| Yellow Cards 09:26 - Sep 18 with 2213 views | bluesbrothers |
By my calculations Morsy already on 4, Hladky up to 3 already...
Not ideal |  | | |  |
| Yellow Cards on 09:27 - Sep 18 with 2204 views | RobTheMonk |
Hladky has got them for exactly the same thing each time lol. He just needs to be quicker on restarts. |  | | |
| Yellow Cards on 09:45 - Sep 18 with 2116 views | SitfcB |
| Yellow Cards on 09:27 - Sep 18 by RobTheMonk |
Hladky has got them for exactly the same thing each time lol. He just needs to be quicker on restarts. |
Hladky’s have all been very harsh.
Each time he’s been booked the opposition GK has taken the same time, if not longer to kick it, yet because they’re on the losing team they don’t get carded.
The referee told the Sheff Utd GK on Saturday to ‘just go long’ instead of waiting to go short ffs. |  |
| |
| Yellow Cards on 09:48 - Sep 18 with 2096 views | Sharkey |
| Yellow Cards on 09:45 - Sep 18 by SitfcB |
Hladky’s have all been very harsh.
Each time he’s been booked the opposition GK has taken the same time, if not longer to kick it, yet because they’re on the losing team they don’t get carded.
The referee told the Sheff Utd GK on Saturday to ‘just go long’ instead of waiting to go short ffs. |
I don't see the ref said anything wrong there. If you don't trust your defenders to accept your pass because they're too tightly marked or not quite as good as Man City's or Real Madrid's, you're going to have to do something else. [Post edited 18 Sep 2023 9:51]
|  | | |
| Yellow Cards on 10:16 - Sep 18 with 2007 views | Basuco |
| Yellow Cards on 09:45 - Sep 18 by SitfcB |
Hladky’s have all been very harsh.
Each time he’s been booked the opposition GK has taken the same time, if not longer to kick it, yet because they’re on the losing team they don’t get carded.
The referee told the Sheff Utd GK on Saturday to ‘just go long’ instead of waiting to go short ffs. |
Sheffield were doing a lot of time wasting, my guess is that while it remains at 1 - 0 they only need one chance or set piece to go in and get the draw, as well, they knew they were not fit enough to chase the ball for 90 minutes against our high possession game, they were all on their knees for the last 15 minutes of the game. |  | | |
| Yellow Cards on 10:40 - Sep 18 with 1932 views | homer_123 |
| Yellow Cards on 09:27 - Sep 18 by RobTheMonk |
Hladky has got them for exactly the same thing each time lol. He just needs to be quicker on restarts. |
Unless he's being instructed to work at the pace.....just a thought. |  |
| |
| Yellow Cards on 10:53 - Sep 18 with 1882 views | textbackup |
| Yellow Cards on 09:48 - Sep 18 by Sharkey |
I don't see the ref said anything wrong there. If you don't trust your defenders to accept your pass because they're too tightly marked or not quite as good as Man City's or Real Madrid's, you're going to have to do something else. [Post edited 18 Sep 2023 9:51]
|
So the ref can dictate how a team plays? |  |
| |
| Yellow Cards on 11:38 - Sep 18 with 1808 views | Sharkey |
| Yellow Cards on 10:53 - Sep 18 by textbackup |
So the ref can dictate how a team plays? |
Absolutely not. The ref can only apply the rules. He can't wait for a goalkeeper who doesn't have the confidence to play the short ball he'd been hoping to play. Conversely, the ref can't object to a team 'wasting time' by knocking the ball back and forth between the goalkeeper and a defender if the other team doesn't press, because it's not against the rules. And, sadly, at present the ref can't penalise a team for wasting time at the other end of the pitch by running the ball up against the corner flag and then huddling around it, because ugly though it is, it's not against the rules, yet. (I recently saw Colchester do this when 3-0 up in extra time at Gillingham, so engrained is this culture of time-wasting.) If the ref was allowed to dictate the aesthetics of the game rather than just follow the rules, he'd surely penalise this. [Post edited 18 Sep 2023 11:51]
| | | |
| Yellow Cards on 13:00 - Sep 18 with 1661 views | SheffordBlue |
| Yellow Cards on 11:38 - Sep 18 by Sharkey |
Absolutely not. The ref can only apply the rules. He can't wait for a goalkeeper who doesn't have the confidence to play the short ball he'd been hoping to play. Conversely, the ref can't object to a team 'wasting time' by knocking the ball back and forth between the goalkeeper and a defender if the other team doesn't press, because it's not against the rules. And, sadly, at present the ref can't penalise a team for wasting time at the other end of the pitch by running the ball up against the corner flag and then huddling around it, because ugly though it is, it's not against the rules, yet. (I recently saw Colchester do this when 3-0 up in extra time at Gillingham, so engrained is this culture of time-wasting.) If the ref was allowed to dictate the aesthetics of the game rather than just follow the rules, he'd surely penalise this. [Post edited 18 Sep 2023 11:51]
|
There were a couple of times on Saturday where just as Hladky was going to go short the Wednesday players decided to press higher up the pitch . I think then he's entirely justified in changing his decision to play it short then. If they've applied a high press throughout the set up and he can't make his mind up then the yellow is probably justified but it does need some context applied. | |
| |
Login to get fewer ads
| Yellow Cards on 13:43 - Sep 18 with 1576 views | BigCommon |
Morsy was always going to get a cumulative suspension at some point. He's OK for Southampton, that's all that matters atm, imo..Plus we've got Taylor, Ball, Evans who can all step in and do a job. Taylor must be begging for a start..
