| They were clearly retaking that corner until they scored... 15:20 - May 10 with 1874 views | Zx1988 |
Baffling. |  |
| |  |
| They were clearly retaking that corner until they scored... on 15:22 - May 10 with 1816 views | TractorWood |
Not sure what the moaning is about. No penalty given, Taylor not sent off.
Just can't defend. Reason we are down. |  |
| |
| They were clearly retaking that corner until they scored... on 15:22 - May 10 with 1793 views | Durovigutum |
I’m sitting in the west stand in line with the penalty spot. I’m a referee. In law that was absolutely terrible. You can’t give a yellow card for pushing if the ball is not in play and it’s not reckless. |  | | |
| They were clearly retaking that corner until they scored... on 15:24 - May 10 with 1727 views | acj |
Both aborted corners saw grappling and fouls committed before the ball came into play, so corner was retaken. Ref’s got that correct.
Set piece defending has been an annoying Achilles heel this year! |  |
| |
| They were clearly retaking that corner until they scored... on 15:24 - May 10 with 1708 views | tonybied |
1-0 to the referee! |  | | |
| They were clearly retaking that corner until they scored... on 15:26 - May 10 with 1655 views | Zx1988 |
| They were clearly retaking that corner until they scored... on 15:24 - May 10 by acj |
Both aborted corners saw grappling and fouls committed before the ball came into play, so corner was retaken. Ref’s got that correct.
Set piece defending has been an annoying Achilles heel this year! |
I appreciate that. But, if the ball hadn't gone live, there were no grounds for the penalty check against Greaves.
Once that check had failed, the corner should have been considered taken. | |
| |
| They were clearly retaking that corner until they scored... on 15:28 - May 10 with 1602 views | acj |
| They were clearly retaking that corner until they scored... on 15:26 - May 10 by Zx1988 |
I appreciate that. But, if the ball hadn't gone live, there were no grounds for the penalty check against Greaves.
Once that check had failed, the corner should have been considered taken. |
Ref had already blown to retake the corner, thinking (correctly) ball hadn’t come into play when the foul was committed. VAR were checking whether ball was in play already when Greaves pulled him down - verified it wasn’t, so original decision stood and corner was retaken. | |
| |
| They were clearly retaking that corner until they scored... on 15:50 - May 10 with 1326 views | Trequartista |
Until the rules are changed on corner-wrestling we're going to get all this nonsense again and again. |  |
| |
| They were clearly retaking that corner until they scored... on 15:51 - May 10 with 1290 views | homer_123 |
| They were clearly retaking that corner until they scored... on 15:22 - May 10 by TractorWood |
Not sure what the moaning is about. No penalty given, Taylor not sent off.
Just can't defend. Reason we are down. |
First corner. Ball was 'in play' before Ref blew.
Can't then be another corner at that point.
Either a pen or foul to us. |  |
| |
Login to get fewer ads
| They were clearly retaking that corner until they scored... on 15:53 - May 10 with 1228 views | Zx1988 |
| They were clearly retaking that corner until they scored... on 15:28 - May 10 by acj |
Ref had already blown to retake the corner, thinking (correctly) ball hadn’t come into play when the foul was committed. VAR were checking whether ball was in play already when Greaves pulled him down - verified it wasn’t, so original decision stood and corner was retaken. |
Ah, fair enough. That makes sense.
It'd be handy if VAR gave a little more information then - I'm not convinced many people in the stadium got the nuance of that particular check. | |
| |
| They were clearly retaking that corner until they scored... on 15:56 - May 10 with 1139 views | wingerii |
5 4 I t referee anyway. | | | |
| They were clearly retaking that corner until they scored... on 15:59 - May 10 with 1085 views | acj |
| They were clearly retaking that corner until they scored... on 15:51 - May 10 by homer_123 |
First corner. Ball was 'in play' before Ref blew.
Can't then be another corner at that point.
Either a pen or foul to us. |
Ball was not in play at the point the foul occurred, how long until the ref blew his whistle is irrelevant. Always going to be some delay between seeing a foul and raising the whistle to your lips.
