Please log in or register. Registered visitors get fewer ads.
Forum index | Previous Thread | Next thread
Lucy Letby. The doubt simply doesn't go away.... 23:43 - Feb 2 with 2792 viewsHugoagogo_Reborn



Whatever the answer, I hope it gets resolved asap. The poor, poor parents of those deceased babies, Lucy's parents, and Lucy herself all need this whole affair done and dusted.

There needs to be a thorough review, and soon.

Poll: Which Manchester team do you dislike the most?

5
Lucy Letby. The doubt simply doesn't go away.... on 21:06 - Feb 4 with 404 viewsEireannach_gorm

Lucy Letby. The doubt simply doesn't go away.... on 13:00 - Feb 4 by WeWereZombies

Yet another documentary about this case, this time on Netflix but here is the BBC summary:

https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/art

There is an element of unavoidable tragedy about how much attention and time the case takes up when one of the principal factors was understaffing, and in the wake of Steven Wright's confession on a conviction that was made from overwhelming circumstantial evidence we have to wonder what to make of the circumstantial evidence in this case.


Interesting observation from this article.

" We were understaffed - that's generally true in most departments on most wards on the NHS," he said. "But we had had those same staffing pressures before 2015 and 2016 and we'd not had those increased deaths then."
0
Lucy Letby. The doubt simply doesn't go away.... on 16:43 - Feb 5 with 282 viewsTresBonne

Just finished the Netflix doc while “working” from home.

Turning into a really messy situation by all accounts, the fact we work on a “beyond reasonable doubt” protocol - but there is an amount of doubt that seems to be growing over this.

For the record I still think she’s guilty, but I think she deserves a re trial.
0
Lucy Letby. The doubt simply doesn't go away.... on 19:45 - Feb 5 with 241 viewsMrPotatoHead

Much of the evidence might be circumstantial, but that doesn’t mean it’s not credible.

If there’s been a big miscarriage of justice then that’s obviously awful, I find it hard to believe though when you look at the substance of the evidence against her, circumstantial or otherwise.

I find it odd that her defence only called up the hospital cleaner, why wouldn’t they call someone medical or technical if the arguments against her were so paper thin?
0
Lucy Letby. The doubt simply doesn't go away.... on 20:00 - Feb 5 with 223 viewsRyorry

Lucy Letby. The doubt simply doesn't go away.... on 19:45 - Feb 5 by MrPotatoHead

Much of the evidence might be circumstantial, but that doesn’t mean it’s not credible.

If there’s been a big miscarriage of justice then that’s obviously awful, I find it hard to believe though when you look at the substance of the evidence against her, circumstantial or otherwise.

I find it odd that her defence only called up the hospital cleaner, why wouldn’t they call someone medical or technical if the arguments against her were so paper thin?


The bulk of it has actually been discredited by numerous experts at the top of their fields in statistics, neonatal medicine, anaesthesia, analysis of drugs including insulin, etc. etc.

Suggest you read, listen and view more widely, including previous threads on this on here. It’s all out there.

Poll: Town's most cultured left foot ever?

-2
Lucy Letby. The doubt simply doesn't go away.... on 20:10 - Feb 5 with 209 viewsMrPotatoHead

Lucy Letby. The doubt simply doesn't go away.... on 20:00 - Feb 5 by Ryorry

The bulk of it has actually been discredited by numerous experts at the top of their fields in statistics, neonatal medicine, anaesthesia, analysis of drugs including insulin, etc. etc.

Suggest you read, listen and view more widely, including previous threads on this on here. It’s all out there.


And I suggest you don’t make assumptions about how familiar people are with the case.

Why didn’t her defence call up any experts? what was the purpose of calling the cleaner to the box?
1
Lucy Letby. The doubt simply doesn't go away.... on 20:14 - Feb 5 with 200 viewsRyorry

Lucy Letby. The doubt simply doesn't go away.... on 20:10 - Feb 5 by MrPotatoHead

And I suggest you don’t make assumptions about how familiar people are with the case.

