| VAR errors according to the Premier League 09:31 - Feb 5 with 7252 views | C_HealyIsAPleasure |
Data out today re VAR errors, according to the PL’s Key Match Incidents panel:
https://www.espn.co.uk/football/story/_/id/43320888/revealed-every-var-referee-e
Apparently we’ve not been subject to any clear VAR errors this season however a few incidents where it’s adjudged the referee decision was potentially incorrect, but VAR right not to intervene as not clear cut or outside of scope (2nd yellow cards):
1. Non-penalty award for the foul on Davis at Man City
2. Non-penalty award for the foul on Chaplin against Leicester (apparently the whole panel agreed VAR was right not to review, somehow)
3. Decision not to give Morsy a second yellow against Villa
4. Decision to give Phillips a second yellow against Leicester
Hmm…
|  |
| |  |
| VAR errors according to the Premier League on 10:36 - Feb 6 with 797 views | ArchiRob |
| VAR errors according to the Premier League on 10:08 - Feb 6 by berkstractorboy |
Answers it perfectly. I accept football is a contact sport, albeit less than previous years, but I think the contact on Chaplin was more than what can be described as fair.
I appreciate we won't agree (Garv), but if the PGMOL don't think they got that one wrong then I think we can see why there is little respect for VAR and officiating in this country. [Post edited 6 Feb 10:17]
|
Until a captains challenge is introduced as in nearly every other sport it will always be seen as inconsistent and open to allegations of corruption. If a captains challenge views are shown on a big screen it has to be explained in front of the whole crowd. It would also get around the stupid second yellow card situation like Clarke sent off. |  |
| |
| VAR errors according to the Premier League on 10:36 - Feb 6 with 796 views | Dennyx4 |
| VAR errors according to the Premier League on 10:23 - Feb 6 by ibbleobble |
Fair point. |
The Davis yellow at Fulham, could easily have been a red. Thought that one went in our favour, from the ref and no var intervention.
If the ref had give it, not sure it would have been overturned. |  | | |
| VAR errors according to the Premier League on 10:43 - Feb 6 with 778 views | ArchiRob |
| VAR errors according to the Premier League on 10:08 - Feb 6 by berkstractorboy |
Answers it perfectly. I accept football is a contact sport, albeit less than previous years, but I think the contact on Chaplin was more than what can be described as fair.
I appreciate we won't agree (Garv), but if the PGMOL don't think they got that one wrong then I think we can see why there is little respect for VAR and officiating in this country. [Post edited 6 Feb 10:17]
|
Until a captains challenge is introduced like a lot of other sports there will always be calls of inconsistency, incompetence and cheating. The challenge would be shown on the main screen on front of the crowd and it would be near impossible to get it wrong. It would also address the ridiculous incorrect 2nd yellow card which we have copped twice. The thing is supposed to correct wrong decisions Refs covering other Refs backs are not doing it are they? | |
| |
| VAR errors according to the Premier League on 11:01 - Feb 6 with 759 views | Herbivore |
| VAR errors according to the Premier League on 10:36 - Feb 6 by Dennyx4 |
The Davis yellow at Fulham, could easily have been a red. Thought that one went in our favour, from the ref and no var intervention.
If the ref had give it, not sure it would have been overturned. |
VAR was right not to intervene as it was a debatable decision, you're right that if he'd been sent off VAR wouldn't have intervened either. It's one of those were fans of either side might feel aggrieved or fortunate either way. |  |
| |
| VAR errors according to the Premier League on 11:50 - Feb 6 with 724 views | berkstractorboy |
| VAR errors according to the Premier League on 10:36 - Feb 6 by Dennyx4 |
The Davis yellow at Fulham, could easily have been a red. Thought that one went in our favour, from the ref and no var intervention.
If the ref had give it, not sure it would have been overturned. |
Think that's fair we were fortunate on that one. |  | | |
| VAR errors according to the Premier League on 12:14 - Feb 6 with 687 views | Vaughan8 |
| VAR errors according to the Premier League on 12:54 - Feb 5 by Garv |
Definitely not the same, you're right. I was just pointing out one incident that we were supposedly hard done by (I've never been convinced - Chaplin was looking for it) and one we were lucky with. Delap made every effort to go down, yes there might have been an ounce of contact but it's a dive. |
If you're going on whether a player is looking for it, then probably about 80% of penalties are that.
I'm baffled how anyone after seeing replays did not think that Chaplin one was a penalty, but you're with the VAR team so each to their own.
The Delap one I agree with. However, as sad as it sounds, we need to be like that because every other team is like that. | | | |
| VAR errors according to the Premier League on 14:53 - Feb 7 with 574 views | Blue_In_Boston |
Please can we stop bleating on about the Leicester decision? It wasn't given. End of.
Focus on the next game not the past. | | | |
| VAR errors according to the Premier League on 17:33 - Feb 7 with 547 views | berkstractorboy |
| VAR errors according to the Premier League on 14:53 - Feb 7 by Blue_In_Boston |
Please can we stop bleating on about the Leicester decision? It wasn't given. End of.
Focus on the next game not the past. |
The whole thread is about VAR errors it's exactly the post to be commenting on the Leicester decision. | | | |
Login to get fewer ads
| VAR errors according to the Premier League on 21:55 - Feb 7 with 514 views | RamRob |
| VAR errors according to the Premier League on 17:33 - Feb 7 by berkstractorboy |
The whole thread is about VAR errors it's exactly the post to be commenting on the Leicester decision. |
Exactly and I don't think we should ever move on, most blatant penalty I've ever seen
And Jack Clarke obstructs the refs view at the key moment (Chaplin controlling the ball) the VAR absolutely should have sent the ref to the screen precisely because his view was obstructed
What Gallagher said on Sky Sports was a load of bull. The ref needed to review it as his "explanation" was obviously wrong... |  |
| |
| VAR errors according to the Premier League on 05:12 - Feb 8 with 425 views | ArchiRob |
| VAR errors according to the Premier League on 14:31 - Feb 5 by Bellevue_Blue |
But they're making them in real time and the appointed review panel are assessing their decisions as wrong?
The problem is that we know what happens when they go to the screen. Why do we not give the referee the autonomy to stick with their decision or change their decision.
The whole clear and obvious error thing just creates more errors. VAR should be there for one thing, to show the referee the footage. Instead we have a whole team of people shouting over each other and make decision based on a whole load of nonsense clear and obvious language.
I agree on the players cheating. I think there should be retrospective action for holding your head/ face if there is no contact on the head/ face. |
Send them for a 10min concussion test and that will stop overnight | |
| |
| |
By continuing to use the site, you agree to our use of cookies and to abide by our Terms and Conditions.
