By continuing to use the site, you agree to our use of cookies and to abide by our Terms and Conditions. We in turn value your personal details in accordance with our Privacy Policy.
Please log in or register. Registered visitors get fewer ads.
In the Premier League I think it's tough to argue that it has. There seems to be a reluctance to acknowledge when a referee has made an error and wrong decisions are being doubled down on. The fact that not once has a referee reviewed an incident on the pitch side monitor is bizarre.
0
Has the introduction of VAR improved decision making? on 11:07 - Oct 21 with 1218 views
It seems to have bee a success everywhere other than the English premier division I hear there are questions about how many 'refs' are watchign how many games???
0
Has the introduction of VAR improved decision making? on 11:25 - Oct 21 with 1186 views
Has the introduction of VAR improved decision making? on 11:25 - Oct 21 by RobTheMonk
That Delofeou one was about 3 penalties in one!
Yup cant see the point if they are only giving offside descisions by 6'' and ignore nailed on penalties . Also think the Ref might think leave that to VAR and visa versa by the VAR .
0
Has the introduction of VAR improved decision making? on 12:19 - Oct 21 with 1135 views
Most decisions in football are too subjective and open to interpretation to make VAR effective in my opinion. Use goal line technology and retrospective punishments for diving, violent acts, etc but leave the rest alone.
It's a game that wasn't broken in the first place. Decisions go for and against over the course of a season. It's that emotion and uncertainty that makes it the game it is.
VAR (much like the huge sums of money sloshing around at the top level) is stripping away at the soul of football.
[Post edited 21 Oct 2019 12:28]
1
Has the introduction of VAR improved decision making? on 12:48 - Oct 21 with 1092 views
You must remember that it is the same prem referee's who find it impossible to be consistent about what is / is not a foul that find it equally impossible to be consistent when looking at a tv replay of an incident. The video refs just seem to back up the mistakes of the ref on the pitch, whereas it was expected that they would correct the errors. Shame as VAR is a very good idea that still manages to make a large number of basic errors in decisions.
As others have said the operation of VAR isn't fully subjective, so in the case of a decision on a 'foul' it can tell you by and large if contact is made or not, but no more than that. So if all that's required for a foul now is contact then it's ideal, but what sort of game you'd have as a result makes the mind boggle.
0
Has the introduction of VAR improved decision making? on 13:01 - Oct 21 with 1062 views
Has the introduction of VAR improved decision making? on 12:48 - Oct 21 by Basuco
You must remember that it is the same prem referee's who find it impossible to be consistent about what is / is not a foul that find it equally impossible to be consistent when looking at a tv replay of an incident. The video refs just seem to back up the mistakes of the ref on the pitch, whereas it was expected that they would correct the errors. Shame as VAR is a very good idea that still manages to make a large number of basic errors in decisions.
This is apparently the hand ball law 'simplified'.
By continuing to use the site, you agree to our use of cookies and to abide by our Terms and Conditions.
