Please log in or register. Registered visitors get fewer ads.
Forum index | Previous Thread | Next thread
It's not a penalty 20:17 - Jul 10 with 10271 viewsGarv

The sad thing is it's not surprising.

But football is absolute bobbins now. Other sports must be laughing at it.

Poll: If forced to sell one of the following this summer, who would you sell?

6
It's not a penalty on 20:17 - Jul 10BrianTablet

Absolute sh*te decision.
Football has done itself one.
[Post edited 10 Jul 2024 20:17]

"......Paul Mariner......John Wark...... Brian Tablet...errrrrrr Talbot."
Poll: You live in Clacton. You are duty-bound to vote. Who do you vote for?

0
It's not a penalty on 20:17 - Jul 10Bent_double

daft decision

Poll: So what do we think will happen with MM and the Aston Villa job?

0
It's not a penalty on 20:19 - Jul 10surreyblue

I mean, if the same challenge happens in the centre circle it's a foul and a yellow.

But if I take my england-tinted glasses off, completely agree
1
It's not a penalty on 20:21 - Jul 10redrickstuhaart

It's not a penalty on 20:19 - Jul 10 by surreyblue

I mean, if the same challenge happens in the centre circle it's a foul and a yellow.

But if I take my england-tinted glasses off, completely agree


Not if the contact is the other player's movement and follow through it isnt.

Poll: Spectrum or C64 / Pablo or Kuqi- your preferences?

2
It's not a penalty on 20:22 - Jul 10RamRob

It's not a penalty on 20:17 - Jul 10 by Bent_double

daft decision


Shouldn't really be a penalty but I can see how that can be perceived as dangerous play by the defender, studs up, out of control.
Compared to some "high foot" decisions I think this was more dangerous than most.
Just surprised they sent him to look at it. Southgate must've bribed the VAR

Poll: What should be the music when opposition score?

0
It's not a penalty on 20:23 - Jul 10Lord_Lucan

Football is screwed baby.

“Hello, I'm your MP. Actually I'm not. I'm your candidate. Gosh.” Boris Johnson canvassing in Henley, 2005.
Poll: How will you be celebrating Prince Phils life today

0
It's not a penalty on 20:26 - Jul 10Garv

It's not a penalty on 20:19 - Jul 10 by surreyblue

I mean, if the same challenge happens in the centre circle it's a foul and a yellow.

But if I take my england-tinted glasses off, completely agree


The threshold for a penalty is different to that of a foul on halfway. Rightly so.

Poll: If forced to sell one of the following this summer, who would you sell?

1
It's not a penalty on 20:26 - Jul 10DublinBlue84

Never a penalty in a million years, if it was, I hate to think how many we've been robbed of in the last two years.

It's very difficult to defend VAR when there are howlers like that.

Poll: Should Davis have been sent off?

3
Login to get fewer ads

It's not a penalty on 20:31 - Jul 10redrickstuhaart

It's not a penalty on 20:26 - Jul 10 by Garv

The threshold for a penalty is different to that of a foul on halfway. Rightly so.


Show us the rule that says that.

No good reason at all for there to be a difference. And there isnt, according to the laws.

Poll: Spectrum or C64 / Pablo or Kuqi- your preferences?

2
It's not a penalty on 20:35 - Jul 10Ewan_Oozami

It's not a penalty on 20:26 - Jul 10 by Garv

The threshold for a penalty is different to that of a foul on halfway. Rightly so.


Why is the threshold different? A foul is a foul. In fact the only person who gets away with stuff in the area that they wouldn't outside it is the goalkeeper..

You are the obsolete SRN4 to my Fairey Rotodyne....
Poll: What else could go on top of the cake apart from icing and a cherry?

0
It's not a penalty on 20:39 - Jul 10Swansea_Blue

It's not a penalty on 20:26 - Jul 10 by Garv

The threshold for a penalty is different to that of a foul on halfway. Rightly so.


I don’t think it is. Every part of the pitch has exactly the same laws.

Poll: Escaped Goat of the day. Who’s it going to be?

3
It's not a penalty on 20:40 - Jul 10crouchendyachtclub

It's not a penalty on 20:21 - Jul 10 by redrickstuhaart

Not if the contact is the other player's movement and follow through it isnt.


That’s not right though is it, who got sent of for Cov vs Leicester last season for a similar one but from the side? Everyone said it was rubbish but a foul and this is the same. It’s a late challenge and even though it’s changed nothing it’s still a foul in the modern game.

