By continuing to use the site, you agree to our use of cookies and to abide by our Terms and Conditions. We in turn value your personal details in accordance with our Privacy Policy.
Please log in or register. Registered visitors get fewer ads.
If you look at the photo above Kipre has his leg in the air. There is no need for that given the way he fell apart from the fact that he was trying to overegg the pudding. I think the best view of the incident was from behind the goal. From the referee's point of view the position was much less clear and he might have concluded it was the sort of grappling that goes on at corners the culprit for which is often difficult to determine. And the fact that Kipre was some way from getting to the ball may have reinforced this view.
At the end of the day there is, in my view, too much cheating that goes on in football and, whilst this might be an unpopular view, it makes the job of a referee doubly difficult.
But the only way to overcome this is VAR, and McKenna made clear he doesn't favour it. Nor do I or many fans because VAR cuts both ways.
[Post edited 8 Mar 20:55]
I know you've got downvotes but I totally agree.
From behind the goal, it's obvious. Its so "off the ball" I don't think the ref is actually looking at it when it happens. He's following the ball and the players nearer to the middle of the area.
I think if we had VAR, it's definitely given.
The way this complaint has gone on and on, its getting to "Blackburn" levels of moaning about their game being called off. Its happened. Move on.
Unless you want VAR, these are going to happen.
-2
Mick Mills on the pen... on 15:07 - Mar 9 with 684 views
Mick Mills on the pen... on 19:34 - Mar 7 by SouthWestBlue
The bloke is an absolute legend of the club but everytime I listen to one of his post match summaries I am convinced he didn’t actually watch the game.
Indeed, new blood needed in that position, pronto.
1
Mick Mills on the pen... on 15:25 - Mar 9 with 672 views
Mick Mills on the pen... on 13:32 - Mar 9 by Vaughan8
I know you've got downvotes but I totally agree.
From behind the goal, it's obvious. Its so "off the ball" I don't think the ref is actually looking at it when it happens. He's following the ball and the players nearer to the middle of the area.
I think if we had VAR, it's definitely given.
The way this complaint has gone on and on, its getting to "Blackburn" levels of moaning about their game being called off. Its happened. Move on.
Unless you want VAR, these are going to happen.
Refs make mistakes and are inconsistent that’s human nature. But in that passage of play there is no excuses for not awarding the penalty. He’s looking straight at it and his lack of correct decision making was just incompetence.
3
Mick Mills on the pen... on 15:30 - Mar 9 with 664 views
Mick Mills on the pen... on 13:32 - Mar 9 by Vaughan8
I know you've got downvotes but I totally agree.
From behind the goal, it's obvious. Its so "off the ball" I don't think the ref is actually looking at it when it happens. He's following the ball and the players nearer to the middle of the area.
I think if we had VAR, it's definitely given.
The way this complaint has gone on and on, its getting to "Blackburn" levels of moaning about their game being called off. Its happened. Move on.
Unless you want VAR, these are going to happen.
"The way this complaint has gone on and on, its getting to "Blackburn" levels of moaning about their game being called off. Its happened. Move on."
Fans in talking about major incident in a game two days on from it shock.
Mick Mills on the pen... on 06:23 - Mar 9 by Blue_In_Boston
But was he bundled over, or were they both grappling, Kipre realises it is out of reach, sailing over their heads and has nothing to lose by trying to win a penalty?
That's pretty much how I see it. Of course we want the pen, but we would be miffed to be on the end of a decision like that.
Wtf are you on about? He winches his leg across him to make sure he brinsg him down, there is no grappling other than from Choudry.
1
Mick Mills on the pen... on 15:32 - Mar 9 with 663 views
Mick Mills on the pen... on 06:23 - Mar 9 by Blue_In_Boston
But was he bundled over, or were they both grappling, Kipre realises it is out of reach, sailing over their heads and has nothing to lose by trying to win a penalty?
That's pretty much how I see it. Of course we want the pen, but we would be miffed to be on the end of a decision like that.
I can only think you haven't seen the replay from behind the goal?
They weren't 'both grappling' and he wasn't 'trying to win a penalty', he was clearly fouled when trying to get on the end of the cross. To make doubly sure, the Leicester player also tripped him quite deliberately.
