| Billy Gilmour 17:01 - Jul 20 with 4188 views | Nutkins_Return |
Napoli had £8 million bid rejected. If he's available up to £12-13 million we should be in for him. That would be good business at his age profile. Can forgive the Norwich games as was Loan... |  |
| |  |
| Billy Gilmour on 17:12 - Jul 20 with 4037 views | CaptainAhab |
Didn't he have a falling out with the Norwich fans? Make it doubly funny if he came here and tore it up! | | | |
| Billy Gilmour on 17:14 - Jul 20 with 4019 views | Mullet |
| Billy Gilmour on 17:12 - Jul 20 by CaptainAhab |
Didn't he have a falling out with the Norwich fans? Make it doubly funny if he came here and tore it up! |
He did in a Brandon Williams kind of way! Not sure how good he actually is in fairness |  |
| |
| Billy Gilmour on 17:14 - Jul 20 with 4024 views | Parky |
If Conte and Napoli are interested, I very much doubt he’d pick here. | | | |
| Billy Gilmour on 17:34 - Jul 20 with 3832 views | Nutkins_Return |
| Billy Gilmour on 17:14 - Jul 20 by Mullet |
He did in a Brandon Williams kind of way! Not sure how good he actually is in fairness |
Scotland always so much better when he plays. Good player. Small though. | |
| |
| Billy Gilmour on 17:38 - Jul 20 with 3792 views | Mercian |
I am not trying to be facetious but he's a Humphreys upgrade. They both can play in defensive midfield but neither have the physical strength or aggression to be naturals in that role. A good player though with a high ceiling. [Post edited 20 Jul 2024 17:39]
|  | | |
| Billy Gilmour on 17:48 - Jul 20 with 3675 views | J2BLUE |
No thanks |  |
| |
| Billy Gilmour on 17:55 - Jul 20 with 3619 views | Nutkins_Return |
| Billy Gilmour on 17:38 - Jul 20 by Mercian |
I am not trying to be facetious but he's a Humphreys upgrade. They both can play in defensive midfield but neither have the physical strength or aggression to be naturals in that role. A good player though with a high ceiling. [Post edited 20 Jul 2024 17:39]
|
Taking my Ipswich specs off he's miles ahead of Humphreys.
Humphreys has to go out and play a season and we will see how he can progress! | |
| |
| Billy Gilmour on 17:58 - Jul 20 with 3590 views | jontysnut |
Hopefully if only for a song based on Looking Through Billy Gilmours Eyes |  | | |
Login to get fewer ads
| Billy Gilmour on 18:04 - Jul 20 with 3534 views | MK1 |
We can do better. |  |
| |
| Billy Gilmour on 19:00 - Jul 20 with 3250 views | backwaywhen |
It’s a NO from me . | | | |
| Billy Gilmour on 19:20 - Jul 20 with 3152 views | Mercian |
| Billy Gilmour on 17:55 - Jul 20 by Nutkins_Return |
Taking my Ipswich specs off he's miles ahead of Humphreys.
Humphreys has to go out and play a season and we will see how he can progress! |
He is miles ahead but I do think they are similar. No one seems to know what their best position is. Both can play as a full back and as a defensive midfielder but both are probably best as a number 8 which is a position we do not use. That is why Gilmour is a no for me. Not because he is not good enough but because he does not fit our system. | | | |
| Billy Gilmour on 19:23 - Jul 20 with 3126 views | ibbleobble |
| Billy Gilmour on 17:14 - Jul 20 by Parky |
If Conte and Napoli are interested, I very much doubt he’d pick here. |
…we’re premier league now, yes he would. | | | |
| Billy Gilmour on 19:38 - Jul 20 with 3027 views | Nutkins_Return |
| Billy Gilmour on 19:20 - Jul 20 by Mercian |
He is miles ahead but I do think they are similar. No one seems to know what their best position is. Both can play as a full back and as a defensive midfielder but both are probably best as a number 8 which is a position we do not use. That is why Gilmour is a no for me. Not because he is not good enough but because he does not fit our system. |
Yes that's fair. I do want Humphreys to have a pathway as well and nail down a position. For me he's a midfielder. A number 8. He just needs to go and play 40+ games in that role.
