| Question on the penalty 21:22 - Apr 11 with 3105 views | Illinoisblue |
How was it described on Sky? The (English) commentator on the CBS coverage here didn’t even realize it was a penalty. Watching a scum vlog filmed from the other end, and the ref is trotting away from the incident when he suddenly stops and goes back to the scene of the crime. Did he get a nod or notification from the linesman? I’d have been foomin at a pen given us against us in that way. As it is, can’t stop laughing 😃😃😃 |  |
| |  |
| Question on the penalty on 21:26 - Apr 11 with 2647 views | RonFearonsHair |
They would have been chatting through the mic/earpiece they wear. To be fair, it's a much better system than having the lino flag and the ref having to stop the game to chat to him. |  | | |
| Question on the penalty on 21:27 - Apr 11 with 2620 views | J2BLUE |
Yep lino's call.
I don't think it would have been overturned with VAR. Soft but probably a pen. Taylor's head seemed to jolt so not sure if he was caught in the face. Didn't look like it but that made me wonder. |  |
| "These middle class, perma-offended, virtue-signalling woke w@nkers have declared that the great unwashed are just one tasteless joke away from turning into fascists" - Jonathan Pie |
| |
| Question on the penalty on 21:27 - Apr 11 with 2607 views | Nthsuffolkblue |
On Sky it took a while for them to realise. I saw the ref point at the spot and whistle and said "he's given a penalty" a while before the commentators appeared to realise it. |  |
| |
| Question on the penalty on 21:28 - Apr 11 with 2597 views | DarkBrandon |
The Lino didn’t flag (it was flag across the chest in my day) but apparently told the ref via his earpiece to give it.
The co-commentator thought it definitely shouldn’t have been given. |  | | |
| Question on the penalty on 21:31 - Apr 11 with 2560 views | Vaughan8 |
Obviously Andy Hinchcliffe was saying it's not a penalty.
It's really soft, and quite frankly I don't like those penalties being given, but its the rules, and they're given so its tough luck.
After all the crying about officials recently, we got away with at least 2 decisions today. I thought the ref was cr@p and inconsistent but it won't get mentioned cos we won! |  | | |
| Question on the penalty on 21:33 - Apr 11 with 2522 views | Nthsuffolkblue |
If you listen to Brenner on Radio Suffolk (thread below), he took a while to realise too. I think the Norfolk commentary got there quicker. | |
| |
| Question on the penalty on 21:34 - Apr 11 with 2513 views | Cheltenham_Blue |
| Question on the penalty on 21:26 - Apr 11 by RonFearonsHair |
They would have been chatting through the mic/earpiece they wear. To be fair, it's a much better system than having the lino flag and the ref having to stop the game to chat to him. |
Really? Not sure about that.
At least if the Lino starts waving their flag in the air like they just don't care and then the ref goes over to have a chat with him, or they put the flag across their chest, you've got a bloody good idea of what is going on.
As this happened, I didn't know what had happened, and even the sky commentators took a little while to realise it was a pen, there was very little clarity in the way it happened. |  |
| |
| Question on the penalty on 21:38 - Apr 11 with 2454 views | NthQldITFC |
| Question on the penalty on 21:34 - Apr 11 by Cheltenham_Blue |
Really? Not sure about that.
At least if the Lino starts waving their flag in the air like they just don't care and then the ref goes over to have a chat with him, or they put the flag across their chest, you've got a bloody good idea of what is going on.
As this happened, I didn't know what had happened, and even the sky commentators took a little while to realise it was a pen, there was very little clarity in the way it happened. |
Word
(up) |  |
| |
Login to get fewer ads
| Question on the penalty on 21:42 - Apr 11 with 2390 views | Nthsuffolkblue |
| Question on the penalty on 21:34 - Apr 11 by Cheltenham_Blue |
Really? Not sure about that.
At least if the Lino starts waving their flag in the air like they just don't care and then the ref goes over to have a chat with him, or they put the flag across their chest, you've got a bloody good idea of what is going on.
As this happened, I didn't know what had happened, and even the sky commentators took a little while to realise it was a pen, there was very little clarity in the way it happened. |
Watching the footage at the time, it felt to me like the ref took a long look and weighed it up in his mind before giving it. He clearly blew and pointed at the spot (but from some distance away and the ball was near our area by then). I immediately said "He has given a penalty" because it was clearly signalled but commentators generally don't appear to have seen that. Listening on the Radio Norfolk commentary linked with Brenner's the co-commentator is clearly in the background repeatedly saying "he's given a penalty." | |
| |
| Question on the penalty on 21:43 - Apr 11 with 2390 views | TRUE_BLUE123 |
I thought it was a pretty clear pen. |  |
| |
| Question on the penalty on 21:46 - Apr 11 with 2323 views | SheffordBlue |
| Question on the penalty on 21:43 - Apr 11 by TRUE_BLUE123 |
I thought it was a pretty clear pen. |
Darren Huckerby agrees with you!
| |
| |
| Question on the penalty on 21:47 - Apr 11 with 2296 views | NthQldITFC |
| Question on the penalty on 21:46 - Apr 11 by SheffordBlue |
Darren Huckerby agrees with you!
|
Unusual for him not to be talking out of his hat. | |
| |
| Question on the penalty on 21:58 - Apr 11 with 2177 views | TRUE_BLUE123 |
| Question on the penalty on 21:46 - Apr 11 by SheffordBlue |
Darren Huckerby agrees with you!
|
unpleasant company.
