| Club developed player 23:16 - Sep 12 with 2993 views | leftback |
Aren’t we supposed to include one in the squad? |  | | |  |
| Club developed player on 23:17 - Sep 12 with 2617 views | pointofblue |
One in the 25 - who I presume is Humphreys. | |
| |
| Club developed player on 23:17 - Sep 12 with 2595 views | Tonytown |
There has to be one in the 25 man squad. We have 2 Humphreys & Baggot | | | |
| Club developed player on 23:18 - Sep 12 with 2586 views | FrimleyBlue |
Only if you want 9 subs I believe |  |
| |
| Club developed player on 23:18 - Sep 12 with 2580 views | _clive_baker_ |
I thought that was a rule if you want to have 9 subs, but I might’ve made that up. |  | | |
| Club developed player on 23:18 - Sep 12 with 2566 views | _clive_baker_ |
| Club developed player on 23:18 - Sep 12 by FrimleyBlue |
Only if you want 9 subs I believe |
We did, didn’t we? | | | |
| Club developed player on 23:20 - Sep 12 with 2527 views | FrimleyBlue |
| Club developed player on 23:18 - Sep 12 by _clive_baker_ |
We did, didn’t we? |
Think 8. Unless I really can't count lol. | |
| |
| Club developed player on 23:20 - Sep 12 with 2520 views | WeWereZombies |
| Club developed player on 23:18 - Sep 12 by _clive_baker_ |
We did, didn’t we? |
Yep, just checked. Do Sindre's tender years make him a development player ? |  |
| |
| Club developed player on 23:22 - Sep 12 with 2472 views | FrimleyBlue |
| Club developed player on 23:20 - Sep 12 by WeWereZombies |
Yep, just checked. Do Sindre's tender years make him a development player ? |
Oh I can't count lol. | |
| |
Login to get fewer ads
| Club developed player on 23:23 - Sep 12 with 2456 views | _clive_baker_ |
| Club developed player on 23:20 - Sep 12 by WeWereZombies |
Yep, just checked. Do Sindre's tender years make him a development player ? |
Let’s go with that.
Otherwise, shhh. | | | |
| Club developed player on 23:25 - Sep 12 with 2428 views | positivity |
| Club developed player on 23:18 - Sep 12 by _clive_baker_ |
I thought that was a rule if you want to have 9 subs, but I might’ve made that up. |
the rule is you have to have at least one player in your 25 man squad. we have two.
it makes no difference if they're on the bench or not | |
| |
| Club developed player on 23:29 - Sep 12 with 2359 views | _clive_baker_ |
| Club developed player on 23:25 - Sep 12 by positivity |
the rule is you have to have at least one player in your 25 man squad. we have two.
it makes no difference if they're on the bench or not |
In all three EFL leagues, clubs have to name at least seven home grown players among their matchday squad for any one game.
Clubs also need to name at least one club developed player in their matchday squad; if they don't, they must name one fewer player on their bench.
https://www.fourfourtwo.com/features/what-are-the-efl-squad-rules-for-202425-loa
Might’ve changed since last season. | | | |
| Club developed player on 00:55 - Sep 13 with 1965 views | bournemouthblue |
We had 9 on the bench today, is there someone in the matchday squad who doesn't make it? |  |
| |
| Club developed player on 06:41 - Sep 13 with 1387 views | SuffolkPunchFC |
Except it not matchday but entire declared squad. Article 34.11 of the current EFL rules. | | | |
| Club developed player on 06:52 - Sep 13 with 1329 views | franz_tyson |
| Club developed player on 06:41 - Sep 13 by SuffolkPunchFC |
Except it not matchday but entire declared squad. Article 34.11 of the current EFL rules. |
Not really much of an incentive to bring through academy players when you just have to name just one academy player in the 25, and he never even makes the matchday squad to get the full allocation of 9 subs. | | | |
| Club developed player on 07:40 - Sep 13 with 1164 views | SuffolkPunchFC |
| Club developed player on 06:52 - Sep 13 by franz_tyson |
Not really much of an incentive to bring through academy players when you just have to name just one academy player in the 25, and he never even makes the matchday squad to get the full allocation of 9 subs. |
I agree that the balance is wrong, but I’m just pointing out what the rules are as written. Lots of people confuse Homegrown and Club Developed, and what the actual requirement for matchday/squad list are.
It’s all in the EFL handbook for checking  | | | |
| Club developed player on 08:03 - Sep 13 with 991 views | _clive_baker_ |
| Club developed player on 07:40 - Sep 13 by SuffolkPunchFC |
I agree that the balance is wrong, but I’m just pointing out what the rules are as written. Lots of people confuse Homegrown and Club Developed, and what the actual requirement for matchday/squad list are.
It’s all in the EFL handbook for checking |
I’m aware of the distinction between squads and matchday squads, and homegrown vs club developed (must’ve been at Town for a year prior to their 19th birthday) but the article I shared implied this:
‘Clubs also need to name at least one club developed player in their matchday squad; if they don't, they must name one fewer player on their bench’.
