| Carroll 07:33 - Sep 10 with 1590 views | tractorboy1978 |
Is he too good not to force his way into this side? It's funny really because his signing has slipped somewhat under the radar given the number we've signed, however, in terms of pedigree he's arguably the most impressive of the lot. May not be a sexy signing but he's a player with pushing 100 Premier League appearances under his belt and by all accounts QPR's best player before his injury last year. |  | | |  |
| Carroll on 09:19 - Sep 10 with 1424 views | jayessess |
I wonder if we might see him Tomorrow, actually. Evans isn't anywhere near Carroll on the ball and off the ball he's been nowhere near it so far. |  |
| |
| Carroll on 09:24 - Sep 10 with 1408 views | BondiBlue |
Agree. Morsy and Carroll will surely end the season as the two (injuries permitting and a stratospheric improvement from Harper notwithstanding) | |
| |
| Carroll on 09:28 - Sep 10 with 1382 views | chicoazul |
| Carroll on 09:24 - Sep 10 by BondiBlue |
Agree. Morsy and Carroll will surely end the season as the two (injuries permitting and a stratospheric improvement from Harper notwithstanding) |
Maybe, but Cook has wanted to reunite Evans and Morsy since he arrived. They played d something like 80 games together. I like Carroll but he is very much a slick ball player not a grafter based on the few times I’ve seen him. |  |
| |
| Carroll on 09:29 - Sep 10 with 1382 views | Skip_Intro |
He's clearly a very good player. I just wonder whether he is physical enough to play the type of Cm role that PC's system needs... |  | | |
| Carroll on 09:32 - Sep 10 with 1372 views | rfretwell |
| Carroll on 09:24 - Sep 10 by BondiBlue |
Agree. Morsy and Carroll will surely end the season as the two (injuries permitting and a stratospheric improvement from Harper notwithstanding) |
Carroll's experience and pedigree shines through when he does get on. He immediately directs and organises teammates around him. Hes excellent at retaining the ball and laying off to a blue shirt. He could well play a much bigger part than he has so far. | | | |
| Carroll on 09:33 - Sep 10 with 1362 views | jayessess |
| Carroll on 09:28 - Sep 10 by chicoazul |
Maybe, but Cook has wanted to reunite Evans and Morsy since he arrived. They played d something like 80 games together. I like Carroll but he is very much a slick ball player not a grafter based on the few times I’ve seen him. |
He's been signed as one of the 2 pivots though, so surely Cook thinks he can definitely play there. Evans' defensive stats at the moment read 0 interceptions, a feeble 0.6 tackles per game, whilst also leading the team on fouls and number of times dribbled past, so we're not exactly losing a lot of defensive work if we drop him. | |
| |
| Carroll on 09:54 - Sep 10 with 1274 views | itfcsuth |
I still don't see why Evans & Harper have come in for so much stick (exc. Evans error v MK).
I think they are a decent pair, both physically very well built, technically good, and have a decent balance to them.
They do probably lack that defensive instinct that Morsy will bring.
Pairing for me needs to be - Morsy + Harper /or Morsy + Evans |  | | |
| Carroll on 10:39 - Sep 10 with 1210 views | jayessess |
| Carroll on 09:54 - Sep 10 by itfcsuth |
I still don't see why Evans & Harper have come in for so much stick (exc. Evans error v MK).
I think they are a decent pair, both physically very well built, technically good, and have a decent balance to them.
They do probably lack that defensive instinct that Morsy will bring.
Pairing for me needs to be - Morsy + Harper /or Morsy + Evans |
Well probably because they've barely made a tackle between them so far. | |
| |
Login to get fewer ads
| Carroll on 11:17 - Sep 10 with 1135 views | BondiBlue |
| Carroll on 09:33 - Sep 10 by jayessess |
He's been signed as one of the 2 pivots though, so surely Cook thinks he can definitely play there. Evans' defensive stats at the moment read 0 interceptions, a feeble 0.6 tackles per game, whilst also leading the team on fouls and number of times dribbled past, so we're not exactly losing a lot of defensive work if we drop him. |
I was going to say the same thing - cook must think he can play there or he wouldn't have signed him. I understand why it's sensible to have two units in there but personally i'd always have a ball-player first and foremost. And yes, i was a big fan of andre dozzell. | |
| |
| Carroll on 11:37 - Sep 10 with 1097 views | jayessess |
| Carroll on 11:17 - Sep 10 by BondiBlue |
I was going to say the same thing - cook must think he can play there or he wouldn't have signed him. I understand why it's sensible to have two units in there but personally i'd always have a ball-player first and foremost. And yes, i was a big fan of andre dozzell. |
People thought Dozzell was poor defensively but his 2020-21 defensive stats look pretty decent in comparison to Harper and Evans so far (the comparison with Downes is even more painful).
Tackles
Dozzell 1.7
Harper 0.8
Evans 0.6
Interceptions
Dozzell 1.5
Harper 0.6
Evans 0
Fouls
Evans 2.6
Dozzell 2
Harper 0.4
Dribbled past
Evans 1.2
Dozzell 0.5
Harper 0.2 [Post edited 10 Sep 2021 17:06]
| |
| |
| Carroll on 12:56 - Sep 10 with 965 views | itfcjoe |
He seems to be a bit of a forgotten man - despite having the best pedigree out of any of our signings |  |
| |
| Carroll on 12:59 - Sep 10 with 958 views | itfcjoe |
| Carroll on 11:37 - Sep 10 by jayessess |
People thought Dozzell was poor defensively but his 2020-21 defensive stats look pretty decent in comparison to Harper and Evans so far (the comparison with Downes is even more painful).
Tackles
Dozzell 1.7
Harper 0.8
Evans 0.6
Interceptions
Dozzell 1.5
Harper 0.6
Evans 0
Fouls
Evans 2.6
Dozzell 2
Harper 0.4
Dribbled past
Evans 1.2
Dozzell 0.5
Harper 0.2 [Post edited 10 Sep 2021 17:06]
|
Evans has won just 20% of his midfield duels, there is one other CM relatively close to him, but 3rd on the list is miles away from him - has been really poor (Morecambe aside) | |
| |
| Carroll on 13:31 - Sep 10 with 869 views | HighgateBlue |
| Carroll on 09:28 - Sep 10 by chicoazul |
Maybe, but Cook has wanted to reunite Evans and Morsy since he arrived. They played d something like 80 games together. I like Carroll but he is very much a slick ball player not a grafter based on the few times I’ve seen him. |
It would be crazy to think that both Harper and Carroll wouldn't be good enough to get into a L1 side in that scenario. If that's what comes to pass, and we finish top 6 though, who cares?! |  | | |
| |
By continuing to use the site, you agree to our use of cookies and to abide by our Terms and Conditions.