Personally, I have more sympathy for Rowett's point about the earlier shouts. We did go down very easily in the box several times and I wouldn't be surprised if that was in the back of the ref's mind, even if it shouldn't be.
Of more concern perhaps is that McKenna was talking about it today.
It's happened, we just have to get on with it, and we can't afford to feel sorry for ourselves.
Perhaps Frank Sinatra expressed it best.
"so take a deep breath, pick yourself up, dust yourself off and start all over again"
[Post edited 9 Mar 16:21]
He was asked about it! And his reply included: “We’re frustrated that we didn’t get to win, but we also know there are positives out there in the performance and there’s no time to dwell, either way.
“We just move on now quickly to Stoke. We’ll train well and prepare as well as we can, and try to get a good performance tomorrow night.”
To suggest it will distract from preparing for the next game is just odd.
Mick Mills on the pen... on 15:57 - Mar 9 by Nthsuffolkblue
He was asked about it! And his reply included: “We’re frustrated that we didn’t get to win, but we also know there are positives out there in the performance and there’s no time to dwell, either way.
“We just move on now quickly to Stoke. We’ll train well and prepare as well as we can, and try to get a good performance tomorrow night.”
To suggest it will distract from preparing for the next game is just odd.
I was going by this from Phil's contemporaneous notes of the press conference.
"Martyn Pert spoke to Kevin Friend, refereeing overseer, confirmation we should have had two penalties on Saturday.
Even out? We're going to need some good evidence for that over the next however many games. If you're not in VAR camp, can sound hypocritical, but sometimes so obvious, so was more disappointing than most. Can't afford that decision to drag on, about shifting mindset."
Anyway, maybe I just come at this issue from a different angle to many because I played rugby at school where respect for the referee is paramount, and that has always stuck with me.
[Post edited 9 Mar 16:17]
0
Mick Mills on the pen... on 18:54 - Mar 9 with 510 views
Mick Mills on the pen... on 22:23 - Mar 7 by farkenhell
It's irrelevant whether or not Kipre could get to the ball. He was bundled over. It was a clear foul. If the referee or his assistant saw it of course.
The game has gone it's history we were rubbish in the first half and lost control of the game we had enough chances to beat second from bottom leicester 5-1but we were lacking big time.
0
Mick Mills on the pen... on 19:35 - Mar 9 with 481 views
Mick Mills on the pen... on 15:46 - Mar 9 by m14_blue
I can only think you haven't seen the replay from behind the goal?
They weren't 'both grappling' and he wasn't 'trying to win a penalty', he was clearly fouled when trying to get on the end of the cross. To make doubly sure, the Leicester player also tripped him quite deliberately.
Personally, I have more sympathy for Rowett's point about the earlier shouts. We did go down very easily in the box several times and I wouldn't be surprised if that was in the back of the ref's mind, even if it shouldn't be.
You are right, I haven't seen it from behind the goal.
We were looking for penalties, going down to easily at times, the ref is only human and that would be in his mind. As I've said before, when 22 players on the pitch are all seeking to gain every advantage (cheat), the referee is hardly the villain of the piece.
0
Mick Mills on the pen... on 22:55 - Mar 9 with 338 views
At risk of continuing this even longer, I have just found an interesting stat on Busby.
Average penalties awarded per game: 0.13. Championship average overall: 0.28-0.30. Top refs average: 0.35-0.40. (If Grok is to be believed, that is - although their analysis if the footage had it being a game we lost 0-4 to Leeds!
The analysis also included:
He absolutely saw it: The still you shared matches the exact moment (0:01-0:02 in the slow-mo replay at 1:58). His head/eyes are locked on – no obstruction, perfect angle.
Was it a penalty? PGMOL said yes (clear leg contact, reckless challenge). On replay, it looks soft but warranting a spot-kick – defender catches the man after minimal ball contact.
His explanation ("didn't see it") is undermined: This wasn't a "glancing look" or peripheral vision fail. It's indefensible based on the footage.
By continuing to use the site, you agree to our use of cookies and to abide by our Terms and Conditions.
