By continuing to use the site, you agree to our use of cookies and to abide by our Terms and Conditions. We in turn value your personal details in accordance with our Privacy Policy.
Please log in or register. Registered visitors get fewer ads.
As a Scotland fan a bit of a disappointment, but fair play to Ireland and good luck. As regards Donegal, it has very close historical, cultural and religious links to Gaelic Scotland, all the result of toings and goings over millenia. The Irish spoken there is similar to Scottish Gaelic, the traditional music also has similarities, and St Columba was born there. As a result, I've always looked rather fondly on it
[Post edited 12 Oct 2022 9:29]
1
Congratulations to the Irish Woman's football team on 13:58 - Oct 12 with 2351 views
Congratulations. Pity the whole thing is being marred by horrific sectarian chanting by the team afterwards. Hope they and anyone else involved in this sort of rubbish are slapped with long bans.
4
Congratulations to the Irish Woman's football team on 14:21 - Oct 12 with 2328 views
Congratulations to the Irish Woman's football team on 14:21 - Oct 12 by GlasgowBlue
A shame they had to ruin it by singing pro IRA songs. I hope they get humped in every WC game they play.
[Post edited 12 Oct 2022 18:51]
Far be it for me to comment on matters in Ireland, but for those old enough to remember, back in the 70s a song used to be sung in the North Stand which began "I, I, R, A, Ipswich Republican Army ...". This caused great offence in particular to fans from Birmingham following as it did the Birmingham pub bombings.
1
Congratulations to the Irish Woman's football team on 15:01 - Oct 12 with 2258 views
Congratulations to the Irish Woman's football team on 14:29 - Oct 12 by DJR
Far be it for me to comment on matters in Ireland, but for those old enough to remember, back in the 70s a song used to be sung in the North Stand which began "I, I, R, A, Ipswich Republican Army ...". This caused great offence in particular to fans from Birmingham following as it did the Birmingham pub bombings.
There's probably a lot of things that were said and done 50 years ago that people wouldn't and shouldn't say now.
Singing songs that are in support of a designated terrorist organisation probably meets that definition. These women are as thick as pig sh1t if they think it's appropriate.
Congratulations to the Irish Woman's football team on 15:12 - Oct 12 by clive_baker
There's probably a lot of things that were said and done 50 years ago that people wouldn't and shouldn't say now.
Singing songs that are in support of a designated terrorist organisation probably meets that definition. These women are as thick as pig sh1t if they think it's appropriate.
The IRA was also the name of the army that liberated the Republic of Ireland from British rule, so it doesn't always have exactly the same connotation for Irish people (and has a significant presence in Irish folk songs that are about the Irish War of Independence rather than the Troubles, of which Come Out Ye Black and Tans is probably best known).
Congratulations to the Irish Woman's football team on 15:12 - Oct 12 by clive_baker
There's probably a lot of things that were said and done 50 years ago that people wouldn't and shouldn't say now.
Singing songs that are in support of a designated terrorist organisation probably meets that definition. These women are as thick as pig sh1t if they think it's appropriate.
Incredibly ignorant to call the IRA a terrorist organisation.
My hobbies include being quiet during trips, clapping with songs, and diabetes.
Congratulations to the Irish Woman's football team on 15:48 - Oct 12 by jayessess
The IRA was also the name of the army that liberated the Republic of Ireland from British rule, so it doesn't always have exactly the same connotation for Irish people (and has a significant presence in Irish folk songs that are about the Irish War of Independence rather than the Troubles, of which Come Out Ye Black and Tans is probably best known).
I suppose another way of putting it is that one man's terrorist is another person's freedom fighter. After all, Nelson Mandela was imprisoned for terrorism, and the ANC was regarded as a terrorist organisation for immigration purposes in the US until as late as 2008, but surely no one is suggesting the song "Free Nelson Mandela" shouldn't have been sung.