No but seriously, Taylor nicked the ball and the Norwich player kicked through him. | |
| |
| Question on the penalty on 22:18 - Apr 11 with 2022 views | Joey_Joe_Joe_Junior |
CBS buys the rights it’d just an EFL world feed and pretty sure they’re always in a studio so he’s just seeing what we see. |  |
| |
| Question on the penalty on 22:33 - Apr 11 with 1884 views | Illinoisblue |
| Question on the penalty on 22:18 - Apr 11 by Joey_Joe_Joe_Junior |
CBS buys the rights it’d just an EFL world feed and pretty sure they’re always in a studio so he’s just seeing what we see. |
I know that but he was utterly baffled and had no clue what was going on… altho sounds like Sky were equally mystified.
New rule for football: games where commentators aren’t at the game should be marked as such on the broadcast. I mean it’s pretty easy to figure out but still annoying as fk. | |
| |
| Question on the penalty on 22:36 - Apr 11 with 1854 views | Swansea_Blue |
| Question on the penalty on 21:31 - Apr 11 by Vaughan8 |
Obviously Andy Hinchcliffe was saying it's not a penalty.
It's really soft, and quite frankly I don't like those penalties being given, but its the rules, and they're given so its tough luck.
After all the crying about officials recently, we got away with at least 2 decisions today. I thought the ref was cr@p and inconsistent but it won't get mentioned cos we won! |
Hinchcliffe was talking rubbish all game. Like when he reckoned Leif should have had a go with a free kick so far out that Roberto Carlos would have struggled. |  |
| |
| Question on the penalty on 22:43 - Apr 11 with 1785 views | NBVJohn |
| Question on the penalty on 22:36 - Apr 11 by Swansea_Blue |
Hinchcliffe was talking rubbish all game. Like when he reckoned Leif should have had a go with a free kick so far out that Roberto Carlos would have struggled. |
Hinchcliffe talks rubbish all game, every game he’s involved in.
The man is an absolute bore. Sucks the life out of games with his constant drone about defensive discipline.
Unless it’s Bannon, Barry Bannon on the pitch and then he’s gushing in his praise. Odd. | | | |
| Question on the penalty on 22:50 - Apr 11 with 1739 views | Joey_Joe_Joe_Junior |
| Question on the penalty on 22:33 - Apr 11 by Illinoisblue |
I know that but he was utterly baffled and had no clue what was going on… altho sounds like Sky were equally mystified.
New rule for football: games where commentators aren’t at the game should be marked as such on the broadcast. I mean it’s pretty easy to figure out but still annoying as fk. |
That’s the issue studio commentators!
Watching it back I’ve got it in a similar bracket to the one that Stoke got awarded. Soft and would be annoyed if it went against you but can see why the officials gave it. Once he nicked the ball and the defender was committed, there is always a danger. Not too dissimilar from the one Kane got against the Dutch.
Not sure if that gets overturned or not really with VAR, think they might stay with the call (if there was indeed any contact at all). Definitely a case of Jack Taylor winning that for us, if there was an award like there used to be in under 13s football, he’s got the most improved player sewn up. Have been critical of him at times but a super solid season. [Post edited 11 Apr 22:55]
| |
| |
| Question on the penalty on 23:03 - Apr 11 with 1637 views | Blue_Moses |
| Question on the penalty on 22:43 - Apr 11 by NBVJohn |
Hinchcliffe talks rubbish all game, every game he’s involved in.
The man is an absolute bore. Sucks the life out of games with his constant drone about defensive discipline.
Unless it’s Bannon, Barry Bannon on the pitch and then he’s gushing in his praise. Odd. |
Barry Bannon | | | |
| Question on the penalty on 00:53 - Apr 12 with 1304 views | SitfcB |
| Question on the penalty on 21:34 - Apr 11 by Cheltenham_Blue |
Really? Not sure about that.
At least if the Lino starts waving their flag in the air like they just don't care and then the ref goes over to have a chat with him, or they put the flag across their chest, you've got a bloody good idea of what is going on.
As this happened, I didn't know what had happened, and even the sky commentators took a little while to realise it was a pen, there was very little clarity in the way it happened. |
Don’t think Lino’s do that anymore for a penalty. Ref held his ear when awarding it. Norwich broke for the counter and were away until ref brought it back. |  |
| |
| Question on the penalty on 01:08 - Apr 12 with 1262 views | Joey_Joe_Joe_Junior |
| Question on the penalty on 00:53 - Apr 12 by SitfcB |
Don’t think Lino’s do that anymore for a penalty. Ref held his ear when awarding it. Norwich broke for the counter and were away until ref brought it back. |
The was the other quite funny part of that, they had a really good break on with numbers lol | |
| |
| Question on the penalty on 02:11 - Apr 12 with 1169 views | Illinoisblue |
| Question on the penalty on 01:08 - Apr 12 by Joey_Joe_Joe_Junior |
The was the other quite funny part of that, they had a really good break on with numbers lol |
Feels like we could look back on that as a sliding doors moment. | |
| |
| Question on the penalty on 07:47 - Apr 12 with 892 views | Freddy |
Sky said it wasnt a penalty, they also thought ref was poor | | | |
| Question on the penalty on 07:52 - Apr 12 with 869 views | Benters |
| Question on the penalty on 07:47 - Apr 12 by Freddy |
Sky said it wasnt a penalty, they also thought ref was poor |
It was definitely one of those if it had been given against Towen we would have been fuming.
But there you go  |  |
| |
| Question on the penalty on 07:55 - Apr 12 with 846 views | breezy_runner |
I can't believe there is any debate on this one. Its a stone wall penalty. The guy foot was so high and could be deemed as dangerous play. The only debate should be why it took the linesman to give it and not the ref straight away | | | |
| |
By continuing to use the site, you agree to our use of cookies and to abide by our Terms and Conditions.
