| Not sure Plymouth fans like us very much on 08:41 - Nov 22 with 1117 views | tractordownsouth |
| Not sure Plymouth fans like us very much on 08:33 - Nov 22 by LeoMuff |
Unless they could use £750-£1m to put towards someone else, and the player fancies a pay rise…. |
No way will Swansea sell him. |  |
|  |
| I was reading that earlier.... on 08:44 - Nov 22 with 1111 views | GeoffSentence |
| I was reading that earlier.... on 22:18 - Nov 21 by Bloots |
....most of their angst seems to be directed at our Phil.
Outrageous accusations. |
He's arrogant apparently.
Phil does have a certain swagger, but do we think it ever steps into arrogance? I'm not so sure.
Actually, I was trying to work out what that poster thought was arrogant, all I can think of is the observation that Town could probably pay a bit more of Whittaker's wages. |  |
| |
| Not sure Plymouth fans like us very much on 09:12 - Nov 22 with 1065 views | Dyland |
If the shoe was on the other foot and all that.
The slamming Hammers aspect aside, which you can put down to ignorance, they have a point. It seems a deliberate ploy to unsettle the club/player, surely no party other than ITFC would benefit from the switch? |  |
| |
| Not sure Plymouth fans like us very much on 09:20 - Nov 22 with 1040 views | Keno |
| Not sure Plymouth fans like us very much on 09:12 - Nov 22 by Dyland |
If the shoe was on the other foot and all that.
The slamming Hammers aspect aside, which you can put down to ignorance, they have a point. It seems a deliberate ploy to unsettle the club/player, surely no party other than ITFC would benefit from the switch? |
Are you suggesting Phil is acting as some kind of agent provocateur?
Not actually sure that’s an image I want to conjure up |  |
| |
| Not sure Plymouth fans like us very much on 09:21 - Nov 22 with 1035 views | Dyland |
| Not sure Plymouth fans like us very much on 09:20 - Nov 22 by Keno |
Are you suggesting Phil is acting as some kind of agent provocateur?
Not actually sure that’s an image I want to conjure up |
PHWOOOOAR!!!
Nope, Hammers and TWTD are a pretty sound media source as you well know yer tinker yer.
Is da club innit cuz. | |
| |
| Not sure Plymouth fans like us very much on 09:24 - Nov 22 with 1025 views | CityBlue |
Swansea still owe us money from the Flynn Downes deal so could be an ideal bargaining tool |  |
| |
| Not sure Plymouth fans like us very much on 09:27 - Nov 22 with 1014 views | cbower |
Agree with their sentiments if it were purely to be a loan. A loan with a buy on promotion clause at an agreed fee or an outright purchase now would be different. Happened to us with Ryan Tunnicliffe and it's what we did with Kieffer Moore |  |
| |
| Not sure Plymouth fans like us very much on 09:31 - Nov 22 with 989 views | ArnoldMoorhen |
| Not sure Plymouth fans like us very much on 22:57 - Nov 21 by HighgateBlue |
If I were Whittaker, I'd probably agree with them. He's doing well there, he's getting games, it's good for his development. Who's to say the same would happen here? If a loan is going well, there's a lot to be said for leaving well alone.
See also: Simpson, T
Having said that, I'd love him here, and all's fair in love and league one... |
Here is my recollection: Simpson's loan was going well until his manager there got him to ask for a permanent move. ITFC weren't happy about that and ended the loan. Simpson wasn't happy about that. Impasse.
I think ITFC were right to not be messed about by a club that we were loaning to. Ashton has a "I just won't deal with them in the future" approach, I believe. |  | | |
Login to get fewer ads
| Not sure Plymouth fans like us very much on 09:51 - Nov 22 with 932 views | Keno |
| Not sure Plymouth fans like us very much on 09:21 - Nov 22 by Dyland |
PHWOOOOAR!!!
Nope, Hammers and TWTD are a pretty sound media source as you well know yer tinker yer.
Is da club innit cuz. |
I just hope no-one does one of those photo-shopped images of Phil .... | |
| |
| Not sure Plymouth fans like us very much on 09:58 - Nov 22 with 914 views | PhilTWTD |
| Not sure Plymouth fans like us very much on 09:31 - Nov 22 by ArnoldMoorhen |
Here is my recollection: Simpson's loan was going well until his manager there got him to ask for a permanent move. ITFC weren't happy about that and ended the loan. Simpson wasn't happy about that. Impasse.
I think ITFC were right to not be messed about by a club that we were loaning to. Ashton has a "I just won't deal with them in the future" approach, I believe. |
Swindon didn't ask for a permanent move. Town offered Simpson a contract which he turned down. We recalled him to persuade him to sign it. If he'd have signed it he'd have gone back. |  | | |
| Not sure Plymouth fans like us very much on 11:09 - Nov 22 with 808 views | Broadhill |
They dont realise that if its written on here its usually got some legs 99% of the time. Its not very often waffle.
For me, l think he should stay where he is. If he moved on to us whos to say his form doesnt go out the window.lf he is happy he should stay put. |  | | |
| |
By continuing to use the site, you agree to our use of cookies and to abide by our Terms and Conditions.