We didn’t in ours last night, but still had the full 9 subs. If that article is wrong then fair enough, I’ve not seen the official laws, was just going off that from FourFourTwo, which admittedly is a year old so maybe out of date (or just incorrect). | | | |
| Club developed player on 08:12 - Sep 13 with 942 views | WeWereZombies |
| Club developed player on 06:52 - Sep 13 by franz_tyson |
Not really much of an incentive to bring through academy players when you just have to name just one academy player in the 25, and he never even makes the matchday squad to get the full allocation of 9 subs. |
I agree, partly, but as the season wears on and injuries take their toll (other cliches are available...cliche that that is) I can see an incentive to bring club developed players through and at least give them a place on the bench. I think we are allowed to do that if they were under twenty one at the start of the calendar year, aren't we ? Or does there have to be an 'r' in the month ? Uranus sits in Sagittarius ? To be honest I'm still a bit worried that someone at the EFL is setting out the tarot this morning and is about to deal the death card on last night's game. | |
| |
| Club developed player on 08:23 - Sep 13 with 858 views | NthQldITFC |
| Club developed player on 06:41 - Sep 13 by SuffolkPunchFC |
Except it not matchday but entire declared squad. Article 34.11 of the current EFL rules. |
I made the effort to read that so I understand you and others to be right. What I don't understand is why they talk about the Squad List OR the Team List. Shirley, to be in the Team List you have to be in the Squad List? OR am I barking up the wrong tree completely? Or completely barking? |  |
| |
| Club developed player on 08:35 - Sep 13 with 806 views | franz_tyson |
| Club developed player on 08:23 - Sep 13 by NthQldITFC |
I made the effort to read that so I understand you and others to be right. What I don't understand is why they talk about the Squad List OR the Team List. Shirley, to be in the Team List you have to be in the Squad List? OR am I barking up the wrong tree completely? Or completely barking? |
I just think they make the rule so slack it's so easy to avoid using academy players. Even the wording " home-grown" player is confusing. Means a player who comes through the system in any team in the UK.
Why not enforce it that if you want 9 subs... make sure you have a club developed player in the matchday squad. ie Humphreys instead of Taylor, for instance. Or stick an under 21 as a sub. Laws seem to be in place more as a get around. | | | |
| Club developed player on 08:47 - Sep 13 with 741 views | Pinewoodblue |
This was discussed on TWTD recently with Phil saying there had to be a club developed player in the 25 player squad.
Personally would be happier if could find this in black and white.
Google AI, which I suppose is a glorified search engine, doesn’t agree with Phil
“In the EFL Championship, clubs must include a "club-developed player" in their matchday squad, which is defined as a player registered with the club for at least a year before the end of their Under-19 season. Failure to do so results in the club being allowed to name only six substitutes instead of the standard seven or nine. “
If Google AI is right we broke the rules last night. |  |
| |
| Club developed player on 08:50 - Sep 13 with 722 views | NthQldITFC |
| Club developed player on 08:47 - Sep 13 by Pinewoodblue |
This was discussed on TWTD recently with Phil saying there had to be a club developed player in the 25 player squad.
Personally would be happier if could find this in black and white.
Google AI, which I suppose is a glorified search engine, doesn’t agree with Phil
“In the EFL Championship, clubs must include a "club-developed player" in their matchday squad, which is defined as a player registered with the club for at least a year before the end of their Under-19 season. Failure to do so results in the club being allowed to name only six substitutes instead of the standard seven or nine. “
If Google AI is right we broke the rules last night. |
In the immortal words of the great Sean Lock, "...well, Google... can go fk itself!" | |
| |
| Club developed player on 08:57 - Sep 13 with 677 views | MrBeckinsale |
| Club developed player on 08:35 - Sep 13 by franz_tyson |
I just think they make the rule so slack it's so easy to avoid using academy players. Even the wording " home-grown" player is confusing. Means a player who comes through the system in any team in the UK.
Why not enforce it that if you want 9 subs... make sure you have a club developed player in the matchday squad. ie Humphreys instead of Taylor, for instance. Or stick an under 21 as a sub. Laws seem to be in place more as a get around. |
But what would be the point of sticking one on there, that isn’t likely to make the pitch from the probable substitutions… what is the benefit of having 9 over just having 8 and not bothering? | | | |
| Club developed player on 09:15 - Sep 13 with 594 views | WeWereZombies |
| Club developed player on 08:47 - Sep 13 by Pinewoodblue |
This was discussed on TWTD recently with Phil saying there had to be a club developed player in the 25 player squad.
Personally would be happier if could find this in black and white.
Google AI, which I suppose is a glorified search engine, doesn’t agree with Phil
“In the EFL Championship, clubs must include a "club-developed player" in their matchday squad, which is defined as a player registered with the club for at least a year before the end of their Under-19 season. Failure to do so results in the club being allowed to name only six substitutes instead of the standard seven or nine. “
If Google AI is right we broke the rules last night. |
As far as I can see all that AI does is go on a superfast and superextensive trawl through the data that it owns, if the data is wrong there is no intelligent process at work to question that. | |
| |
| Club developed player on 09:39 - Sep 13 with 513 views | WeWereZombies |
| Club developed player on 08:47 - Sep 13 by Pinewoodblue |
This was discussed on TWTD recently with Phil saying there had to be a club developed player in the 25 player squad.
Personally would be happier if could find this in black and white.
Google AI, which I suppose is a glorified search engine, doesn’t agree with Phil
“In the EFL Championship, clubs must include a "club-developed player" in their matchday squad, which is defined as a player registered with the club for at least a year before the end of their Under-19 season. Failure to do so results in the club being allowed to name only six substitutes instead of the standard seven or nine. “
If Google AI is right we broke the rules last night. |
Where's Finidi when you need him... | |
| |
| |
By continuing to use the site, you agree to our use of cookies and to abide by our Terms and Conditions.
