Please log in or register. Registered visitors get fewer ads.
Forum index | Previous Thread | Next thread
What is the point in VAR if it doesn’t pick things like this up? 07:02 - May 20 with 2193 viewsEly_Blue



If it was a penalty taken a yard from the spot or a goal kick taken from outside of the 6 yard box the officials wouldn’t allow it.

Poll: Will you still buy a Season Ticket for next year in league 1

0
What is the point in VAR if it doesn’t pick things like this up? on 07:26 - May 20 with 1624 viewsFrimleyBlue

Not something the ref will see so not an obvious error.

Whilst I agree with you, if VAR did pick up on that sort of thing teams would be hounding for VAR for various reasons.

My name is Edward Ebineezer Jerimiah Brown, I’m a football supporter of Ipswich Town, wherever they play, you’ll find me. I haven’t missed a game since I was three
Poll: Do you think the squad itself is good enough to stay up
Blog: Marcus Evans Needs Our Support Not to Be Hounded Out

1

What is the point in VAR if it doesn’t pick things like this up? on 07:32 - May 20 with 1601 viewsMarshalls_Mullet

Pedants corner.

Poll: Would Lambert have acheived better results than Cook if given the same resources

2

What is the point in VAR if it doesn’t pick things like this up? on 07:41 - May 20 with 1587 viewsgosblue

What is the point in VAR if it doesn’t pick things like this up? on 07:26 - May 20 by FrimleyBlue

Not something the ref will see so not an obvious error.

Whilst I agree with you, if VAR did pick up on that sort of thing teams would be hounding for VAR for various reasons.


A clear and obvious mistake made by the assistant referee. If the AR’s mistakes don’t count, then the offside rule changes completely. Foul throw-ins are common but rarely penalised.
0
What is the point in VAR if it doesn’t pick things like this up? on 08:47 - May 20 with 1434 viewsC_HealyIsAPleasure

What is the point in VAR if it doesn’t pick things like this up? on 07:41 - May 20 by gosblue

A clear and obvious mistake made by the assistant referee. If the AR’s mistakes don’t count, then the offside rule changes completely. Foul throw-ins are common but rarely penalised.


Jesus H, VAR is one of the worst things in football. You have to be a special kind of saddo to be demanding a goal is ruled out because someone’s foot was over the line on a throw in

Highlighting crass stupidity since sometime around 2010
Poll: Would you want Messi to sign?

0
What is the point in VAR if it doesn’t pick things like this up? on 09:18 - May 20 with 1337 viewsSouperJim

What is the point in VAR if it doesn’t pick things like this up? on 08:47 - May 20 by C_HealyIsAPleasure

Jesus H, VAR is one of the worst things in football. You have to be a special kind of saddo to be demanding a goal is ruled out because someone’s foot was over the line on a throw in


I'd politely suggest if we were on the wrong end of a goal following a throw that blatantly illegal, you might feel different.

Poll: Prawn Crackers
Blog: Broken Ipswich

0
What is the point in VAR if it doesn’t pick things like this up? on 09:44 - May 20 with 1261 viewsellaandred

What is the point in VAR if it doesn’t pick things like this up? on 08:47 - May 20 by C_HealyIsAPleasure

Jesus H, VAR is one of the worst things in football. You have to be a special kind of saddo to be demanding a goal is ruled out because someone’s foot was over the line on a throw in


Let's not bother with any of the laws,then.
The lineman should have noticed that it's his job.
1
What is the point in VAR if it doesn’t pick things like this up? on 09:48 - May 20 with 1242 viewsEly_Blue

What is the point in VAR if it doesn’t pick things like this up? on 08:47 - May 20 by C_HealyIsAPleasure

Jesus H, VAR is one of the worst things in football. You have to be a special kind of saddo to be demanding a goal is ruled out because someone’s foot was over the line on a throw in


Why? Why is it any different to being offside by the same (or smaller) margin?

A corner isn’t allowed to be taken outside of the quadrant, a penalty isn’t given if it’s outside the box. If there was foul play in the build up to the goal it would have been called back, this is no different.

I’d say you are the “special kind of person “
[Post edited 20 May 9:49]

Poll: Will you still buy a Season Ticket for next year in league 1

1
What is the point in VAR if it doesn’t pick things like this up? on 09:55 - May 20 with 1214 viewsMookamoo

That should be the rule for throw ins anyway. As long as one foot is on the line it shouldn't matter where the rest of you is. I would even want under arm throws to speed things up.
0

Login to get fewer ads

What is the point in VAR if it doesn’t pick things like this up? on 09:58 - May 20 with 1202 viewsVaughan8

What is the point in VAR if it doesn’t pick things like this up? on 08:47 - May 20 by C_HealyIsAPleasure

Jesus H, VAR is one of the worst things in football. You have to be a special kind of saddo to be demanding a goal is ruled out because someone’s foot was over the line on a throw in


But someones toenail being offside is OK to call? haha

What level of the rules should we be abiding to.