Not sure why we’d complain about the first one - if the foul was half a second later it would have been a penalty as it was Greaves that was doing the fouling on that one. | |
| |
| They were clearly retaking that corner until they scored... on 16:00 - May 10 with 1060 views | acj |
| They were clearly retaking that corner until they scored... on 15:53 - May 10 by Zx1988 |
Ah, fair enough. That makes sense.
It'd be handy if VAR gave a little more information then - I'm not convinced many people in the stadium got the nuance of that particular check. |
Totally agree with you on this - if they made it clearer what VAR was checking and why they came to the decisions they did, it would make it all a lot easier to understand! | |
| |
| They were clearly retaking that corner until they scored... on 16:12 - May 10 with 957 views | ronnyd |
| They were clearly retaking that corner until they scored... on 15:24 - May 10 by acj |
Both aborted corners saw grappling and fouls committed before the ball came into play, so corner was retaken. Ref’s got that correct.
Set piece defending has been an annoying Achilles heel this year! |
Must admit that the constant wrestling and grappling at corners is spoiling the games for me. It seems it's worse in the Prem. Better coached at it i suppose. | | | |
| They were clearly retaking that corner until they scored... on 17:00 - May 10 with 776 views | Durovigutum |
| They were clearly retaking that corner until they scored... on 15:24 - May 10 by acj |
Both aborted corners saw grappling and fouls committed before the ball came into play, so corner was retaken. Ref’s got that correct.
Set piece defending has been an annoying Achilles heel this year! |
No, the ball was in play and one had even been touched by a player - referee bottled it and the rest of the game was a shambles as a result. | | | |
| They were clearly retaking that corner until they scored... on 17:18 - May 10 with 691 views | Herbivore |
| They were clearly retaking that corner until they scored... on 15:59 - May 10 by acj |
Ball was not in play at the point the foul occurred, how long until the ref blew his whistle is irrelevant. Always going to be some delay between seeing a foul and raising the whistle to your lips.
Not sure why we’d complain about the first one - if the foul was half a second later it would have been a penalty as it was Greaves that was doing the fouling on that one. |
Then surely the ref should blow for a penalty and let VAR check, not signal for another corner which is what he did? I've never seen anything like today to be honest. Either the ref thinks there's a foul or he doesn't but I don't get how the corner comes all the way in and he awards them another corner when the ball hasn't gone out off our player while he then sees whether VAR might be interested. [Post edited 10 May 17:19]
|  |
| |
| They were clearly retaking that corner until they scored... on 17:20 - May 10 with 660 views | TractorWood |
| They were clearly retaking that corner until they scored... on 15:51 - May 10 by homer_123 |
First corner. Ball was 'in play' before Ref blew.
Can't then be another corner at that point.
Either a pen or foul to us. |
Foul was before. Hence VAR not giving anything etc etc. | |
| |
| They were clearly retaking that corner until they scored... on 17:22 - May 10 with 632 views | Durovigutum |
| They were clearly retaking that corner until they scored... on 15:28 - May 10 by acj |
Ref had already blown to retake the corner, thinking (correctly) ball hadn’t come into play when the foul was committed. VAR were checking whether ball was in play already when Greaves pulled him down - verified it wasn’t, so original decision stood and corner was retaken. |
The ball had reached the penalty spot… | | | |
| They were clearly retaking that corner until they scored... on 17:57 - May 10 with 421 views | Dennyx4 |
| They were clearly retaking that corner until they scored... on 15:59 - May 10 by acj |
Ball was not in play at the point the foul occurred, how long until the ref blew his whistle is irrelevant. Always going to be some delay between seeing a foul and raising the whistle to your lips.
Not sure why we’d complain about the first one - if the foul was half a second later it would have been a penalty as it was Greaves that was doing the fouling on that one. |
When the ref blows is very important, as if the ball is in play, it would be a bounce ball for the goalkeeper. |  | | |
| |
By continuing to use the site, you agree to our use of cookies and to abide by our Terms and Conditions.
