Please log in or register. Registered visitors get fewer ads.
McKenna: If It Becomes a Bigger Narrative It Becomes Detrimental to the Team and Players
Friday, 5th Dec 2025 16:00

Town boss Kieran McKenna has launched a robust defence of the rotation policy which has come under scrutiny from some fans in recent games and says it’s important that it doesn’t become a bigger narrative than getting behind the team.

McKenna has regularly made five or six changes with games coming thick and fast - the Blues are currently in a run of seven matches in 22 days - and with the squad having undergone extensive changes over the summer.

Following the 2-1 defeat at Oxford on Friday and then Tuesday’s 1-1 draw at Blackburn Rovers, when McKenna admitted his team had played poorly, the regular changes of personnel faced criticism from some supporters, as have some of those individual players coming into the side.

Asked his thoughts on how the rotation policy is progressing and it having become a talking point, McKenna said: “I know it’s a topic and I can speak about that at the end. You can’t remove it from the context of where we are as a group and a club first of all.

“I’ve been a manager here for four years now and we’ve had lots of periods where we’ve had settled teams and consistency and, of course, every manager in the world would like to have a group that are playing really well, that are robust enough to play all the minutes, that the connections have been built over time.

“When you have that sort of group, you tend to try and be as a consistent as you can be. But that is so far detached from our reality. In terms of our starters from last year, regular, regular starters, probably Dara [O’Shea] and Leif [Davis], I would have thought. That’s the reality of the turnover that we had.

“If we had Axel [Tuanzebe] and Sam Morsy and Liam Delap and Omari Hutchinson, then I think we would have had fewer changes this year.

“We are a group that are building, not from scratch because some of the players were here last year, but with almost a complete turnover after two promotions and a relegation.

“A fair amount of those players have joined in the summer and a fair amount joined with no pre-season, some with injury issues.

“So, from that point, as a group and as a club, when we decide that when we’ve lost players we want to replace them with quality players and have a strong squad, I don’t think it’s possible then to click your fingers and have a cohesive team that’s, certainly in some cases, Sindre [Walle Egeli] may be an easy example because he’s young, ready to go and play every game.

“I don’t think you can compare it with previous years here, you can’t compare it with other clubs because we’re in a really different position in terms of how many new players and how late the group has come together. It takes time to build a team, it takes time to build those connections.

“In my first six months here, there were probably a fair few more changes here than there were in the six months when we were first in the Championship and we were coming off a promotion and the group had played together, physically could do 40, 45 games of a Championship season, had had that time together. We don’t have that group at the moment.

“I’ve said many times, it feels like then we start on 1st September in between three international breaks with some really good players, with an EFL fixture programme when we probably don’t have 11 ready to play every minute of every game.

“We decide as a club that we want to have a strong squad. I’m not someone who is going to bring players to the club, good players who we think can be really good players at the level, and not give them opportunities to play, to prove [themselves].

“You don’t build a team in that way, you don’t build a team on the pitch or off the pitch if you bring players in who are good players at the level and they never play.

“Of course, there’s a process to go through there. That for me is more in relation to where we are as a club.

“Other than that, I’ve said it many times, it’s always going to be a topic. If we’re not winning, in the position that we’re in as a team who have come down from the Premier League, if you don’t win and you rotate, that’s going to be the reason why.

“In my opinion, I’ve not got the scientific formula, but if you look for a correlation with results, I don’t think there is one.

“When we make six changes at Hull and we win, it’s not mentioned. The games that we’ve lost this season, Preston, we played the same team and lost. Middlesbrough we played the same team and lost. Oxford, with Jens [Cajuste] injured, we only made three, which with a Tuesday night and Friday night away is pretty minimum changes, and we lost.

“So I don’t think there’s any correlation between that and the points that we’ve had. I can make many, many different arguments on it. But at the end, I know that if you don’t win, that’s always going to be the story.

“Of course, we want to get to a more consistent group, but that doesn’t usually happen straight away, not with the context, not with the position we’re in. That takes some time and we know a lot more about the players now than we did on 1st September and I’m pretty sure on 1st February we’ll know a little bit more on who’s working well with who and what the best partnerships are and what are the best teams.

“And hopefully on 1st February, we’ll have a really good group with very few injuries, as we do at the moment.

“It is what it is. If we make a change and we don’t win a game, that’s going to be the story.

“I know there is another world you can imagine up where we could have gone with a much smaller squad and picked the starting team from 1st September and played them in every minute and then the performances would have been better and we would have taken all our chances late in games and we’d have more points.

“But there are many other ways that world could have played out as well and, for one, simply, I don’t think I’d be sitting here with a fully fit squad.

“Of course, there are other realities, but as a manager, the only reality you live is the one that you do.

“And it’s what we believe is right for the club. The same way, whenever we’ve been here and not made changes or had more consistent teams, we felt it was the right thing for the club.

“Of course, we want to work back through to that sort of position again with the team. With the schedule we’ve had in the last month or two, I don’t think it’s been possible, even on schedule, availability and fitness alone. So, that is what it is.

