Please log in or register. Registered visitors get fewer ads.
Forum index | Previous Thread | Next thread
Embarrassing decision by the referee there. 16:57 - Jan 10 with 1969 viewsITFC_84

Nowhere near a pen
0
Embarrassing decision by the referee there. on 16:58 - Jan 10 with 1927 viewsJoey_Joe_Joe_Junior

What a clown.

Poll: Ok gut feeling then, promotion?

0
Embarrassing decision by the referee there. on 16:59 - Jan 10 with 1885 viewstonybied

Good job we got the 2nd, so it didn't matter.
1
Embarrassing decision by the referee there. on 17:00 - Jan 10 with 1844 viewsfarkenhell

Embarrassing decision by the referee there. on 16:58 - Jan 10 by Joey_Joe_Joe_Junior

What a clown.


A bit unfair on the OP?
3
Embarrassing decision by the referee there. on 17:04 - Jan 10 with 1755 viewsThe_Flashing_Smile

"Nowhere near" is a bit strong. Pretty close IMO and I can see why the ref's given it.

Trust the process. Trust Phil.
Blog: Between The Lines, The Irreverent Poetry Of Ipswich Town. No.26 - Two One And Tickled Pink

2
Embarrassing decision by the referee there. on 17:06 - Jan 10 with 1706 viewsBanksterDebtSlave

Man then ball.

"They break our legs and tell us to be grateful when they offer us crutches."
Poll: Do you wipe after having a piss?

4
Embarrassing decision by the referee there. on 17:12 - Jan 10 with 1600 viewsVic

I’d have been livid if it was given again me when I was playing. But rules are rules and he touched the players foot first so right decision.

Poll: Right now, who would you rather have as Prime Minister?

1
Embarrassing decision by the referee there. on 17:22 - Jan 10 with 1495 viewsRyorry

Embarrassing decision by the referee there. on 17:12 - Jan 10 by Vic

I’d have been livid if it was given again me when I was playing. But rules are rules and he touched the players foot first so right decision.


Both TownTV commentators immediately said it was a terrible decision by ref, as his view was blocked by a player, he couldn’t possibly have actually seen it - only the Blackpool player falling - and that Greaves got his toe to the ball first.

Poll: Town's most cultured left foot ever?

1
Embarrassing decision by the referee there. on 17:26 - Jan 10 with 1427 viewsThe_Flashing_Smile

Embarrassing decision by the referee there. on 17:22 - Jan 10 by Ryorry

Both TownTV commentators immediately said it was a terrible decision by ref, as his view was blocked by a player, he couldn’t possibly have actually seen it - only the Blackpool player falling - and that Greaves got his toe to the ball first.


Those totally unbiased Town TV commentators!

Trust the process. Trust Phil.
Blog: Between The Lines, The Irreverent Poetry Of Ipswich Town. No.26 - Two One And Tickled Pink

3
Login to get fewer ads

Embarrassing decision by the referee there. on 17:30 - Jan 10 with 1397 viewsRyorry

Embarrassing decision by the referee there. on 17:26 - Jan 10 by The_Flashing_Smile

Those totally unbiased Town TV commentators!


They are very fair, tbf.

(I’m talking about the audio commentators Glenn and Westie just to be clear).

Poll: Town's most cultured left foot ever?

1
Embarrassing decision by the referee there. on 17:37 - Jan 10 with 1304 viewstonybied

Embarrassing decision by the referee there. on 17:30 - Jan 10 by Ryorry

They are very fair, tbf.

(I’m talking about the audio commentators Glenn and Westie just to be clear).


I think Glen is quite fair. Westie clearly isn't, he is very biased, especially at his first viewing of any incidents.
0
Embarrassing decision by the referee there. on 17:39 - Jan 10 with 1284 viewsThe_Flashing_Smile

Embarrassing decision by the referee there. on 17:30 - Jan 10 by Ryorry

They are very fair, tbf.

(I’m talking about the audio commentators Glenn and Westie just to be clear).


Westie is, much more than Glenn (understandably, as a club employee).
My initial reaction was a great tackle, but seeing the replay there is a slight touch on the player first. Seen 'em given, seen 'em not given.

Trust the process. Trust Phil.
Blog: Between The Lines, The Irreverent Poetry Of Ipswich Town. No.26 - Two One And Tickled Pink

1
Embarrassing decision by the referee there. on 17:41 - Jan 10 with 1251 viewsRozz

Embarrassing decision by the referee there. on 17:39 - Jan 10 by The_Flashing_Smile

Westie is, much more than Glenn (understandably, as a club employee).
My initial reaction was a great tackle, but seeing the replay there is a slight touch on the player first. Seen 'em given, seen 'em not given.


Similar story with Brenner and Judge on BBCRS. Both thought it wasn't a pen on viewing the replays.
1
Embarrassing decision by the referee there. on 18:02 - Jan 10 with 1103 viewsBlue_Uprising

Embarrassing decision by the referee there. on 17:41 - Jan 10 by Rozz

Similar story with Brenner and Judge on BBCRS. Both thought it wasn't a pen on viewing the replays.


