subconsciously made me ask the question.




Also, Jimmy Buffett maybe. I think he's very big in America.
[Post edited 14 Nov 2022 16:16]


To be fair, they DO like their Buffets over there, don't they?

Poll: Which Which nickname for ITFC do you prefer? poll do you prefer?
Blog: Graphical Blog: I Feel the Need...

1
USA music question on 15:50 - Nov 15 with 1262 viewsTractor_Buck

USA music question on 03:07 - Nov 15 by IPS_wich

In a similar vein - there are 3-4 rock bands that are Australian icons and folks down here are absolutely flabbergasted when I say I've never heard of them. Which is odd given how so many UK acts/artists seem even bigger here than in the UK (especially 80s UK acts - Nik Kershaw's work from the 80s springs to mind as something that is still regularly played on the radio). Examples of Australian acts who I've never heard of until I moved here:

Silverchair - 5 x Number 1 albums in Australia from 95 to 07; Top 10 albums in the US; only one of the albums scraped into the top 40 in the UK charts.

Cold Chisel/Jimmy Barnes - despite being born in Scotland Jimmy Barnes (initially as front man to Cold Chisel and then as a solo artist) is a national treasure with 12-15 #1 albums going back to the 70s - but not one album in the UK Top 100.

Powderfinger - an alternative rock act from the late 90s and 00s with six #1 albums in Australia - never made it overseas.

Birds of Tokyo - a big act from the last 15 years. 5 x Top 3 albums in Australia but no success overseas.

Then you have the acts that would be one hit wonders in the UK but who are huge here - the likes of John Farnham, Men At Work, Midnight Oil and Gotye.

Of course there are many big Australian acts internationally: AC/DC, INXS, Kylie, Bee Gees, Tame Impala, Crowded House, Nick Cave - but most of them (perhaps except Kylie and the Bee Gees) were big in Australia for a few years before making it big internationally.


Not rock, more indie-pop but I'd respectfully add Sheppard to the Aussie list. Award winning, massive sales, a staple of Aus pop music radio, and virtually unknown outside the country.

Geronimo, a proper decent example of its genre, was their only breakout hit and just scraped the Top40 over here.
0
USA music question on 16:32 - Nov 15 with 1238 viewsBlueandTruesince82

USA music question on 15:50 - Nov 15 by Tractor_Buck

Not rock, more indie-pop but I'd respectfully add Sheppard to the Aussie list. Award winning, massive sales, a staple of Aus pop music radio, and virtually unknown outside the country.

Geronimo, a proper decent example of its genre, was their only breakout hit and just scraped the Top40 over here.


Airborne as well. They have a following over here and quote big across much of the globe but not nearly the profile you'd expect

Poll: Will Phil ever confirm we are actually close on a signing ever again

0
USA music question on 23:53 - Nov 15 with 1196 viewsFoghornGleghorn

USA music question on 20:11 - Nov 14 by BlueNomad

They try too hard to be 1970 Zeppelin


Always worth wheeling this out again:

https://pitchfork.com/reviews/albums/greta-van-fleet-anthem-of-the-peaceful-army
0
USA music question on 06:14 - Nov 16 with 1134 viewsTeHuia

USA music question on 16:34 - Nov 14 by You_Bloo_Right

Aren't The Grateful Dead another band that have a huge US following but who have had limited if any success over here?


Grateful Dead, good call.

A fair bit of that West Coast stuff didn’t get much UK exposure, stuff like Buffalo Springfield, Jefferson Airplane (the UK ‘Surrealistic Pillow’ LP is a mash up of their first two albums), Country Joe The Fish. Love were popular in the UK though.

And the #1 UK band of that era that didn’t crack America but should have? Small Faces.
0
USA music question on 06:25 - Nov 16 with 1124 viewsTeHuia

USA music question on 03:07 - Nov 15 by IPS_wich

In a similar vein - there are 3-4 rock bands that are Australian icons and folks down here are absolutely flabbergasted when I say I've never heard of them. Which is odd given how so many UK acts/artists seem even bigger here than in the UK (especially 80s UK acts - Nik Kershaw's work from the 80s springs to mind as something that is still regularly played on the radio). Examples of Australian acts who I've never heard of until I moved here:

Silverchair - 5 x Number 1 albums in Australia from 95 to 07; Top 10 albums in the US; only one of the albums scraped into the top 40 in the UK charts.

Cold Chisel/Jimmy Barnes - despite being born in Scotland Jimmy Barnes (initially as front man to Cold Chisel and then as a solo artist) is a national treasure with 12-15 #1 albums going back to the 70s - but not one album in the UK Top 100.

Powderfinger - an alternative rock act from the late 90s and 00s with six #1 albums in Australia - never made it overseas.

Birds of Tokyo - a big act from the last 15 years. 5 x Top 3 albums in Australia but no success overseas.

Then you have the acts that would be one hit wonders in the UK but who are huge here - the likes of John Farnham, Men At Work, Midnight Oil and Gotye.

Of course there are many big Australian acts internationally: AC/DC, INXS, Kylie, Bee Gees, Tame Impala, Crowded House, Nick Cave - but most of them (perhaps except Kylie and the Bee Gees) were big in Australia for a few years before making it big internationally.


A couple of Aussie bands you may want to check out that didn't get much traction outside Australia

The Church
The Reels

Early '80s stuff

Also, Crowded House are a kiwi band ;-)
0
USA music question on 06:28 - Nov 16 with 1120 viewsWeWereZombies

USA music question on 06:25 - Nov 16 by TeHuia

A couple of Aussie bands you may want to check out that didn't get much traction outside Australia

The Church
The Reels

Early '80s stuff

Also, Crowded House are a kiwi band ;-)


Whilst the Finns are Kiwi, so Kiwi, didn't the early line ups of Crowded House feature a preponderance of Aussies and mainly gig in Australia ?

And the best band from New Zealand are Fat Freddy's Drop.

Poll: What was in Wes Burns' imaginary cup of tea ?

0
USA music question on 07:01 - Nov 16 with 1109 viewsIPS_wich

USA music question on 06:25 - Nov 16 by TeHuia

A couple of Aussie bands you may want to check out that didn't get much traction outside Australia

The Church
The Reels

Early '80s stuff

Also, Crowded House are a kiwi band ;-)


I like The Church - but they haven't even had a Top 10 album in Australia (Starfish got to #11) - I tried to focus on the bands that are genuinely huge here.

[Never heard of the Reels - but a quick wiki shows their most popular album only got to #27 in Australia]

Also - I think it's fair to say that Australia has effectively adopted Crowded House despite the Finns being from across the Tasman.
0
Login to get fewer ads

USA music question on 13:43 - Nov 17 with 993 viewsSharkey

USA music question on 23:53 - Nov 15 by FoghornGleghorn

Always worth wheeling this out again:

https://pitchfork.com/reviews/albums/greta-van-fleet-anthem-of-the-peaceful-army


Brightened my day. Few things are as good as a really really bad review.
1
USA music question on 16:13 - Nov 17 with 941 viewsC_HealyIsAPleasure

Not a band but John Mayer is another who is absolutely huge in the States, every album other than his first charting in the top 2 and various single hits, yet never had a single crack the top 40 over here

Quite the dating back catalogue too

Highlighting crass stupidity since sometime around 2010
Poll: Would you want Messi to sign?

1




About Us Contact Us Terms & Conditions Privacy Cookies Online Safety Advertising
© TWTD 1995-2025