| Ranking our recent goalkeepers 17:51 - Dec 22 with 1745 views | ringwoodblue |
Out of our recent goalkeepers Gerken, Norris, Bialkowski, Cornell, Holy, Walton, Hladky and Muric, how would you rank them?
I’d say : Best - Hladky, Bialkowski, Walton, Muric, Holy, Norris, Cornell and Worst : Gerken
[Post edited 22 Dec 2024 17:52]
|  |
| |  |
| Ranking our recent goalkeepers on 17:56 - Dec 22 with 1666 views | Scuzzer |
Bartman was the best out of those. Then Hlad the impaler.
Walton then take your pick. |  |
| |
| Ranking our recent goalkeepers on 18:00 - Dec 22 with 1619 views | positivity |
tricky given the quality of opposition.
i'd break it down to the league, so
prem: muric,walton
champ: bart, hladky, gerken
l1:walton, holy, norris, cornell
overall: bart |  |
| |
| Ranking our recent goalkeepers on 18:04 - Dec 22 with 1591 views | olimar |
Its hard to compare as some were being asked to play a completely different type of game.
If Hladcky was playing for a MM team, then he would probably not look all that great, as he didnt have much presence in his own box and was a very good if not amazing shot stopper.
Bart, by contrast, was exceptional as a shot stopper in a MM team, but not sure how he would have fared playing ball out in a KM team.
In terms of ability to stop goals, first and foremost, Bart, Muric, Walton, Hladky then any of the others below them.
In terms of ability to create goals, Hladcky, Muric, Walton and Norris are possibly the only ones who showed they could do it (in that order?).
In any team, asked to played any way, Holy is last. | | | |
| Ranking our recent goalkeepers on 18:11 - Dec 22 with 1523 views | RobTheMonk |
Bart and Hladky tied for me. Bart saved stuff that should have been saveable. Let down my distribution.
Hladky was an underrated shot stopper and very good with his grey. Didn't like claiming crosses and often punched ones that looked easy.
Muric had all the pieces to be an exceptional keeper, but those pieces sometimes fall out at random intervals. |  | | |
| Ranking our recent goalkeepers on 18:18 - Dec 22 with 1491 views | Churchman |
Bart was far and away the best keeper of that little lot. No 2 Walton. He’s a proper goalkeeper. 3. Muric. Controversial but he actually comes for the ball and looks the real deal.. Errors? Too many, but for a keeper he’s quite young and he will learn. Stay with him. 4. Hladky. Great against mediocre Championship teams with time on his side. Decent shot stopper.
The rest? Forget it. |  | | |
| Ranking our recent goalkeepers on 18:32 - Dec 22 with 1434 views | Tampa_Florida_Blue |
| Ranking our recent goalkeepers on 18:18 - Dec 22 by Churchman |
Bart was far and away the best keeper of that little lot. No 2 Walton. He’s a proper goalkeeper. 3. Muric. Controversial but he actually comes for the ball and looks the real deal.. Errors? Too many, but for a keeper he’s quite young and he will learn. Stay with him. 4. Hladky. Great against mediocre Championship teams with time on his side. Decent shot stopper.
The rest? Forget it. |
I agree with your comment regarding Muric. But part of me feels we need to be given a couple of games to catch some thoughts. Put Walton in for the gunners and chelsea, which I dont see as any thing to lose, But togive Muric some rest. If Muric stays in, let him be allowed to throw the ball out past the halfway line. Stop making it so predictable and easy to close us down in our half |  | | |
| Ranking our recent goalkeepers on 18:37 - Dec 22 with 1405 views | tcblue |
| Ranking our recent goalkeepers on 18:32 - Dec 22 by Tampa_Florida_Blue |
I agree with your comment regarding Muric. But part of me feels we need to be given a couple of games to catch some thoughts. Put Walton in for the gunners and chelsea, which I dont see as any thing to lose, But togive Muric some rest. If Muric stays in, let him be allowed to throw the ball out past the halfway line. Stop making it so predictable and easy to close us down in our half |
Hi Christian, we're going to build up your confidence by putting you in two games we don't expect a result in.
Is that how you'd phrase it? | | | |
| Ranking our recent goalkeepers on 18:39 - Dec 22 with 1385 views | FifeITFC |
I'd have Bart as best.
Probably Holy, Morris or Cornell as worst, below Gerken and even Loach. |  |
| |
Login to get fewer ads
| Ranking our recent goalkeepers on 18:54 - Dec 22 with 1310 views | Tampa_Florida_Blue |
| Ranking our recent goalkeepers on 18:37 - Dec 22 by tcblue |
Hi Christian, we're going to build up your confidence by putting you in two games we don't expect a result in.
Is that how you'd phrase it? |
I dont recall Walton looking that out of place against Liverpool | | | |
| Ranking our recent goalkeepers on 19:39 - Dec 22 with 1116 views | DavoIPB |
They all have different attributes. In terms of what goal keepers used to be ranked on i.e savings shots, handling and catching crosses then Muric would be well in the lead followed closely by Bart. Hladky pulled off some good saves but couldn't catch a cross and Walton is very average at all of them. | | | |
| Ranking our recent goalkeepers on 19:56 - Dec 22 with 1051 views | WestSussexBlue |
| Ranking our recent goalkeepers on 18:54 - Dec 22 by Tampa_Florida_Blue |
I dont recall Walton looking that out of place against Liverpool |
Sorry meant to upvote 👍 | | | |
| Ranking our recent goalkeepers on 20:06 - Dec 22 with 1020 views | Libero |
From best to worst…
Bilakowski
Hladky
Walton
Muric
Holy
Cornell
Norris
Gerken [Post edited 22 Dec 2024 20:06]
|  | | |
| |
By continuing to use the site, you agree to our use of cookies and to abide by our Terms and Conditions.