“What I will say is, and this I think is important. If we bring in a new group of players we want to really, really get behind them.

“If we allow this internally to become such a big narrative because players read stuff, players know how the perception is for them or against. Some of the players we could mention, they’re two, three, four, five appearances into their time at the football club.

“I can understand any opinion, I can take any perspective. I’ve have enough good and bad days in my career already to roll with any, it doesn’t matter to me, I’ll always do what I think is right for the club and for the group.

“But the one thing I would ask is that if you’re an Ipswich Town player and you’ve been trusted to come here to the club and brought here for a reason and you’ve wanted to come here for the right reasons, which all the players have, that we get right behind whoever plays.

“When it supersedes that, when it becomes a bigger narrative than getting behind the players who are playing, then that becomes detrimental to the team and detrimental to the players.

“That’s where we’re at. We’ll pick the right team for the next six games that we have in December and keep trying to do the right things for the team and hopefully the team will pick up good results, starting from tomorrow.”

Photo: TWTD



Please report offensive, libellous or inappropriate posts by using the links provided.



ITFCSG added 18:05 - Dec 5
1st February, by that time even play-offs may be out of reach if we continue with such pi$$ poor performances
0

blueboy1981 added 18:12 - Dec 5
The Footballing Quality of individual players at the Club, and the quantity would be a dream for any other Manager in the Championship - just ask them ?
Therefore people criticising the quality of recruitment are wrong and out of order - the failing lies with McKenna, his rotation of players, and tactics.
He knows a player when he sees one - but therein it ends after signing !!
-4

blueoutlook added 18:22 - Dec 5
The year we won the UEFA cup,finished runners up in the league and semi finalists in the FA cup. We played 66 games, we didn’t rotate, we hadn’t the players fora start. The thing was they were more robust. Nowadays they go down at the slightest touch, are injured for months and are wrapped in cotton wool,that’s the truth of the matter. Kieran, we have no steel in the team, no winners, no one who will run through fire. You have bought a bunch of wimps.
6

blueboy1981 added 18:34 - Dec 5
Unfortunately some of our ‘fans’ have and always will make excuses for whatever is served up by the Team.
Such people are just not bothered too much about success and winning, if at all - I’ve said it before, as long as a Ball is Kicked - they are Happy !!
But NOT ALL - Thankfully !!
-7

Tedray added 18:54 - Dec 5
The game seems to have changed now - much more about passing and passing and passing than individual skill.Years ago when such as John Elsworthy,Danny Hegan or Arnold Muhren and co were playing well the whole team was playing well and they were a joy to watch.Tomorrow is crucial and marks an interesting period of games. Can we reclaim the desire and make a fight of it or heaven forbid will we be timidly turned over - there is a lot riding on it.Hopefully with the support of the crowd the team whoever they might be will be able to shake off the apathy.
1

HOG500 added 18:59 - Dec 5
The usual flapping, doom and gloom. Five points off 2nd place with a squad who hardly know each other and 84 points to play for. Get a grip and support your team ffs.
-4

SickParrot added 19:11 - Dec 5
Large squads are now a necessity because of the demands of the modern game and the fans understand that the same eleven are rarely likely to play in consecutive games. However changing 5 or 6 players, as Kieran often has this season, must surely hinder the development of on field relationships and may therefore explain our lack of confidence and cohesion. Kieran will of course want all the squad to feel involved and fully motivated but so many changes may have the opposite affect. Why should a player give 100% if they know that regardless of how well they play they will probably not play in the next game. Also, there is less incentive for players who have not played well to improve if they know that they will bevpicked again anyway because of the rotation policy. Hopefully Kieran's rotation policy will pay dividends in the long term but here we are in December, still playing like complete strangers, with a fragile mentality and Kieran has no idea who he should pick if he wants to play his best team!
4

armchaircritic59 added 19:17 - Dec 5
blueoutlook, a point I've made before, but I got largely shouted down by the " Football is much faster, players are fitter today, blah blah, squad " They didn't quite get my point that it's irrelevant. Those players played against teams of pretty much the same fitness levels as themselves, playing similar football too. Just as todays players are. Further, I will maintain this, take the class of 80/81, have it trained at todays levels ( no half time fag breaks! ), put it up against the team we have now ( any 11 ), and it would be a mismatch. That's not an attempt to slight todays players, just a fact. My main point being, if players can't play 3 games in what is usually 8 days, Saturday, midweek, Saturday regularly, maybe they should take up something else. I actually don't have a problem with a couple of rotations here and there, but half the outfield on a regular basis I do.

Personally I'd put winning points before keeping players happy as it's a results based business. It's up to them to prove they are worth a regular starting place. If they don't like it, it will soon be January.

I'm never afraid to admit I'm wrong, so if KM keeps insisting on mass rotation and we go on a long run of picking up a shed load of points, which we will possibly need to, I'll be one of the first to hold my hands up and say I was wrong. I will await the outcome!
7

Lightningboy added 20:32 - Dec 5
I just think he's trying to be too clever....and it's backfiring on him.

