| Cricket: T20 Semi Final Thread on 09:45 - Nov 10 with 1276 views | Simonds92 |
| Cricket: T20 Semi Final Thread on 09:29 - Nov 10 by Guthrum |
Or the umpires have the freedom to make whatever decision they think correct in real time, knowing that any errors will be cleared up if one side or the other chooses to review. |
I dont know, maybe? Just asking the question really thanks for those clarifying with the half a ball scenario though it does at least make a bit of sense. It does seem strange that we trust the goal line technology to the absolute millimetre but dont trust it in cricket when i believe its very similar tech. |  | |  |
| Cricket: T20 Semi Final Thread on 09:54 - Nov 10 with 1251 views | gainsboroughblue |
Decent start. 18/0. |  |
| |
| Cricket: T20 Semi Final Thread on 09:59 - Nov 10 with 1230 views | Steve_M |
| Cricket: T20 Semi Final Thread on 09:45 - Nov 10 by Simonds92 |
I dont know, maybe? Just asking the question really thanks for those clarifying with the half a ball scenario though it does at least make a bit of sense. It does seem strange that we trust the goal line technology to the absolute millimetre but dont trust it in cricket when i believe its very similar tech. |
The key difference though is that cricket uses a projection of where the ball is likely to have gone had it not struck the batter, football and tennis can use where the ball actually went for line decisions.
It does work pretty well in cricket, albeit with some oddities at times, but it tool some adapting to at first there too. |  |
| |
| Cricket: T20 Semi Final Thread on 10:01 - Nov 10 with 1228 views | Zx1988 |
| Cricket: T20 Semi Final Thread on 09:45 - Nov 10 by Simonds92 |
I dont know, maybe? Just asking the question really thanks for those clarifying with the half a ball scenario though it does at least make a bit of sense. It does seem strange that we trust the goal line technology to the absolute millimetre but dont trust it in cricket when i believe its very similar tech. |
I think that the key distinction (on goals vs. LBW at least) is that the goal is a matter of absolute fact (i.e. has all of the ball crossed the line) whereas the LBW decision is based on a projection (i.e. would the ball have gone on to hit the stumps).
The goal is a very clear binary yes/no answer, whereas the LBW is 'we think it would have done, but with x.xx% margin of error. I like that cricket acknowledges that the technology is also fallible, rather than insisting that it is 100% correct 100% of the time. | |
| |
| Cricket: T20 Semi Final Thread on 10:13 - Nov 10 with 1195 views | Zx1988 |
| Cricket: T20 Semi Final Thread on 09:59 - Nov 10 by Steve_M |
The key difference though is that cricket uses a projection of where the ball is likely to have gone had it not struck the batter, football and tennis can use where the ball actually went for line decisions.
It does work pretty well in cricket, albeit with some oddities at times, but it tool some adapting to at first there too. |
There are also situations where the DRS system works perfectly:
(What the image doesn't show, is that this was actually an England review after Finch had originally been given 'not out'!) | |
| |
| Cricket: T20 Semi Final Thread on 10:15 - Nov 10 with 1189 views | SaleAway |
| Cricket: T20 Semi Final Thread on 10:01 - Nov 10 by Zx1988 |
I think that the key distinction (on goals vs. LBW at least) is that the goal is a matter of absolute fact (i.e. has all of the ball crossed the line) whereas the LBW decision is based on a projection (i.e. would the ball have gone on to hit the stumps).
The goal is a very clear binary yes/no answer, whereas the LBW is 'we think it would have done, but with x.xx% margin of error. I like that cricket acknowledges that the technology is also fallible, rather than insisting that it is 100% correct 100% of the time. |
What you to remember with the DRS, is that it is designed " to remove clear and obvious errors". It is not designed to make sure every decision is 100% perfect. So they always bias it into the umpires decision.
Moving back to the game, cracking powerplay for england | |
| |
| Cricket: T20 Semi Final Thread on 10:20 - Nov 10 with 1181 views | gainsboroughblue |
Rattling away here. Love to see it. | |
| |
| Cricket: T20 Semi Final Thread on 10:20 - Nov 10 with 1181 views | Zx1988 |
| Cricket: T20 Semi Final Thread on 10:15 - Nov 10 by SaleAway |
What you to remember with the DRS, is that it is designed " to remove clear and obvious errors". It is not designed to make sure every decision is 100% perfect. So they always bias it into the umpires decision.
Moving back to the game, cracking powerplay for england |
Agreed - they'll be dead chuffed with that. Doubly so with extending it to 75/7.
No further comment, though. | |
| |
Login to get fewer ads
| Cricket: T20 Semi Final Thread on 10:23 - Nov 10 with 1177 views | clive_baker |
I'm going to whisper this quietly, and I'm certainly not getting carried away, but this isn't the worst start for England... |  |
| |
| Cricket: T20 Semi Final Thread on 10:25 - Nov 10 with 1168 views | Zx1988 |
| Cricket: T20 Semi Final Thread on 10:23 - Nov 10 by clive_baker |
I'm going to whisper this quietly, and I'm certainly not getting carried away, but this isn't the worst start for England... |
I'll balance this all out by chipping in that this has been an appalling start for England, and they'll be absolutely gutted with how they've fared so far.