1
Congratulations to the Irish Woman's football team on 16:15 - Oct 12 with 2024 views
Congratulations to the Irish Woman's football team on 16:12 - Oct 12 by DJR
I suppose another way of putting it is that one man's terrorist is another person's freedom fighter. After all, Nelson Mandela was imprisoned for terrorism, and the ANC was regarded as a terrorist organisation for immigration purposes in the US until as late as 2008, but surely no one is suggesting the song "Free Nelson Mandela" shouldn't have been sung.
I don't dispute that as a principle, it's often the case. You can argue the same about ISIS and the like, it doesn't forgive the atrocities such groups commit though.
I don't think any of that changes the fact that to sing songs in support of the IRA in the changing rooms post-match is moronic, and they have to be as thick as mince to think it's acceptable. Glad to see the FAI, managers and players have all apologised for it.
Congratulations to the Irish Woman's football team on 16:12 - Oct 12 by DJR
I suppose another way of putting it is that one man's terrorist is another person's freedom fighter. After all, Nelson Mandela was imprisoned for terrorism, and the ANC was regarded as a terrorist organisation for immigration purposes in the US until as late as 2008, but surely no one is suggesting the song "Free Nelson Mandela" shouldn't have been sung.
I think specifically the history of Britain and Ireland is complicated, and the general level of knowledge about that history is not evenly distributed between the two places. The IRA is used colloquially to refer to three different organisations. The original IRA - the guerrilla army that liberates the Republic of Ireland from the British, the official IRA - the original organisation that formed immediately after the Anglo-Irish Treaty to continue what was ultimately a very low level of armed resistance to the existence of Northern Ireland and the provisional IRA (the one that conducts a multi-decade campaign of bomb attacks that claims the lives of lots of civilians, British and Irish).
Most young Irish people will learn in a fair bit of depth about the whole century of conflict because it's how modern Ireland comes into existence. Most British people won't because it's one independence war amongst many in Britain's 20th Century.
That said, whilst I take the point about perspectives and freedom fighters, you can still make definitive judgements about causes, methods and ideas that separate the ANC from the Provisional IRA.
Congratulations to the Irish Woman's football team on 15:48 - Oct 12 by jayessess
The IRA was also the name of the army that liberated the Republic of Ireland from British rule, so it doesn't always have exactly the same connotation for Irish people (and has a significant presence in Irish folk songs that are about the Irish War of Independence rather than the Troubles, of which Come Out Ye Black and Tans is probably best known).
But shouldn't they just have asked them nicely to leave?
"They break our legs and tell us to be grateful when they offer us crutches."
Congratulations to the Irish Woman's football team on 16:30 - Oct 12 by jayessess
I think specifically the history of Britain and Ireland is complicated, and the general level of knowledge about that history is not evenly distributed between the two places. The IRA is used colloquially to refer to three different organisations. The original IRA - the guerrilla army that liberates the Republic of Ireland from the British, the official IRA - the original organisation that formed immediately after the Anglo-Irish Treaty to continue what was ultimately a very low level of armed resistance to the existence of Northern Ireland and the provisional IRA (the one that conducts a multi-decade campaign of bomb attacks that claims the lives of lots of civilians, British and Irish).
Most young Irish people will learn in a fair bit of depth about the whole century of conflict because it's how modern Ireland comes into existence. Most British people won't because it's one independence war amongst many in Britain's 20th Century.
That said, whilst I take the point about perspectives and freedom fighters, you can still make definitive judgements about causes, methods and ideas that separate the ANC from the Provisional IRA.
I certainly bow to your superior knowledge. Interestingly, my parents grew up in Scotland before and during WW2 and they were never taught about Scottish history or even much about the country itself. I imagine it's a bit different now.
[Post edited 12 Oct 2022 16:50]
0
Congratulations to the Irish Woman's football team on 17:11 - Oct 12 with 1848 views
Congratulations to the Irish Woman's football team on 16:46 - Oct 12 by DJR
I certainly bow to your superior knowledge. Interestingly, my parents grew up in Scotland before and during WW2 and they were never taught about Scottish history or even much about the country itself. I imagine it's a bit different now.
