| Phil's report and comments 10:01 - Sep 26 with 7003 views | Dyland |
Can't agree with the fans blaming the ref, he wasn't too bad against one team (relatively).
Morsy booked for a 50/50? Looked like a red to me.
Annoying from Chappers, what a silly place and situation to try and buy a foul. And Edmundsen... Jesus. Frustrating errors/decisions costing us rather than being under the cosh particularly.
Good game though and fair play to the Pilgrim scorers, cracking strikes. We didn't have our shooting boots on. We will come back fine.
Agree with Blooters re subs. Easy to forget how green KmC is though... he'll be learning from all this (presumably).
COYFB |  |
| |  |
| Blimey Phil…. on 13:34 - Sep 26 with 1179 views | SitfcB |
| Blimey Phil…. on 11:03 - Sep 26 by Bloots |
….take off the blue specs and put on the real ones!
I take your point re the first view of the Morsy foul, but on second viewing which VAR would have provided, it was a shocker. He was lucky.
Chaplin couldn’t have been looking for a foul any more if he was holding a placard saying “I’m going to try and make you foul me”. He literally moves away from the direction of the ball and into the Plymouth players path. I’d have booked him for obstruction!
You don’t no nuffink bout football. |
Probably the first thing I’ve ever disagreed with you on, clear foul on Chaplin, doesn’t matter if he was looking for it a foul is a foul, we all know it would be given against us if it was the other way round! |  |
| |
| Phil's report and comments on 13:41 - Sep 26 with 1121 views | Ryorry |
| Phil's report and comments on 13:27 - Sep 26 by FrimleyBlue |
Also didn't help that twice in the game Chaplin had a freekick given against him for backing and ducking into a player. Probably explains again why the ref didn't give a freekick. |
Hadn't realised that, does perhaps help explain it. |  |
| |
| Phil's report and comments on 13:44 - Sep 26 with 1115 views | Ryorry |
| Phil's report and comments on 12:07 - Sep 26 by Dyland |
If anything it's a penalty :) |
If that was a pen, then so were thousands of others that we were not awarded over the last couple of decades! | |
| |
| Phil's report and comments on 13:46 - Sep 26 with 1109 views | ArnieM |
| Phil's report and comments on 10:41 - Sep 26 by PhilTWTD |
I have to say I thought the Morsy booking looked harsh from where I was sitting at the time, just looked like two players colliding as they made a challenge, which I think was how SM saw it from his reaction. I've not actually seen it again and can't find a clip.
Just watched the first goal again and looks a foul on Chaplin to me, is just knocked over as he's getting himself between the player and the ball. Think most refs would have blown up. |
you can put your house on it , had it happened at the other end of the pitch, that ref would have given Plymouth a penalty at the drop of a hat.
Seems odd that only Town players got carded yesterday , and not a single Plymouth player did. The two footed tackle by their left back on Doancian was in my view, a straight red. But we do always seem to get "cheap2 yellow cards in games . Is it poor tackling technique do you think ? |  |
| |
| Blimey Phil…. on 13:47 - Sep 26 with 1104 views | jeera |
| Blimey Phil…. on 13:34 - Sep 26 by SitfcB |
Probably the first thing I’ve ever disagreed with you on, clear foul on Chaplin, doesn’t matter if he was looking for it a foul is a foul, we all know it would be given against us if it was the other way round! |
I thought it a foul at the time and having watched it since still do.
The ball is in the air and he's looking up then around to see where it might drop and trying to position himself.
The Plymouth cheating moron thuggishly slams into the back of him sending him to the ground and robs us of an extra man to defend for their goal.
In my unbiased opinion. |  |
| |
| Phil's report and comments on 13:48 - Sep 26 with 1081 views | Ryorry |
| Phil's report and comments on 13:46 - Sep 26 by ArnieM |
you can put your house on it , had it happened at the other end of the pitch, that ref would have given Plymouth a penalty at the drop of a hat.
Seems odd that only Town players got carded yesterday , and not a single Plymouth player did. The two footed tackle by their left back on Doancian was in my view, a straight red. But we do always seem to get "cheap2 yellow cards in games . Is it poor tackling technique do you think ? |
Hadn't realised that - not a single Plymouth player carded at all? Wow, astonishing. That tackle on Donacien for starters, as you say. | |
| |
| Phil's report and comments on 13:54 - Sep 26 with 1046 views | bungaytractor |
| Phil's report and comments on 13:48 - Sep 26 by Ryorry |
Hadn't realised that - not a single Plymouth player carded at all? Wow, astonishing. That tackle on Donacien for starters, as you say. |
Yep plymouth no cards amd we got 4 so another stat we beat them on lol |  | | |
| Phil's report and comments on 13:57 - Sep 26 with 1028 views | FrimleyBlue |
| Phil's report and comments on 13:48 - Sep 26 by Ryorry |
Hadn't realised that - not a single Plymouth player carded at all? Wow, astonishing. That tackle on Donacien for starters, as you say. |
The ref was strange.