It's India's to lose  | |
| |
| Cricket: T20 Semi Final Thread on 10:49 - Nov 10 with 1119 views | gainsboroughblue |
A 10 wicket win here would be quite the statement. | |
| |
| Cricket: T20 Semi Final Thread on 10:56 - Nov 10 with 1093 views | Steve_M |
| Cricket: T20 Semi Final Thread on 10:49 - Nov 10 by gainsboroughblue |
A 10 wicket win here would be quite the statement. |
Even you can't jinx this from here, although we'll probably lose a wicket. Really impressive to take the start from the SL and just be so relentless with the scoring.
I thought Hales had a chance of a century at one point and then Butler hogged the strike. | |
| |
| Cricket: T20 Semi Final Thread on 10:57 - Nov 10 with 1091 views | Ewan_Oozami |
| Cricket: T20 Semi Final Thread on 10:49 - Nov 10 by gainsboroughblue |
A 10 wicket win here would be quite the statement. |
Possibly one of the most comprehensive wins I've seen in a WC T20 - would have been over sooner if Kohli and Hardik hadn't upped the run rate in the last 5 overs... |  |
| |
| Cricket: T20 Semi Final Thread on 10:59 - Nov 10 with 1079 views | chicoazul |
Bet they’re glad they let Hales off the naughty step. |  |
| |
| Cricket: T20 Semi Final Thread on 11:01 - Nov 10 with 1069 views | gainsboroughblue |
| Cricket: T20 Semi Final Thread on 10:56 - Nov 10 by Steve_M |
Even you can't jinx this from here, although we'll probably lose a wicket. Really impressive to take the start from the SL and just be so relentless with the scoring.
I thought Hales had a chance of a century at one point and then Butler hogged the strike. |
Should be a fascinating game Sunday. Arguably the two most mercurial sides in world cricket. God knows which version of each will turn up. Eng coming good at the right time though. [Post edited 10 Nov 2022 11:02]
| |
| |
| Cricket: T20 Semi Final Thread on 11:02 - Nov 10 with 1067 views | Steve_M |
Absolutely brutal batting, winning with four overs to spare. | |
| |
| Cricket: T20 Semi Final Thread on 11:03 - Nov 10 with 1061 views | BlueandTruesince82 |
Alex Hales and Jos Buter are utter monsters! |  |
| |
| Cricket: T20 Semi Final Thread on 11:05 - Nov 10 with 1054 views | Steve_M |
| Cricket: T20 Semi Final Thread on 11:01 - Nov 10 by gainsboroughblue |
Should be a fascinating game Sunday. Arguably the two most mercurial sides in world cricket. God knows which version of each will turn up. Eng coming good at the right time though. [Post edited 10 Nov 2022 11:02]
|
I want revenge for '92. | |
| |
| Cricket: T20 Semi Final Thread on 11:06 - Nov 10 with 1044 views | Geomorph |
great to see the town badge on the hadleigh flag |  | | |
| Cricket: T20 Semi Final Thread on 11:06 - Nov 10 with 1046 views | clive_baker |
| Cricket: T20 Semi Final Thread on 10:57 - Nov 10 by Ewan_Oozami |
Possibly one of the most comprehensive wins I've seen in a WC T20 - would have been over sooner if Kohli and Hardik hadn't upped the run rate in the last 5 overs... |
Has to be one of England's best T20 performances ever? Would've got good odds on a 10 wicket victory! | |
| |
| Cricket: T20 Semi Final Thread on 11:06 - Nov 10 with 1038 views | farkenhell |
What a thrashing! | | | |
| Cricket: T20 Semi Final Thread on 11:07 - Nov 10 with 1037 views | Steve_M |
| |
| |
| Cricket: T20 Semi Final Thread on 11:08 - Nov 10 with 1029 views | gainsboroughblue |
| Cricket: T20 Semi Final Thread on 11:05 - Nov 10 by Steve_M |
I want revenge for '92. |
That was gutting! We were robbed in the earlier game against them as well. Bowled them out for 75, then the rain came. | |
| |
| Cricket: T20 Semi Final Thread on 11:16 - Nov 10 with 994 views | Daninthecampo |
| Cricket: T20 Semi Final Thread on 11:01 - Nov 10 by gainsboroughblue |
Should be a fascinating game Sunday. Arguably the two most mercurial sides in world cricket. God knows which version of each will turn up. Eng coming good at the right time though. [Post edited 10 Nov 2022 11:02]
|
I'm hoping one of the main channels will show it like they did for the one day final. Strangely Not one of my cricket streams has been working for this tournament
England to win! | | | |
| Cricket: T20 Semi Final Thread on 11:19 - Nov 10 with 990 views | gainsboroughblue |
| Cricket: T20 Semi Final Thread on 11:16 - Nov 10 by Daninthecampo |
I'm hoping one of the main channels will show it like they did for the one day final. Strangely Not one of my cricket streams has been working for this tournament
England to win! |
Me too. I've not seen a ball of this tournament. The only highlights I have seen have been clips on youtube where the editing has rendered it pretty unwatchable. | |
| |
| |
By continuing to use the site, you agree to our use of cookies and to abide by our Terms and Conditions.
