| A journo never reveals their sources... but Phil 01:02 - Jul 5 with 4323 views | wkj |
Can you shed a little more light on why the Celina story seems credible?
Don't get me wrong, this is not critique - but more curiosity as the story gives very little way as to how the story has legs.
[Post edited 5 Jul 2021 5:24]
|  |
| |  |
| A journo never reveals their sources... but Phil on 01:14 - Jul 5 with 4277 views | marcus1642 |
I don't necessarily believe everything I read, and I find this story far fetched. Maybe a loan at best? Even then I doubt it. |  | | |
| A journo never reveals their sources... but Phil on 01:17 - Jul 5 with 4268 views | wkj |
| A journo never reveals their sources... but Phil on 01:14 - Jul 5 by marcus1642 |
I don't necessarily believe everything I read, and I find this story far fetched. Maybe a loan at best? Even then I doubt it. |
It is one of the harder stories to treat without a skeptical stance - though there is plenty to suggest that there are problems at his current team that might mean he and others are on the move - just unsure where the tie to Ipswich comes in. | |
| |
| A journo never reveals their sources... but Phil on 04:34 - Jul 5 with 4111 views | Ryorry |
"A journo never reveals their sources" - but basically, you've asked Phil to.
 |  |
| |
| A journo never reveals their sources... but Phil on 05:21 - Jul 5 with 4072 views | wkj |
| A journo never reveals their sources... but Phil on 04:34 - Jul 5 by Ryorry |
"A journo never reveals their sources" - but basically, you've asked Phil to.
|
Not really - Phil has a way of explaining things sometimes that lines up his own hunches with the story itself.
If it was a case of me asking him to do that the post would read
"ere... Phil - Who told you that then"
Clearly, it does not say that. | |
| |
| A journo never reveals their sources... but Phil on 06:46 - Jul 5 with 3853 views | Fixed_It |
| A journo never reveals their sources... but Phil on 01:17 - Jul 5 by wkj |
It is one of the harder stories to treat without a skeptical stance - though there is plenty to suggest that there are problems at his current team that might mean he and others are on the move - just unsure where the tie to Ipswich comes in. |
Ashton is a serious player in transfer dealings. We're just not used to it. |  |
| |
| A journo never reveals their sources... but Phil on 07:33 - Jul 5 with 3607 views | Oldboy |
Think Phil is still hungover from Saturday. He will get back to you once he has had 3 coffees and a pack of hob nobs. Patience my friend, I think this one might actually be happening. |  | | |
| A journo never reveals their sources... but Phil on 07:40 - Jul 5 with 3529 views | BryanPlug |
[content removed at owner's request] |  |
| |
Login to get fewer ads
| A journo never reveals their sources... but Phil on 08:00 - Jul 5 with 3397 views | StokieBlue |
Whilst it would seem quite an unlikely transfer, both Phil and SomethingBlue think there is something in it so the signs in the Journo-world must be fairly strong.
SB |  |
| Avatar - IC410 - Tadpoles Nebula |
| |
| A journo never reveals their sources... but Phil on 09:22 - Jul 5 with 3003 views | BondiBlue |
EADT have it as a 'transfer rumour' which i think is their code for 'we read it on TWTD but we know nothing about this'. |  |
| |
| A journo never reveals their sources... but Phil on 10:39 - Jul 5 with 2710 views | bracknell_blue |
Remember that Phil's track record is pretty good when reporting stories like this. |  |
| |
| A journo never reveals their sources... but Phil on 10:43 - Jul 5 with 2664 views | SaigonTractor |
I think Phil has gotten enough stories spot on over the years for us to give him the benefit of the doubt on this one. |  | | |
| A journo never reveals their sources... but Phil on 10:45 - Jul 5 with 2647 views | rayman_10 |
| A journo never reveals their sources... but Phil on 09:22 - Jul 5 by BondiBlue |
EADT have it as a 'transfer rumour' which i think is their code for 'we read it on TWTD but we know nothing about this'. |
They’ve also said ‘it’s understood’ which I translate to ‘theres most definitely something In it, but it’s not our story and cannot yet confirm’. |  |
| |
| A journo never reveals their sources... but Phil on 11:03 - Jul 5 with 2475 views | PhilTWTD |
Not sure what I can really add, talks ongoing, move is a real possibility. |  | | |
| A journo never reveals their sources... but Phil on 11:07 - Jul 5 with 2409 views | wkj |
I do feel some may have misunderstood my motives on this post - again, it isn't a critique or bringing Phil's reputation into disrepute, but more intrigue around how an unlikely rumour starts to become a tangible lead.
I am a number jockey, not a wordsmith. I find this all very fascinating when we get a link out of the blue. | |
| |
| A journo never reveals their sources... but Phil on 14:02 - Jul 5 with 1716 views | SamWhiteUK |
| A journo never reveals their sources... but Phil on 11:03 - Jul 5 by PhilTWTD |
Not sure what I can really add, talks ongoing, move is a real possibility. |
Unreal. Everything crossed |  | | |
| A journo never reveals their sources... but Phil on 14:21 - Jul 5 with 1608 views | breedalot |
| A journo never reveals their sources... but Phil on 11:07 - Jul 5 by wkj |
I do feel some may have misunderstood my motives on this post - again, it isn't a critique or bringing Phil's reputation into disrepute, but more intrigue around how an unlikely rumour starts to become a tangible lead.
I am a number jockey, not a wordsmith. I find this all very fascinating when we get a link out of the blue. |
there was a really good piece on this on the KOA podcast a few weeks back, I am sorry I can't remember the episode and I know I am promoting a rival pod to BM with TWTD so sorry for that Phil but I found it really informative they also explained how they categorise stories. I presume Phil and TWTD do things in a very similar way. | | | |
| A journo never reveals their sources... but Phil on 14:59 - Jul 5 with 1450 views | stopmoaning |
| A journo never reveals their sources... but Phil on 11:03 - Jul 5 by PhilTWTD |
Not sure what I can really add, talks ongoing, move is a real possibility. |
I think things have gone beyond that.
Just kidding, no idea, just wanted to use the famous phrase. |  | | |
| |
By continuing to use the site, you agree to our use of cookies and to abide by our Terms and Conditions.