Harness got a yellow for a late ankle nip. Yet davis only 1 minute later got taken out by the sideline in the same manner, we got the freekick but no card.
Same with the challenge on donacien altho strangley the ref looked away as the challenge was made for no logical reason at that point. |  |
| |
Login to get fewer ads
| Phil's report and comments on 14:04 - Sep 26 with 991 views | skinnybob72 |
| Phil's report and comments on 11:10 - Sep 26 by Oatkins |
How many times?
Their equalising goal yesterday was never a foul in a million years. |
Every single game you watch you will see a ball played into the channel, the defender will get himself between the ball and the attacking player, with no intention of playing the ball, slow down to initiate contact and then fall to the ground. The ref awards a free kick every single time. Chaplin did the same and suddenly it’s not a free kick? | | | |
| Phil's report and comments on 14:06 - Sep 26 with 969 views | Ryorry |
| Phil's report and comments on 13:57 - Sep 26 by FrimleyBlue |
The ref was strange.
Harness got a yellow for a late ankle nip. Yet davis only 1 minute later got taken out by the sideline in the same manner, we got the freekick but no card.
Same with the challenge on donacien altho strangley the ref looked away as the challenge was made for no logical reason at that point. |
Sorry to say that sometimes you really do have to wonder about the impartiality and/or mental robustness of refs. | |
| |
| Up yours.... on 14:07 - Sep 26 with 968 views | Bloots |
| Blimey Phil…. on 13:34 - Sep 26 by SitfcB |
Probably the first thing I’ve ever disagreed with you on, clear foul on Chaplin, doesn’t matter if he was looking for it a foul is a foul, we all know it would be given against us if it was the other way round! |
....fair enough.
You're wrong though.
But fair enough.
Idiot.
Entitled to your opinion though.
Balls. |  |
| "The sooner he comes back the better, this place has been a disaster without him" - TWTD User (July 2025) |
| |
| Phil's report and comments on 14:08 - Sep 26 with 951 views | FrimleyBlue |
| Phil's report and comments on 14:06 - Sep 26 by Ryorry |
Sorry to say that sometimes you really do have to wonder about the impartiality and/or mental robustness of refs. |
He was a strange ref. And one I'm not sure if you can say he was good or bad. Just weird. | |
| |
| Phil's report and comments on 14:10 - Sep 26 with 945 views | hype313 |
| Phil's report and comments on 13:54 - Sep 26 by bungaytractor |
Yep plymouth no cards amd we got 4 so another stat we beat them on lol |
The Referee was abysmal. |  |
| |
| Phil's report and comments on 14:24 - Sep 26 with 903 views | Garv |
| Phil's report and comments on 13:16 - Sep 26 by PhilTWTD |
Of course they're not. It's part of the game to put yourself in a position where the opponent fouls you because it's difficult for them to get to the ball.
This post has been edited by an administrator |
So deliberately get in the way of someone running towards the ball and wait for them to knock you over (or simply fall over)?
Fair enough if you see the game like that. |  |
| |
| Phil's report and comments on 14:30 - Sep 26 with 880 views | bungaytractor |
| Phil's report and comments on 14:10 - Sep 26 by hype313 |
The Referee was abysmal. |
Was only listening so couldnt see but sounded like that .... mate of mine said if no prem games why couldnt we use there refs as all refs in this league seem crap part timers | | | |
| Phil's report and comments on 14:33 - Sep 26 with 877 views | Ryorry |
| Phil's report and comments on 14:24 - Sep 26 by Garv |
So deliberately get in the way of someone running towards the ball and wait for them to knock you over (or simply fall over)?