Edit: it was Fatawu that got sent off but the challenge I’m thinking of was Bobby Thomas for the penalty.
[Post edited 10 Jul 2024 20:45]
0
It's not a penalty on 20:42 - Jul 10Freddy

Never ever a penalty, crazy decision
0
It's not a penalty on 20:43 - Jul 10redrickstuhaart

It's not a penalty on 20:40 - Jul 10 by crouchendyachtclub

That’s not right though is it, who got sent of for Cov vs Leicester last season for a similar one but from the side? Everyone said it was rubbish but a foul and this is the same. It’s a late challenge and even though it’s changed nothing it’s still a foul in the modern game.

Edit: it was Fatawu that got sent off but the challenge I’m thinking of was Bobby Thomas for the penalty.
[Post edited 10 Jul 2024 20:45]


Its not late. His foot is just there. Awful awful decision.

Poll: Spectrum or C64 / Pablo or Kuqi- your preferences?

0
It's not a penalty on 20:46 - Jul 10crouchendyachtclub

It's not a penalty on 20:43 - Jul 10 by redrickstuhaart

Its not late. His foot is just there. Awful awful decision.


If it wasn’t late he’d have blocked the ball rather than stud the foot.

I don’t like it but it’s what it is.
3
It's not a penalty on 20:47 - Jul 10redrickstuhaart

It's not a penalty on 20:46 - Jul 10 by crouchendyachtclub

If it wasn’t late he’d have blocked the ball rather than stud the foot.

I don’t like it but it’s what it is.


Its not late, because he didnt kick Kane. Kane kicked him.

Poll: Spectrum or C64 / Pablo or Kuqi- your preferences?

3
It's not a penalty on 20:53 - Jul 10RadioOrwell

Penalty for me.
Studs up.
Said it as soon as it happened.
Anywhere on the pitch it's a foul.
QED - a penalty.
0
It's not a penalty on 20:56 - Jul 10Europablue

It's not a penalty on 20:31 - Jul 10 by redrickstuhaart

Show us the rule that says that.

No good reason at all for there to be a difference. And there isnt, according to the laws.


The scrutiny on a penalty decision will be much higher so the threshold for giving one has to be much higher.
-1
It's not a penalty on 20:56 - Jul 10redrickstuhaart

It's not a penalty on 20:56 - Jul 10 by Europablue

The scrutiny on a penalty decision will be much higher so the threshold for giving one has to be much higher.


Simply not true or logical.

Poll: Spectrum or C64 / Pablo or Kuqi- your preferences?

3
It's not a penalty on 20:56 - Jul 10RadioOrwell

It's not a penalty on 20:56 - Jul 10 by Europablue

The scrutiny on a penalty decision will be much higher so the threshold for giving one has to be much higher.


you're making things up now
0
It's not a penalty on 20:59 - Jul 10Ewan_Oozami

It's not a penalty on 20:56 - Jul 10 by Europablue

The scrutiny on a penalty decision will be much higher so the threshold for giving one has to be much higher.


What? That doesn't make any sense whatsoever. The scrutiny is higher, yes, because the potential outcome is potentially more impactful - but that scrutiny is only there to see if it's a foul or not, not whether it meets some hypothetical threshold for a penalty to be given.

You are the obsolete SRN4 to my Fairey Rotodyne....
Poll: What else could go on top of the cake apart from icing and a cherry?

1
It's not a penalty on 21:02 - Jul 10The_Flashing_Smile

Defender makes contact with Kane not the ball. Blatant pen. I don't know what anyone else is seeing.

Trust the process. Trust Phil.
Blog: Between The Lines 2, The Irreverent PREM Poetry Of ITFC - Match 9 - “Hulloween”

3
It's not a penalty on 21:32 - Jul 10RamRob

There you go, middle of the pitch, Dutch player kicks Bellingham, Free kick & Bellingham gets a yellow.

Poll: What should be the music when opposition score?

0
It's not a penalty on 21:34 - Jul 10redrickstuhaart

It's not a penalty on 21:32 - Jul 10 by RamRob

There you go, middle of the pitch, Dutch player kicks Bellingham, Free kick & Bellingham gets a yellow.


Not remotely comparable.

Poll: Spectrum or C64 / Pablo or Kuqi- your preferences?

0
It's not a penalty on 21:35 - Jul 10RamRob

It's not a penalty on 21:34 - Jul 10 by redrickstuhaart

Not remotely comparable.


I'll have to check what definition of comparable you're using, because it's literally what I just did...

Poll: What should be the music when opposition score?

0
About Us Contact Us Terms & Conditions Privacy Cookies Online Safety Advertising
© TWTD 1995-2026