Judge Jules? - when it comes to penalty calls the Judge won’t Budge. Strange co-commentator choice for Brenner though.
0
Embarrassing decision by the referee there. on 18:15 - Jan 10 with 987 viewsITFC_Forever

Couldn’t really tell from the North Stand, but KMc was pretty animated by his standards at the end.

This is the same ref that sent Edwards off for a second yellow for diving at Cambridge a couple of years ago.

P 1180, W 516, D 302, L 361, F 1782, A 1451 90 / 92
Blog: Confessions of a Statto - Why We Bother

0
Embarrassing decision by the referee there. on 18:20 - Jan 10 with 951 viewsSimonds92

It's definitely a penalty by the way, your not allowed to bring a player down and then touch the ball afterwards.... apparently Greaves was great today, but he always has this in the locker, poor decision making and most importantly making tackles from terrible positions. Maybe he can be a backup left back but as a CB he is far too error prone.
-2
Embarrassing decision by the referee there. on 18:31 - Jan 10 with 870 viewsITFC_Forever

Embarrassing decision by the referee there. on 18:20 - Jan 10 by Simonds92

It's definitely a penalty by the way, your not allowed to bring a player down and then touch the ball afterwards.... apparently Greaves was great today, but he always has this in the locker, poor decision making and most importantly making tackles from terrible positions. Maybe he can be a backup left back but as a CB he is far too error prone.


There’s no apparently about it.

Made numerous important blocks and scored a goal.

P 1180, W 516, D 302, L 361, F 1782, A 1451 90 / 92
Blog: Confessions of a Statto - Why We Bother

2
Embarrassing decision by the referee there. on 19:57 - Jan 10 with 647 viewsWickets

Embarrassing decision by the referee there. on 18:20 - Jan 10 by Simonds92

It's definitely a penalty by the way, your not allowed to bring a player down and then touch the ball afterwards.... apparently Greaves was great today, but he always has this in the locker, poor decision making and most importantly making tackles from terrible positions. Maybe he can be a backup left back but as a CB he is far too error prone.


Must admit I was unsure , yes Greaves gets the ball but think he got the player first ? Harsh but yes you can see why it was given .
0
Embarrassing decision by the referee there. on 20:04 - Jan 10 with 613 viewsPhilTWTD

Embarrassing decision by the referee there. on 18:20 - Jan 10 by Simonds92

It's definitely a penalty by the way, your not allowed to bring a player down and then touch the ball afterwards.... apparently Greaves was great today, but he always has this in the locker, poor decision making and most importantly making tackles from terrible positions. Maybe he can be a backup left back but as a CB he is far too error prone.


Even their manager admitted it shouldn't have been a penalty.
1
Embarrassing decision by the referee there. on 20:19 - Jan 10 with 555 viewsSimonds92

Embarrassing decision by the referee there. on 20:04 - Jan 10 by PhilTWTD

Even their manager admitted it shouldn't have been a penalty.


I've watched it about 10 times on the BBC highlights and he takes his standing leg then gets the ball. VAR give that as a penalty imo.
2
Embarrassing decision by the referee there. on 20:56 - Jan 10 with 447 viewsVic

Embarrassing decision by the referee there. on 18:20 - Jan 10 by Simonds92

It's definitely a penalty by the way, your not allowed to bring a player down and then touch the ball afterwards.... apparently Greaves was great today, but he always has this in the locker, poor decision making and most importantly making tackles from terrible positions. Maybe he can be a backup left back but as a CB he is far too error prone.


What does he have in the locker 92? Goof blocks? Last ditch goal saving tackles? Im trying to think of what other pens you're thinking of. Players make mistakes, sometimes they just cant get there in time and sometimes the other team players outwith ours. It happens - I cant see we need to get on thr blame game about it.

Poll: Right now, who would you rather have as Prime Minister?

0
Embarrassing decision by the referee there. on 21:15 - Jan 10 with 391 viewsSimonds92

Embarrassing decision by the referee there. on 20:56 - Jan 10 by Vic

What does he have in the locker 92? Goof blocks? Last ditch goal saving tackles? Im trying to think of what other pens you're thinking of. Players make mistakes, sometimes they just cant get there in time and sometimes the other team players outwith ours. It happens - I cant see we need to get on thr blame game about it.


He has plenty of good attributes in the locker, I want to like him, but I just find him so frustrating. I think it's mainly because he looked so impressive in his first few games and he then really fell off. He has a mistake in him fairly regularly caused by his positioning and his body positioning. My fundamental issue I have with him is I've never seen a CB attempt to make a tackle from the wrong side so regularly. He's having to make the last ditch tackles throwing himself at things because he's often the wrong side of the attacker. As a result he's been sent off, given away cheap freekicks or we've conceded really poor goals. Kipre as a comparison does all the fundamentals of defending better so he's not often having to do that. I just don't think we look as in control of games when Greaves plays instead of Kipre. I'd also put Burgess in to that category of being a better fit in our team.
0
Embarrassing decision by the referee there. on 22:07 - Jan 10 with 292 viewsbrazil1982

Penalty all day imo
0
About Us Contact Us Terms & Conditions Privacy Cookies Online Safety Advertising
© TWTD 1995-2026