| Bruno Fernandes red card over turned. 18:32 - Oct 1 with 2138 views | MK1 |
I think that is the right decision. Thought it was very harsh. Can't stand him, but think this is right. |  |
| |  |
| Bruno Fernandes red card over turned. on 18:38 - Oct 1 with 2101 views | Miaow |
It was never a sending off.
But hopefully he gets a warranted red card in his next game as that would be funny. |  |
| |
| Bruno Fernandes red card over turned. on 19:35 - Oct 1 with 1977 views | SitfcB |
Makes a mockery of VAR. |  |
| |
| Bruno Fernandes red card over turned. on 19:36 - Oct 1 with 1961 views | Whos_blue |
| Bruno Fernandes red card over turned. on 19:35 - Oct 1 by SitfcB |
Makes a mockery of VAR. |
Another one? |  |
| Distortion becomes somehow pure in its wildness. |
| |
| Bruno Fernandes red card over turned. on 19:36 - Oct 1 with 1959 views | Whos_blue |
And rightly so! | |
| Distortion becomes somehow pure in its wildness. |
| |
| Bruno Fernandes red card over turned. on 19:43 - Oct 1 with 1928 views | BloomBlue |
Does that mean we'll have VAR II checking VAR I decisions and then ultimately VAR III checking what VAR II decided on VAR I ? |  | | |
| Bruno Fernandes red card over turned. on 19:54 - Oct 1 with 1891 views | LeoMuff |
It was an awful decision and sums up the premier league, barely tapped him on the shin pad and he is rolling around screaming like his legs snapped, team mates wading in like it was a leg breaker, ridiculous. Ex pros saying it was dangerous in the press (Nigel Reo Coker) when it clearly wasn’t. Then VAR - plain as day wasn’t a red but nothing doing. |  |
| |
| Bruno Fernandes red card over turned. on 20:32 - Oct 1 with 1811 views | SheffordBlue |
| Bruno Fernandes red card over turned. on 19:35 - Oct 1 by SitfcB |
Makes a mockery of VAR. |
I think that's only true if the VAR disagreed with the ref and didn't do anything about it - it's a subjective decision - I personally don't think it was a red but pundits disagreed on it at the time so no reason to believe that refs wouldn't disagree about it either.
The alternative would almost certainly have been an extended pause in play while VAR looked at all the angles and then called the ref over to the monitor. Fans keep saying this is something that they don't want.
I personally don't think it matters what form of VAR or no VAR we end up with there will still be decisions that people disagree with ! |  |
| |
| Bruno Fernandes red card over turned. on 21:01 - Oct 1 with 1758 views | Garv |
| Bruno Fernandes red card over turned. on 19:54 - Oct 1 by LeoMuff |
It was an awful decision and sums up the premier league, barely tapped him on the shin pad and he is rolling around screaming like his legs snapped, team mates wading in like it was a leg breaker, ridiculous. Ex pros saying it was dangerous in the press (Nigel Reo Coker) when it clearly wasn’t. Then VAR - plain as day wasn’t a red but nothing doing. |
I'm confused that no one has publicly called out Maddison, that I've seen.
It's a travesty of a decision and it definitely reduced the quality of the game, despite it obviously being fun to watch United continue to be rubbish.
But referees are human. In real time from certain angles it looked a bit malicious and high, like the Stephens' red card for Soton against United, which wasn't really disputed. I can see why he might make a snap decision it was a bad tackle, but a lot of that will have been based on Maddison's pathetic reaction - and for him to then be BF's best mate as he's walking off telling him he's unlucky. Could he perhaps not play act to get him sent off in the first place? |  |
| |
Login to get fewer ads
| Bruno Fernandes red card over turned. on 21:06 - Oct 1 with 1716 views | WicklowBlue |
| Bruno Fernandes red card over turned. on 21:01 - Oct 1 by Garv |
I'm confused that no one has publicly called out Maddison, that I've seen.
It's a travesty of a decision and it definitely reduced the quality of the game, despite it obviously being fun to watch United continue to be rubbish.
But referees are human. In real time from certain angles it looked a bit malicious and high, like the Stephens' red card for Soton against United, which wasn't really disputed. I can see why he might make a snap decision it was a bad tackle, but a lot of that will have been based on Maddison's pathetic reaction - and for him to then be BF's best mate as he's walking off telling him he's unlucky. Could he perhaps not play act to get him sent off in the first place? |
Fernandes caught him midway up his leg. Agree some mitigation as Fernandes slipped when attempting the tackle but he still went for it. For one I was quite happy to see him sent off as while a quality player for me he epitomises what is wrong with Manure. Why he was made Captain I have no idea! |  | | |
| Bruno Fernandes red card over turned. on 12:07 - Oct 2 with 1428 views | Radlett_blue |
| Bruno Fernandes red card over turned. on 19:54 - Oct 1 by LeoMuff |
It was an awful decision and sums up the premier league, barely tapped him on the shin pad and he is rolling around screaming like his legs snapped, team mates wading in like it was a leg breaker, ridiculous. Ex pros saying it was dangerous in the press (Nigel Reo Coker) when it clearly wasn’t. Then VAR - plain as day wasn’t a red but nothing doing. |
Fernandes slipped, which made the tackle look reckless if you saw it once at normal speed. But yes, overturning decisions like this was one of the main purposes of VAR.
I suppose Fernandes won't be punished for his refusal to leave the field, which is becoming all too common these days. |  |
| |
| Bruno Fernandes red card over turned. on 12:14 - Oct 2 with 1396 views | Keno |
Mt Man Utd supporting son in law is very disappointed
he was hoping the ban would be extended |  |
| |
| Bruno Fernandes red card over turned. on 15:11 - Oct 2 with 1244 views | Garv |
| Bruno Fernandes red card over turned. on 21:06 - Oct 1 by WicklowBlue |
Fernandes caught him midway up his leg. Agree some mitigation as Fernandes slipped when attempting the tackle but he still went for it. For one I was quite happy to see him sent off as while a quality player for me he epitomises what is wrong with Manure. Why he was made Captain I have no idea! |
It's probably a case of the best player getting the armband, because he is quite comfortably their best.
He's petulant but most of their good play goes through him. Unfortunately he doesn't mind play acting himself at times, most of them are as bad as each other in that sense.
Apart from him being unlikable to a lot of people, it was never deserving of a red card. | |
| |
| Bruno Fernandes red card over turned. on 15:17 - Oct 2 with 1232 views | RobTheMonk |
| Bruno Fernandes red card over turned. on 15:11 - Oct 2 by Garv |
It's probably a case of the best player getting the armband, because he is quite comfortably their best.
He's petulant but most of their good play goes through him. Unfortunately he doesn't mind play acting himself at times, most of them are as bad as each other in that sense.
Apart from him being unlikable to a lot of people, it was never deserving of a red card. |
Indeed. Great player and has really dragged his teams through games in the past (for Sporting Lisbon too).
We've been spoiled with Morsy as our captain. |  | | |
| Bruno Fernandes red card over turned. on 15:27 - Oct 2 with 1204 views | wischip |
| Bruno Fernandes red card over turned. on 19:43 - Oct 1 by BloomBlue |
Does that mean we'll have VAR II checking VAR I decisions and then ultimately VAR III checking what VAR II decided on VAR I ? |
Wouldn't that be taking matters a bit too VAR ? |  | | |
| |
By continuing to use the site, you agree to our use of cookies and to abide by our Terms and Conditions.