I'm in agreement with others on Hladky. Rather harsh to be on 3 yellows. I suspect, depending on Waltons readiness, KM will have a word, not just with Hladky, but with others to get set quicker so he can release the ball quicker.. |  | | |
| Yellow Cards on 14:18 - Sep 18 with 1519 views | Sharkey |
| Yellow Cards on 13:00 - Sep 18 by SheffordBlue |
There were a couple of times on Saturday where just as Hladky was going to go short the Wednesday players decided to press higher up the pitch . I think then he's entirely justified in changing his decision to play it short then. If they've applied a high press throughout the set up and he can't make his mind up then the yellow is probably justified but it does need some context applied. |
They're entitled to run around as they like. They will have looked at previous games and know what Town like to do, ("They want the keeper to give it the 5, on his left foot", or whatever) and 'anticipate' that move at the last moment and block it off. I'm not saying the ref wasn't too quick to penalise Hladky, (I haven't seen it, and it sounds like he was), but the ref can't wait for ever for the keeper to find a short pass to his liking. | | | |
| Yellow Cards on 14:35 - Sep 18 with 1496 views | Meadowlark |
Tuesday night's ref has already booked Morsy and Hladky once each this season, so we know what we can expect from him, but the Hladky booking and JD's in the same game for allegedly time wasting were daft decisions. In fact all of Hladky's bookings have been ridiculous decisions. |  | | |
| Yellow Cards on 14:39 - Sep 18 with 1476 views | tractorboy1978 |
| Yellow Cards on 14:18 - Sep 18 by Sharkey |
They're entitled to run around as they like. They will have looked at previous games and know what Town like to do, ("They want the keeper to give it the 5, on his left foot", or whatever) and 'anticipate' that move at the last moment and block it off. I'm not saying the ref wasn't too quick to penalise Hladky, (I haven't seen it, and it sounds like he was), but the ref can't wait for ever for the keeper to find a short pass to his liking. |
Don't think anyone is suggesting they do wait forever. Playing out from the back may take a few seconds longer than lumping it up the pitch though in the same way lining up for a long throw may take a few seconds longer than taking a short throw. | | | |
| Yellow Cards on 14:40 - Sep 18 with 1476 views | nrb1985 |
| Yellow Cards on 13:43 - Sep 18 by BigCommon |
Morsy was always going to get a cumulative suspension at some point. He's OK for Southampton, that's all that matters atm, imo..Plus we've got Taylor, Ball, Evans who can all step in and do a job. Taylor must be begging for a start..
I'm in agreement with others on Hladky. Rather harsh to be on 3 yellows. I suspect, depending on Waltons readiness, KM will have a word, not just with Hladky, but with others to get set quicker so he can release the ball quicker.. |
by my reckoning most if not all of Morsy's yellows have been committed after somebody has played him an absolute hospital pass or given the ball away sloppily. Think that may have been the case on Saturday too. Very harsh he'll be the one who picks up the suspension. | | | |
| |
By continuing to use the site, you agree to our use of cookies and to abide by our Terms and Conditions.
