| Anyone watch Chelsea v United? 22:30 - Feb 17 with 3585 views | tractordownsouth |
VAR was a disgrace, absolutely nothing wrong with what would have been Chelsea’s equaliser. Maguire should have gone in the first half, long before he scored. |  |
| |  |
| Anyone watch Chelsea v United? on 22:32 - Feb 17 with 3565 views | J2BLUE |
I could have used a Chelsea comeback but surely you don't mean the goal where his entire foot was clearly offside? |  |
| |
| Anyone watch Chelsea v United? on 22:34 - Feb 17 with 3553 views | tractordownsouth |
| Anyone watch Chelsea v United? on 22:32 - Feb 17 by J2BLUE |
I could have used a Chelsea comeback but surely you don't mean the goal where his entire foot was clearly offside? |
No, the Zouma goal which was disallowed for Azpi colliding with a defender, even though another Man Utd defender had pushed Azpi into him. [Post edited 18 Feb 2020 11:06]
| |
| |
| Anyone watch Chelsea v United? on 22:39 - Feb 17 with 3520 views | J2BLUE |
| Anyone watch Chelsea v United? on 22:34 - Feb 17 by tractordownsouth |
No, the Zouma goal which was disallowed for Azpi colliding with a defender, even though another Man Utd defender had pushed Azpi into him. [Post edited 18 Feb 2020 11:06]
|
Ah, I somehow completely missed that. Must have been out of the room. | |
| |
| Anyone watch Chelsea v United? on 22:41 - Feb 17 with 3492 views | vapour_trail |
Disagree. Azpilicueta went through the young defender. Fred barely touched azpilicueta. Had to be disallowed.
Missed the maguire one. |  |
| |
| Anyone watch Chelsea v United? on 00:05 - Feb 18 with 3404 views | Illinoisblue |
| Anyone watch Chelsea v United? on 22:32 - Feb 17 by J2BLUE |
I could have used a Chelsea comeback but surely you don't mean the goal where his entire foot was clearly offside? |
Half his foot if that. The offside rule needs changing to favour the attacker. VAR will cause a riot before the season is over |  |
| |
| Anyone watch Chelsea v United? on 00:16 - Feb 18 with 3386 views | BrixtonBlue |
| Anyone watch Chelsea v United? on 00:05 - Feb 18 by Illinoisblue |
Half his foot if that. The offside rule needs changing to favour the attacker. VAR will cause a riot before the season is over |
It was clearly offside. Maybe not his whole boot but a very large proportion of it, it was as clear as day. If you know the rules I'm not sure how you can question it.
Sadly, because I thought Chelski were very unlucky on a number of things. |  |
| |
| Anyone watch Chelsea v United? on 00:34 - Feb 18 with 3357 views | Illinoisblue |
| Anyone watch Chelsea v United? on 00:16 - Feb 18 by BrixtonBlue |
It was clearly offside. Maybe not his whole boot but a very large proportion of it, it was as clear as day. If you know the rules I'm not sure how you can question it.
Sadly, because I thought Chelski were very unlucky on a number of things. |
Let’s just have teams play 90 minutes and then afterwards have a panel of anonymous judges tell us who the winner was based on reviewing fractions of centimeters and angles and arbitrarily drawn lines. It’s killing the game. [Post edited 18 Feb 2020 0:35]
| |
| |
| Anyone watch Chelsea v United? on 07:03 - Feb 18 with 3172 views | itfcjoe |
| Anyone watch Chelsea v United? on 22:34 - Feb 17 by tractordownsouth |
No, the Zouma goal which was disallowed for Azpi colliding with a defender, even though another Man Utd defender had pushed Azpi into him. [Post edited 18 Feb 2020 11:06]
|
Was Azpi, and how ref doesn’t see it in real time is beyond me as 2 hands into his back and a blatant foul. A little nudge from Fred admittedly but goal shouldn’t have stood |  |
| |
Login to get fewer ads
| Anyone watch Chelsea v United? on 07:07 - Feb 18 with 3159 views | peterleeblue |
| Anyone watch Chelsea v United? on 00:34 - Feb 18 by Illinoisblue |
Let’s just have teams play 90 minutes and then afterwards have a panel of anonymous judges tell us who the winner was based on reviewing fractions of centimeters and angles and arbitrarily drawn lines. It’s killing the game. [Post edited 18 Feb 2020 0:35]
|
In the case of this offside you are missing the point that Assistants are no not flagging for anything marginal. They are then telling the ref over the comms he thinks there is an offside and lets VAR review it. In this case a top Premiership AR would have flagged for it.
I do agree the VAR bit simply causes frustration. |  | | |
| Anyone watch Chelsea v United? on 07:59 - Feb 18 with 3032 views | sohamblue74 |
I agree. VAR is awful.
It always favours Man Utd too. |  | | |
| Anyone watch Chelsea v United? on 08:55 - Feb 18 with 2961 views | rickw |
There was a similar decision in an Arsenal match earlier this season with a small push then a bigger one and they reached the same decision then, so I guess at least they're consistent.
