By continuing to use the site, you agree to our use of cookies and to abide by our Terms and Conditions. We in turn value your personal details in accordance with our Privacy Policy.
Please log in or register. Registered visitors get fewer ads.
I don't think either of those stills help. The 1st one appears to thinking the question is about Browne, the 2nd isn't when he squares it as Taylor is much closer to him by that point.
FWIW I think Strelec is behind him when its played so looked onside to me.
0
Was Boro's first goal offside? on 16:18 - Apr 21 with 1468 views
Not sure if that is the moment the ball is played, looks like that's when he's controlling it. And looks in line anyway if you look at the grass cutting lines on the pitch.
Sat right in line with that, the scorer was offside when the cross came in, assistant behind the play, not close to in line, no chance that was being given, but he was definitely offside.
0
Was Boro's first goal offside? on 17:03 - Apr 21 with 1129 views
If he's level with or behind the ball when the ball is crossed then I don't think he can be offside, and that looked to me to be the case from the upper North.
It also looked to me as if Greaves could have cut out the cross but he seemed to be playing for the offside.
[Post edited 21 Apr 17:30]
0
Was Boro's first goal offside? on 17:32 - Apr 21 with 934 views
When I saw the replay I thought it was. I think if we were in the Premier League then VAR would have disallowed it, but we're not and they didn't. Unfortunately.
He's not crossing it in the second picture though? Hes further towards the by-line. by the time he crosses. Not sure what straws we are trying to be clutching here?
0
Was Boro's first goal offside? on 17:39 - Apr 21 with 877 views
I don't like blaming people but both goals appear to show that Davis was caught out of position. On their second goal he made a bad pass which led to them getting in behind, a good save by Walton, but tucked away on the rebound. For whatever reason after a poor Premier League campaign I thought we had overcome this situation of teams getting in behind Davis because he is used to overlap Philogene. It is up to a midfielder of central defender to cover that position when Davis bombs forward.
0
Was Boro's first goal offside? on 18:48 - Apr 21 with 444 views
Was Boro's first goal offside? on 16:38 - Apr 21 by skinnybob72
He’s behind the ball - surely that’s ONside?
The angles further down are better but this is the problem with people judging offsides from pictures. There is no way his head is past the ball. That's just the angle of this frame. If you reversed it his head would look conversely miles behind the ball.
You can only judge this completely side on and he would be behind the ball.
From behind on the diagonal your brain can't process this other than upright body looking like it is forward. (Not a criticism of your brain specifically haha).
By continuing to use the site, you agree to our use of cookies and to abide by our Terms and Conditions.