Billy Gilmour for £10-12 million at 23 just makes sense to me. Quality player. Probably only goes up in value. | |
| |
| Billy Gilmour on 20:54 - Jul 20 with 2720 views | Mercian |
| Billy Gilmour on 19:38 - Jul 20 by Nutkins_Return |
Yes that's fair. I do want Humphreys to have a pathway as well and nail down a position. For me he's a midfielder. A number 8. He just needs to go and play 40+ games in that role.
Billy Gilmour for £10-12 million at 23 just makes sense to me. Quality player. Probably only goes up in value. |
Of the clubs promoted into The Championship I think both Derby and Portsmouth will survive and either would be a good loan move for Cam. I expect Oxford will struggle and be relegated so I don't think that will be a good move. I would edge towards Derby as they mostly play a 5-3-2 formation which would suit him better. Other options would be good Scottish Prem clubs like Hibs or Aberdeen. Birmingham is another possibility. He would be a regular there and they are quite possibly the best team to be relegated in the last decade and I do not expect them to be caught in the same slog that many relatively big clubs relegated to League One like ourselves did. A good move I think. [Post edited 20 Jul 2024 21:03]
| | | |
| Billy Gilmour on 21:03 - Jul 20 with 2634 views | franz_tyson |
| Billy Gilmour on 20:54 - Jul 20 by Mercian |
Of the clubs promoted into The Championship I think both Derby and Portsmouth will survive and either would be a good loan move for Cam. I expect Oxford will struggle and be relegated so I don't think that will be a good move. I would edge towards Derby as they mostly play a 5-3-2 formation which would suit him better. Other options would be good Scottish Prem clubs like Hibs or Aberdeen. Birmingham is another possibility. He would be a regular there and they are quite possibly the best team to be relegated in the last decade and I do not expect them to be caught in the same slog that many relatively big clubs relegated to League One like ourselves did. A good move I think. [Post edited 20 Jul 2024 21:03]
|
Why would his level be Championship? He started one game and was sub twice last season. Just because we've got promoted it doesn't mean our kid's loans are the league below. Ŵhen we were League One, we got loanees from PL clubs. Id say his best bet is L1 so he's got more chance to nail down a starting spot.
Cam Humphreys needs games and not more stting on the bench or being a non-playing squad member. | | | |
| Billy Gilmour on 21:05 - Jul 20 with 2625 views | Mercian |
| Billy Gilmour on 21:03 - Jul 20 by franz_tyson |
Why would his level be Championship? He started one game and was sub twice last season. Just because we've got promoted it doesn't mean our kid's loans are the league below. Ŵhen we were League One, we got loanees from PL clubs. Id say his best bet is L1 so he's got more chance to nail down a starting spot.
Cam Humphreys needs games and not more stting on the bench or being a non-playing squad member. |
Since your reply I edited the post and suggested Birmingham. Do you think that would work for him? [Post edited 20 Jul 2024 21:05]
| | | |
| Billy Gilmour on 23:54 - Jul 21 with 1681 views | rickw |
He's a good player but doesn't have the physicality or aggression for a McKenna-ball midfielder so I can't see it |  |
| |
| Billy Gilmour on 00:23 - Jul 22 with 1636 views | ParisBlue |
| Billy Gilmour on 20:54 - Jul 20 by Mercian |
Of the clubs promoted into The Championship I think both Derby and Portsmouth will survive and either would be a good loan move for Cam. I expect Oxford will struggle and be relegated so I don't think that will be a good move. I would edge towards Derby as they mostly play a 5-3-2 formation which would suit him better. Other options would be good Scottish Prem clubs like Hibs or Aberdeen. Birmingham is another possibility. He would be a regular there and they are quite possibly the best team to be relegated in the last decade and I do not expect them to be caught in the same slog that many relatively big clubs relegated to League One like ourselves did. A good move I think. [Post edited 20 Jul 2024 21:03]
|
Not sure he's suited to a Paul Warne team. And Derby may struggle.
I'd like to see him at a top end side where he can gain confidence, so probably league one. If he excels we can always recall him in January and send him up higher.
On the same subject, Baggott needs a championship loan. |  |
| |
| |
By continuing to use the site, you agree to our use of cookies and to abide by our Terms and Conditions.