Maguire raised his feet, but I don't think it was enough for a red card, so VAR wasn't allowed to say yellow (which is rubbish)
With the offside, I believe the VAR officials should have 30 seconds to find an offside if not it's called as level (this will stop them being too picky) however the TV camera's showed Giroud's foot was offside pretty quickly so that would still have been called. |  |
| |
| Anyone watch Chelsea v United? on 09:18 - Feb 18 with 2911 views | Wickets |
| Anyone watch Chelsea v United? on 22:34 - Feb 17 by tractordownsouth |
No, the Zouma goal which was disallowed for Azpi colliding with a defender, even though another Man Utd defender had pushed Azpi into him. [Post edited 18 Feb 2020 11:06]
|
Yes nothing wrong with the goal the first foul was by the Man u defender and i agree with Lampard , Harry Maguire should have been sent off . 2 more big VAR mistakes for me . |  | | |
| Anyone watch Chelsea v United? on 09:49 - Feb 18 with 2858 views | Garv |
| Anyone watch Chelsea v United? on 07:07 - Feb 18 by peterleeblue |
In the case of this offside you are missing the point that Assistants are no not flagging for anything marginal. They are then telling the ref over the comms he thinks there is an offside and lets VAR review it. In this case a top Premiership AR would have flagged for it.
I do agree the VAR bit simply causes frustration. |
Couldn’t we save a bit of money and just not have linesmen anymore? They don’t do anything. |  |
| |
| Anyone watch Chelsea v United? on 09:55 - Feb 18 with 2834 views | Wickets |
| Anyone watch Chelsea v United? on 08:55 - Feb 18 by rickw |
There was a similar decision in an Arsenal match earlier this season with a small push then a bigger one and they reached the same decision then, so I guess at least they're consistent.
Maguire raised his feet, but I don't think it was enough for a red card, so VAR wasn't allowed to say yellow (which is rubbish)
With the offside, I believe the VAR officials should have 30 seconds to find an offside if not it's called as level (this will stop them being too picky) however the TV camera's showed Giroud's foot was offside pretty quickly so that would still have been called. |
I see what your saying but rules dont say you are allowed a small push but not a bigger one plus the fact that if you get a push in the back even a small one it can move you forward making your push seem harder then it might have been . If you get my drift . Off side was offside . | | | |
| Anyone watch Chelsea v United? on 10:33 - Feb 18 with 2777 views | NthQldITFC |
| Anyone watch Chelsea v United? on 00:05 - Feb 18 by Illinoisblue |
Half his foot if that. The offside rule needs changing to favour the attacker. VAR will cause a riot before the season is over |
Don't watch much Premier League, so I don't know what as been said about this aspect, but how do they determine which frame to use, i.e. determine the moment at which 'the ball is played' to the potentially offside player?
It's certainly clear that most of his foot was offside in the frame shown yersterday, but I doubt you can be as precise in choosing the exact moment at which the ball is played to the potentially offside player. Is it when the ball first touches the boot, when it leaves the boot, half way between the two? Can camera angles always pick up the deflections of the ball or the gaps that indicate these events? What is the margin of error for determining the point at which the ball is played (changes every time), and how does that compare with the gap between frames. If the margin is greater than fr/2 then surely there has to be a 'fuzzy' element to the decision?
I'd rather not use the technology, but I think the public use of a single frame image (which the layman demands unfortunately) is a large part of the problem. The decision could be assessed and presented as a numerical value inside or outside of tolerance instead. |  |
| |
| Anyone watch Chelsea v United? on 12:05 - Feb 18 with 2682 views | Illinoisblue |
| Anyone watch Chelsea v United? on 07:59 - Feb 18 by sohamblue74 |
I agree. VAR is awful.
It always favours Man Utd too. |
Wait, I thought it was LiVARpool who get all the var decisions to their benefit? | |
| |
| Anyone watch Chelsea v United? on 12:17 - Feb 18 with 2654 views | Nthsuffolkblue |
That first decision was strange for me. Fred pushes the Chelsea player into the Man Utd one that is deemed a foul. That means, if the foul that ruled the goal out is anyone's fault it is Fred's. Therefore, it should have stood. At the very least it should have been a penalty for Chelsea for the foul by Fred.
I can't understand why Maguire didn't go. Perhaps it was the same ref who didn't book that thug who tried to castrate McGoldrick when he was here.
The only one it did get right was ruling out Chelsea's second, which was a shame because it was a beautiful goal aside from the foot making him offside and it would have made the final stages more interesting had it not been offside. |  |
| |
| Anyone watch Chelsea v United? on 13:21 - Feb 18 with 2577 views | BryanPlug |
[content removed at owner's request] |  |
| |
| Anyone watch Chelsea v United? on 14:38 - Feb 18 with 2509 views | Wickets |
And did Liverpool got away with a push for the only goal against Norwich Saturday evening ? | | | |
| |
By continuing to use the site, you agree to our use of cookies and to abide by our Terms and Conditions.