Surely this is a clear and obvious error, though this doesn't even matter anymore. AFter the Man City handball vs Everton, i'm not sure anyone can rely on VAR!
0
What is the point in VAR if it doesn’t pick things like this up? on 10:00 - May 20 with 1185 viewsellaandred

What is the point in VAR if it doesn’t pick things like this up? on 09:55 - May 20 by Mookamoo

That should be the rule for throw ins anyway. As long as one foot is on the line it shouldn't matter where the rest of you is. I would even want under arm throws to speed things up.


Under arm throw ins were discussed a few (many) years ago.
0
What is the point in VAR if it doesn’t pick things like this up? on 10:05 - May 20 with 1174 viewsSwansea_Blue

If they ran an high voltage electric field around the out of play lines, right up to boll^ck height, you'dd soon see an end to stuff like this.

Poll: Do you think Pert is key to all of this?

0

What is the point in VAR if it doesn’t pick things like this up? on 10:30 - May 20 with 1102 viewsC_HealyIsAPleasure

What is the point in VAR if it doesn’t pick things like this up? on 09:18 - May 20 by SouperJim

I'd politely suggest if we were on the wrong end of a goal following a throw that blatantly illegal, you might feel different.


No, I’d be questioning why we allowed the ball to be lifted into the box so easily and a player drift in unmarked from 30 yards out to easily volley in, rather than whining about a throw in which happened so far before it isn’t even included on the clip in the highlights

Highlighting crass stupidity since sometime around 2010
Poll: Would you want Messi to sign?

-1
What is the point in VAR if it doesn’t pick things like this up? on 10:31 - May 20 with 1094 viewsC_HealyIsAPleasure

What is the point in VAR if it doesn’t pick things like this up? on 09:48 - May 20 by Ely_Blue

Why? Why is it any different to being offside by the same (or smaller) margin?

A corner isn’t allowed to be taken outside of the quadrant, a penalty isn’t given if it’s outside the box. If there was foul play in the build up to the goal it would have been called back, this is no different.

I’d say you are the “special kind of person “
[Post edited 20 May 9:49]


VAR giving offsides by a millimetre is also ridiculous

Have you even seen the goal in question? Absolutely laughable that anyone would think it should have been chalked off because of that

Highlighting crass stupidity since sometime around 2010
Poll: Would you want Messi to sign?

0
What is the point in VAR if it doesn’t pick things like this up? on 10:32 - May 20 with 1090 viewsC_HealyIsAPleasure

What is the point in VAR if it doesn’t pick things like this up? on 09:44 - May 20 by ellaandred

Let's not bother with any of the laws,then.
The lineman should have noticed that it's his job.


The linesman should indeed have noticed but he didn’t, these things happen. Maybe we should get VAR to check goalkeepers have placed the ball absolutely correctly for goal kicks too

Highlighting crass stupidity since sometime around 2010
Poll: Would you want Messi to sign?

0
What is the point in VAR if it doesn’t pick things like this up? on 10:36 - May 20 with 1081 viewsC_HealyIsAPleasure

What is the point in VAR if it doesn’t pick things like this up? on 09:58 - May 20 by Vaughan8

But someones toenail being offside is OK to call? haha

What level of the rules should we be abiding to.

Surely this is a clear and obvious error, though this doesn't even matter anymore. AFter the Man City handball vs Everton, i'm not sure anyone can rely on VAR!


How far back from a goal should VAR check for a clear and obvious error before deciding if it should be disallowed? 30 seconds? A minute? 10?

Alternatively, perhaps we could just leave the referees and linesman to try and apply the laws as best as they can and so be it

Highlighting crass stupidity since sometime around 2010
Poll: Would you want Messi to sign?

1
What is the point in VAR if it doesn’t pick things like this up? on 10:39 - May 20 with 1068 viewsellaandred

What is the point in VAR if it doesn’t pick things like this up? on 10:32 - May 20 by C_HealyIsAPleasure

The linesman should indeed have noticed but he didn’t, these things happen. Maybe we should get VAR to check goalkeepers have placed the ball absolutely correctly for goal kicks too


I never mentioned VAR.
But the ball should be checked that it's placed correctly, otherwise why bother with any of the laws?
0
What is the point in VAR if it doesn’t pick things like this up? on 10:42 - May 20 with 1050 viewsRadlett_blue

What is the point in VAR if it doesn’t pick things like this up? on 10:36 - May 20 by C_HealyIsAPleasure

How far back from a goal should VAR check for a clear and obvious error before deciding if it should be disallowed? 30 seconds? A minute? 10?