Seems to be quite a stubborn bloke,the sort who won't admit he's wrong,no matter how dreadful the style of play is becoming.

Really needs to sort this team out,it's Christmas now,not mid September.
6

Hatman2 added 21:25 - Dec 5
He’s spot on. Some of our so called supporters are dinosaurs spouting on about rotations. If the team played every 7 days then maybe you ask that question but when we play every 3 days and you have 20+ players of equal quality rotating so most start every 7 days is not disruptive, it’s the same as a settled side playing every 7 days. He’s trying to guard against half the squad getting rinsed and the other half being in-played, un-prepared and un-happy. Rinse the same 11 players in a 50+ game season we’re dead in the water come February. Wake up everyone - it’s not 1982.
0

Stato added 21:40 - Dec 5
Why ship Chaplin out the doir if famaliarity is such an important factor? Hopefully the rotation polcy will start to reward us but there will be more signings in Jan especially in defensive midfirld and at number 9 so when does the complaining about new signings stop ? Half a season is way too long for a team to gel and thats on the manager
4

bobble added 21:40 - Dec 5
Other teams do what be says cant be done...but if they get several injuries they may start sliding and his approach may get us up
0

TimmyH added 22:08 - Dec 5
I said at the beginning of the season with all the new faces coming in he'll have a job keeping them all happy and also struggle to find what is his best starting 11, the fact is I've been right and wrong as I'm certain he doesn't know his strongest starting line up and McK is actually keeping the majority happy with his ridiculous rotation policy whether in form or not other than the captain/Walton and maybe Matusiwa. Can't help so far thinking this is a bit self inflicted.
1

Drifter3012 added 22:13 - Dec 5
What is concerning for me is that we just don't have any team spirit. This was evident on Tuesday I think. We score in the final seconds of a match in front of our fans and there was hardly any celebration from the players. Yes it was a bad performance but 2/3 seasons ago the likes of Harry Clarke, Wes Burns would have thrown themselves into the crowd but Tuesday, nothing. That needs addressing. For consistency we need that to be built up again somehow.
3

bigredude added 22:21 - Dec 5
KM talks about building for the future. Sorry I cannot see how after being battered defensively in the Prem last season, we are where we are today in building a strong back line and goalie ready for our next Prem adventure. Using Young, BJ and others to fashion together a defensive line that leaks goals seem odd?

We have younger players Harry C, Elkan B, Cam H etc developed through our own academy that should be being bedded in now. They could do no worse than what we are seeing just now. For sure (200% sure) they would be prepared to give it all every time they played ... running through a wall for club and manager like the teams of the 2 promotion seasons.

That our own 3 academy 1st team registered players have played less than 10 appearances between them this season (I think Baggott has zero!!) is a real weakness of our club's culture and belief. Even more suprising KM developed his management skills through Man Utd's academy organisation thus should have some affinity to youth development.
5

Dissboyitfc added 22:21 - Dec 5
No Blueboy many of us aren’t happy it’s just that many understand km knows more than you about football!
2

algarvefan added 22:49 - Dec 5
The key word here is 'Team' how can players gel, form on field relationships, with so many week to week changes? It's not worked so far this season and players are lacking the fighting spirit that the Championship needs. In 1981 Sir Bobby's town had 61 games, injury only forcing changes with I think about 16 players. These games often were played on very rough cut up pitches, not the lovely ones (well at home at least) that they play on today.

Start each game with your best 11 boss, there is plenty of room for substitutions if players are tiring. Good luck to the team tomorrow COYB.
0

Len_Brennan added 23:59 - Dec 5
If the performances & results are poor, and if some of the players are unhappy with the minutes they are getting, just remember that that will be your fault and not in any way the fault of the man who picks the team, coaches them, chooses formations/tactics, substitutions and has responsibility for mental strength & focus.
0

OliveR16 added 10:42 - Dec 6
The two clubs who have used the fewest players this season in the Championship are Coventry and Stoke. So rather than listen to the blarney, we can see for ourselves in the next two games how much better our rested, rotated, fit squad is than those worn out, overplayed teams.
But then again . . .
0

Cadiar added 19:12 - Dec 6
God, I wonder if the majority of people on here are thicker than Narwich fans. KM made it very simple for even Blueboy to understand but some fell on barren ground, in fact most did. Even the most sensible comment, by HOG got downs. So, I'm reading this after we just beat the leaders 3-0. Any deep inciteful thoughts now you bunch of muppets.
-1

TimmyH added 20:29 - Dec 6
HOG500 post - 5pts off 2nd place because it's an awful league lacking in quality!!!, good ol' Cadiar above was slating Coventry tonight after their loss to us saying they're not that good and Lampard too! and they're 12 points clear of us.

As for the many players whom hardly know each other...I wonder why? Come the end of the season we'll see if McK's right with all the changes to personnel and from game to game.
0


You need to login in order to post your comments

Blogs 297 bloggers

Ipswich Town Polls

About Us Contact Us Terms & Conditions Privacy Cookies Online Safety Advertising
© TWTD 1995-2025