[Post edited 12 Oct 2022 16:50]
You would hope!
I teach some of the history of Britain and Ireland to university undergraduates and a lot of the time the starting baseline is essentially zero. Makes it difficult to have a conversation about it that isn't wrenching some quite complicated things from all their pre-history and context.
Congratulations to the Irish Woman's football team on 16:30 - Oct 12 by jayessess
I think specifically the history of Britain and Ireland is complicated, and the general level of knowledge about that history is not evenly distributed between the two places. The IRA is used colloquially to refer to three different organisations. The original IRA - the guerrilla army that liberates the Republic of Ireland from the British, the official IRA - the original organisation that formed immediately after the Anglo-Irish Treaty to continue what was ultimately a very low level of armed resistance to the existence of Northern Ireland and the provisional IRA (the one that conducts a multi-decade campaign of bomb attacks that claims the lives of lots of civilians, British and Irish).
Most young Irish people will learn in a fair bit of depth about the whole century of conflict because it's how modern Ireland comes into existence. Most British people won't because it's one independence war amongst many in Britain's 20th Century.
That said, whilst I take the point about perspectives and freedom fighters, you can still make definitive judgements about causes, methods and ideas that separate the ANC from the Provisional IRA.
There has been a quite patronising attitude towards the Irish girls singing it - one Sky Sports reporter looked especially stupid whilst calling it an education problem.
0
Congratulations to the Irish Woman's football team on 17:45 - Oct 12 with 1765 views
Congratulations to the Irish Woman's football team on 17:11 - Oct 12 by jayessess
You would hope!
I teach some of the history of Britain and Ireland to university undergraduates and a lot of the time the starting baseline is essentially zero. Makes it difficult to have a conversation about it that isn't wrenching some quite complicated things from all their pre-history and context.
Given my parents were taught about English kings and queens, and English but not Scottish authors, it's probably not surprising that people of that generation tend to be more pro-Union than the younger generations.
It would be interesting to know how British and Irish history is taught in Northern Ireland. I wonder if it is taught differently in Protestant and Catholic schools. Or perhaps it just isn't taught at all, if a common line is needed for the purpose of exams.
The need to inform people properly about history would probably be regarded these days as woke, but it shows to me the importance of things like Black History Month.
0
Congratulations to the Irish Woman's football team on 17:55 - Oct 12 with 1746 views
Congratulations to the Irish Woman's football team on 17:25 - Oct 12 by JakeITFC
There has been a quite patronising attitude towards the Irish girls singing it - one Sky Sports reporter looked especially stupid whilst calling it an education problem.
I think George Orwell summed up this type of thing perfectly in the following quote.
"At any given moment there is an orthodoxy, a body of ideas which it is assumed that all right-thinking people will accept without question."
These days I am constantly reminded of this quote when voices to the contrary are effectively suppressed in all manner of issues eg. republicanism following the death of the Queen.
1
Congratulations to the Irish Woman's football team on 19:12 - Oct 12 with 1640 views
This thread has gone off in a direction I was not expecting. There seems to be a bit of begrudgery from some posters, if the foolish singing of 'up the RA' song in the dressing room is the take away from this. I don't hear any sectarian or derogatory words in the audio clip. I think that Irish manager, Vera Pauw, put it in context in her apology as did the team members. https://www.rte.ie/sport/soccer/2022/1012/1328693-fai-apologise-for-offensive-so
Congratulations to the Irish Woman's football team on 13:58 - Oct 12 by AlamoSam
Congratulations. Pity the whole thing is being marred by horrific sectarian chanting by the team afterwards. Hope they and anyone else involved in this sort of rubbish are slapped with long bans.
Horrific sectarian chanting?
Get over yourself and educate yourself on Irish history.
There was absolutely no intention of sectarian chanting last night.
2
Congratulations to the Irish Woman's football team on 19:58 - Oct 12 with 1531 views
By continuing to use the site, you agree to our use of cookies and to abide by our Terms and Conditions.