Alternatively, perhaps we could just leave the referees and linesman to try and apply the laws as best as they can and so be it


Indeed, at every corner kick there are probably several fouls committed by players on both sides. Do we want VAR to pick all of those out, or do we want the current system whereby referees only ever penalise a foul by an attacker?
0
What is the point in VAR if it doesn’t pick things like this up? on 10:42 - May 20 with 1049 viewsC_HealyIsAPleasure

What is the point in VAR if it doesn’t pick things like this up? on 10:39 - May 20 by ellaandred

I never mentioned VAR.
But the ball should be checked that it's placed correctly, otherwise why bother with any of the laws?


Cool, we’ll delay the game every time there’s a goal kick then so the ref can run over to the six yard box, check the ball is placed correctly and then get back into position in the centre circle. Sounds great 👍🏻

Highlighting crass stupidity since sometime around 2010
Poll: Would you want Messi to sign?

1
What is the point in VAR if it doesn’t pick things like this up? on 10:46 - May 20 with 1029 viewsLankHenners

What is the point in VAR if it doesn’t pick things like this up? on 08:47 - May 20 by C_HealyIsAPleasure

Jesus H, VAR is one of the worst things in football. You have to be a special kind of saddo to be demanding a goal is ruled out because someone’s foot was over the line on a throw in


Yes, VAR should absolutely not be used to check whether there was a marginal foul throw 30 seconds or whatever previous to a goal being scored and it’s utterly mad to think otherwise.

Just because I don't care doesn't mean I don't understand.
Poll: What is Celina's problem?

1
What is the point in VAR if it doesn’t pick things like this up? on 10:58 - May 20 with 1009 viewsellaandred

What is the point in VAR if it doesn’t pick things like this up? on 10:42 - May 20 by C_HealyIsAPleasure

Cool, we’ll delay the game every time there’s a goal kick then so the ref can run over to the six yard box, check the ball is placed correctly and then get back into position in the centre circle. Sounds great 👍🏻


The lineman can do that because he's in that position anyway.
Let's not bother with any laws, then.
0
What is the point in VAR if it doesn’t pick things like this up? on 10:59 - May 20 with 996 viewsC_HealyIsAPleasure

What is the point in VAR if it doesn’t pick things like this up? on 10:58 - May 20 by ellaandred

The lineman can do that because he's in that position anyway.
Let's not bother with any laws, then.


So you mean we should just leave the officials to do these things as best as they can from a distance as they have always done, like I’m suggesting then?

Highlighting crass stupidity since sometime around 2010
Poll: Would you want Messi to sign?

0
What is the point in VAR if it doesn’t pick things like this up? on 11:06 - May 20 with 962 viewsEwan_Oozami

What is the point in VAR if it doesn’t pick things like this up? on 10:59 - May 20 by C_HealyIsAPleasure

So you mean we should just leave the officials to do these things as best as they can from a distance as they have always done, like I’m suggesting then?


"As best they can" is why we have VAR in the first place....

"Cake or death?" "Eh, cake please." "Very well! Give him cake!" Pronouns: h to he
Poll: Does the Forum think little snoozes during the day are acceptable, or not?

0
What is the point in VAR if it doesn’t pick things like this up? on 11:11 - May 20 with 952 viewsC_HealyIsAPleasure

What is the point in VAR if it doesn’t pick things like this up? on 11:06 - May 20 by Ewan_Oozami

"As best they can" is why we have VAR in the first place....


No, money is why we have VAR in the first place

Highlighting crass stupidity since sometime around 2010
Poll: Would you want Messi to sign?

0
What is the point in VAR if it doesn’t pick things like this up? on 11:43 - May 20 with 901 viewsjayessess

VAR is just an official checking footage of the match in real time. If it isn't noticed at the time and it has no direct involvement in the goal, then they aren't going to review it (nor should they).

Blog: What Now? Taking a Look at Life in League One

0

What is the point in VAR if it doesn’t pick things like this up? on 11:49 - May 20 with 867 viewsEly_Blue

What is the point in VAR if it doesn’t pick things like this up? on 11:43 - May 20 by jayessess

VAR is just an official checking footage of the match in real time. If it isn't noticed at the time and it has no direct involvement in the goal, then they aren't going to review it (nor should they).


Ah you mean like the offsides? Yeah VAR checks those in real time doesn’t it. Also the countless was it/wasn’t it handball decisions that get looked at from 10 angles in slo mo for 5 minutes!

If the player gained a clear advantage as he would have done in this case by being able to take the throw in from inside the playing area the yes it does have a direct impact. Not withstanding that effectively it’s a handball offence if we’re going to ignore the fact that his foot is a yard over the line. Let’s allow the same for corners, goal kicks and penalties shall we too?

Poll: Will you still buy a Season Ticket for next year in league 1

0

Please log in or register. Registered visitors get fewer ads.
About Us Contact Us Terms & Conditions Privacy Cookies Advertising
© TWTD 1995-2022