Fair enough if you see the game like that. |
No. Standard legitimate block, get deliberately knocked over by opponent, normally a foul would be given & you'd get a free kick. On any part of the pitch. | |
| |
| Phil's report and comments on 14:45 - Sep 26 with 847 views | Blue_In_Boston |
| Phil's report and comments on 10:47 - Sep 26 by bluefunk |
While Chaplin should have made more attempt for the ball, imagine if the incident was our defender ploughing through their player, that would have been a stonewall penalty, so how it wasn’t given I will never know |
Chaplin has no eyes on the ball at all, he's more interested in watching their player and trying to 'win' a foul. Why leave the ref a decision to make, just clear it. My first instinct was that it was a foul, and at the other end I would be screaming penalty... in the cold light of day, and having seen the replays, I think the ref got it right. | | | |
| Phil's report and comments on 14:58 - Sep 26 with 820 views | jayessess |
| Phil's report and comments on 14:45 - Sep 26 by Blue_In_Boston |
Chaplin has no eyes on the ball at all, he's more interested in watching their player and trying to 'win' a foul. Why leave the ref a decision to make, just clear it. My first instinct was that it was a foul, and at the other end I would be screaming penalty... in the cold light of day, and having seen the replays, I think the ref got it right. |
Not sure how he's supposed to just clear it, by the time the ball drops as low as head height he's already been bundled over and the opposition player is lying on top of him. |  |
| |
| Phil's report and comments on 15:18 - Sep 26 with 769 views | Wickets |
| Phil's report and comments on 10:41 - Sep 26 by PhilTWTD |
I have to say I thought the Morsy booking looked harsh from where I was sitting at the time, just looked like two players colliding as they made a challenge, which I think was how SM saw it from his reaction. I've not actually seen it again and can't find a clip.
Just watched the first goal again and looks a foul on Chaplin to me, is just knocked over as he's getting himself between the player and the ball. Think most refs would have blown up. |
I agree many Ref's would have seen Chaplin's effort to buy a foul as a foul but dont think we have much to complain about as he didn't , i'm not sure why he did not just put his foot through the ball and clear it . I love the fact that at last we have a bit of steel in our midfield now as it has been missing for a while but Sam's tackle was lucky not to be deemed a red miles from the ball and straight into his opponents thigh . The one on Donacian by the Norwich loanee was not much better and was not even seen as a yellow apart from that i thought the Ref did well . |  | | |
| Phil's report and comments on 15:24 - Sep 26 with 752 views | jayessess |
| Phil's report and comments on 15:18 - Sep 26 by Wickets |
I agree many Ref's would have seen Chaplin's effort to buy a foul as a foul but dont think we have much to complain about as he didn't , i'm not sure why he did not just put his foot through the ball and clear it . I love the fact that at last we have a bit of steel in our midfield now as it has been missing for a while but Sam's tackle was lucky not to be deemed a red miles from the ball and straight into his opponents thigh . The one on Donacian by the Norwich loanee was not much better and was not even seen as a yellow apart from that i thought the Ref did well . |
Look where the ball is when the collision happens, "just clear it" wasn't much of an option
 | |
| |
| Phil's report and comments on 15:25 - Sep 26 with 732 views | FrimleyBlue |
| Phil's report and comments on 15:24 - Sep 26 by jayessess |
Look where the ball is when the collision happens, "just clear it" wasn't much of an option
|
You've ignored the part where he could have jumped for the ball tho rather than let it drop whilst backing into the player | |
| |
| Phil's report and comments on 15:29 - Sep 26 with 709 views | jayessess |
| Phil's report and comments on 15:25 - Sep 26 by FrimleyBlue |
You've ignored the part where he could have jumped for the ball tho rather than let it drop whilst backing into the player |
How's he supposed to start his jump when the ball is 20 foot in the air?! | |
| |
| Phil's report and comments on 15:31 - Sep 26 with 694 views | PhilTWTD |
| Phil's report and comments on 15:25 - Sep 26 by FrimleyBlue |
You've ignored the part where he could have jumped for the ball tho rather than let it drop whilst backing into the player |
The ball is up by the advertising hoarding if you can't see it. He's not Jet Set Willy (reference for the kids). Nothing wrong with physically putting yourself in front of someone as a ball is dropping. |  | | |
| Phil's report and comments on 15:31 - Sep 26 with 692 views | jeera |
| Phil's report and comments on 15:24 - Sep 26 by jayessess |
Look where the ball is when the collision happens, "just clear it" wasn't much of an option
|
You'd never locate that fecker on Spot The Ball would you. | |
| |
| Phil's report and comments on 15:35 - Sep 26 with 687 views | FrimleyBlue |
| Phil's report and comments on 15:29 - Sep 26 by jayessess |
How's he supposed to start his jump when the ball is 20 foot in the air?! |
Well had he not looked for the player and bent down looking for the freekick he could have jumped for the ball as it came down. | |
| |
| |
By continuing to use the site, you agree to our use of cookies and to abide by our Terms and Conditions.
