Please log in or register. Registered visitors get fewer ads.
Forum index | Previous Thread | Next thread
My god, what a mess they have made of an effective and simple rule 21:34 - May 28 with 859 viewsZXBlue

Offside contains an element of intent? FFS
[Post edited 28 May 2022 21:35]
1
My god, what a mess they have made of an effective and simple rule on 21:36 - May 28 with 827 viewsDubtractor

I'd like to see Liverpool win, but how can that be offside? It's not like it was a deflection of a Madrid pass was it? It was a clean contact off his knee.

I was born underwater, I dried out in the sun. I started humping volcanoes baby, when I was too young.
Poll: Important Christmas poll - which is the best Celebration chocolate?

1
My god, what a mess they have made of an effective and simple rule on 21:36 - May 28 with 817 viewsVic

Exactly! Glad I’m not playing now.

Poll: Right now, who would you rather have as Prime Minister?

0
My god, what a mess they have made of an effective and simple rule on 21:36 - May 28 with 818 viewsMarshalls_Mullet

There was intent.

Fabinho was sliding in to get the ball, his touch sends it to benzema.

It wasnt a deflection in any shape or form.

I think the ref in the studio has it wrong, there is not way that offside would only apply if he intentionally played it to Benzema.

Poll: Would Lambert have acheived better results than Cook if given the same resources

0
My god, what a mess they have made of an effective and simple rule on 21:37 - May 28 with 814 viewsgtsb1966

I still prefer the "clear daylight" rule of days gone by. So much easier to implement.
3
My god, what a mess they have made of an effective and simple rule on 21:37 - May 28 with 811 viewsMarshalls_Mullet

My god, what a mess they have made of an effective and simple rule on 21:36 - May 28 by Dubtractor

I'd like to see Liverpool win, but how can that be offside? It's not like it was a deflection of a Madrid pass was it? It was a clean contact off his knee.


This.

Poll: Would Lambert have acheived better results than Cook if given the same resources

0
My god, what a mess they have made of an effective and simple rule on 21:41 - May 28 with 758 viewsheavyweight

When did the 'intentional' part come into laws, its not how I remember it from my refereeing days.

It has to be an intentional pass from an opponent for it to be onside, that has got to be a fairly rare occurrence.
1
My god, what a mess they have made of an effective and simple rule on 21:41 - May 28 with 754 viewscbower

The rule nowadays is nuts but I think the initial touch forward is from the Madrid player and that's when he was offside, nothing to do with Fabihno touch imo.

bluescouser

0
My god, what a mess they have made of an effective and simple rule on 21:45 - May 28 with 718 viewsNthsuffolkblue

My god, what a mess they have made of an effective and simple rule on 21:41 - May 28 by cbower

The rule nowadays is nuts but I think the initial touch forward is from the Madrid player and that's when he was offside, nothing to do with Fabihno touch imo.


That would be the most sensible interpretation but the Madrid player doesn't manage to play it, there is a block as he tries to and then ball breaks before coming off Fabinho's knee. If that all comes to a forward pass from Madrid, fair enough but I didn't see it that way. Further, the ref is the studio said it is offside if it deflects off the defender but onside if the defender deliberately plays it. That bit is plain bizarre.

Poll: How do you feel about the re-election of Trump?
Blog: [Blog] Ghostbusters

0
Login to get fewer ads

My god, what a mess they have made of an effective and simple rule on 21:49 - May 28 with 695 viewsstonojnr

I dont get if all the intent stuff is involved, and seriously way to make offside even harder than handball to understand, why did the replay show the lines on the pitch suggesting there was only a toe nail in it.

because if its about intent of the pass, it doesnt matter if he is millimetres, centimetres or a metre offside surely its then about the intent of the pass ?

if Liverpool had scored that goal Im sure the assembled TV pundits, apart from Rio who is just as confused as the rest of us about it, would have been screaming that Liverpool had been robbed of a goal there.
0




About Us Contact Us Terms & Conditions Privacy Cookies Online Safety Advertising
© TWTD 1995-2025