Why didn’t her defence call up any experts? what was the purpose of calling the cleaner to the box?


Your ”familiarity with the case doesn’t seem to have extended as far as reading the first page of this thread, where your question was answered multiple times.

Poll: Town's most cultured left foot ever?

0
Lucy Letby. The doubt simply doesn't go away.... on 20:35 - Feb 5 with 170 viewsMrPotatoHead

Lucy Letby. The doubt simply doesn't go away.... on 20:14 - Feb 5 by Ryorry

Your ”familiarity with the case doesn’t seem to have extended as far as reading the first page of this thread, where your question was answered multiple times.


There are more reliable sources than you spouting nonsense on a TWTD thread.
-1
Lucy Letby. The doubt simply doesn't go away.... on 21:04 - Feb 5 with 147 viewsRyorry

Lucy Letby. The doubt simply doesn't go away.... on 20:35 - Feb 5 by MrPotatoHead

There are more reliable sources than you spouting nonsense on a TWTD thread.


When you call ”nonsense“ is what hundreds of those experts from all around the world have said and written, no more no less.

I still prefer the “nonsense” that they “spouted” to yours, thanks.

Poll: Town's most cultured left foot ever?

0
Login to get fewer ads

Lucy Letby. The doubt simply doesn't go away.... on 21:21 - Feb 5 with 128 viewscoote

Lucy Letby. The doubt simply doesn't go away.... on 21:04 - Feb 5 by Ryorry

When you call ”nonsense“ is what hundreds of those experts from all around the world have said and written, no more no less.

I still prefer the “nonsense” that they “spouted” to yours, thanks.


She doesn’t deserve a retrial. Anyone who watched that doc and thought she wasn’t guilty needs to have their head looked at.
[Post edited 5 Feb 21:21]
0
Lucy Letby. The doubt simply doesn't go away.... on 21:33 - Feb 5 with 104 viewsredrickstuhaart

Lucy Letby. The doubt simply doesn't go away.... on 21:04 - Feb 5 by Ryorry

When you call ”nonsense“ is what hundreds of those experts from all around the world have said and written, no more no less.

I still prefer the “nonsense” that they “spouted” to yours, thanks.


Hundreds?

Name them.

And as has been pointed out several times, the conviction was not just on the medical evidence.

Poll: Will the US Mid terms get cancelled or "postponed"?

0
Lucy Letby. The doubt simply doesn't go away.... on 21:44 - Feb 5 with 93 viewsbartyg

Lucy Letby. The doubt simply doesn't go away.... on 21:04 - Feb 5 by Ryorry

When you call ”nonsense“ is what hundreds of those experts from all around the world have said and written, no more no less.

I still prefer the “nonsense” that they “spouted” to yours, thanks.


Repeating that there are hundreds of experts that agree with you without giving any sources is very compelling
1
Lucy Letby. The doubt simply doesn't go away.... on 23:31 - Feb 5 with 29 viewsRyorry

Lucy Letby. The doubt simply doesn't go away.... on 21:44 - Feb 5 by bartyg

Repeating that there are hundreds of experts that agree with you without giving any sources is very compelling


Sorry, I made the mistake of assuming that everyone replying to my “nonsense” had gone into the case sufficiently themselves to be aware of the mass of evidence that has been widely available in the public domain for the past 6-12 months.

https://www.theguardian.com/uk

https://www.bmj.com/content/38

https://jollycontrarian.com/in

https://www.expertcourtreports

https://www.private-eye.co.uk/

https://www.bbc.com/news/artic

There’s more out there, I don’t have the time right now but I’m sure most on here are capable of searching if they wish to.

Poll: Town's most cultured left foot ever?

1
About Us Contact Us Terms & Conditions Privacy Cookies Online Safety Advertising
© TWTD 1995-2026