| Celina or Twine......with the following conditions 14:08 - Jun 14 with 7584 views | itfcjoe |
Celina - one year loan, total cost - approx £800k to £1m. No resale at end obviously.
Twine - £4m transfer fee, 4 year contract on £15k a week, total investment ~£7m, with potential resale if he does well.
What would you go with, personally I'd normally go for the permanent transfer - but feel as though any investment we'd have to make in Twine (if we could get him) would be so large and risky
I'd edge towards the safer choice of Celina and spend elsewhere |  |
| |  |
| Celina or Twine......with the following conditions on 18:12 - Jun 14 with 1661 views | wkj |
| Celina or Twine......with the following conditions on 18:09 - Jun 14 by chicoazul |
Is there really anything in this Twine business lads |
People are just stringing us along, I'm afraid. |  |
| |
| Celina or Twine......with the following conditions on 18:15 - Jun 14 with 1653 views | Cheltenham_Blue |
| Celina or Twine......with the following conditions on 14:12 - Jun 14 by hype313 |
Twine all day long, higher ceiling and has improved year on year and is consistently good.
Love Celina, but Twine would be the better buy. |
Improved year on year, but this is Ipswich.
Until we are certain the banter era is over, chances are, he'd suffer a career ending injury in the bleep test. |  |
| |
| Celina or Twine......with the following conditions on 18:56 - Jun 14 with 1587 views | Vic |
Are you teasing us a little here Joe? Come one, what do you know? |  |
| |
| Celina or Twine......with the following conditions on 19:06 - Jun 14 with 1574 views | Parky |
Celina every day of the week, whilst in League One.
No League One team should be spending anywhere near £4m on one player. Stinks of something Derby would do if they weren’t in a mess. |  | | |
| Celina or Twine......with the following conditions on 19:35 - Jun 14 with 1525 views | TomTheWriter |
I'd go with Elliot Anderson on a season-long loan from Newcastle. Already wanted by Championship sides some guaranteed football goes in our favour
I'd go with Phoenix Patterson for a nominal fee from Waterford. 16 goal contributions from 16 games. 20-years-old where a 'Twine' like season turns a huge profit.
I'd go with Morgan Rogers for a snip from Man City. 19-years-old. V.impressive for Lincoln 2 seasons back, and attainable after limited game with Bournemouth. Again, another that is a low fee with a huge re-sale value if successful.
If you're willing to spend 'Celina' money, I'd go with Fashion Sakala from Rangers. We've an impressive history with Rangers players in the last few years. They are only going in one direction, and they will spend and spend to out-do Celtic. Guaranteed goals from limited starts.
Twine is out of reach for all but 25 sides in England. I love Celina, and if the choice was Celina loan or Celina permanent, I too would vote for Celina on loan once again. But Celina on loan isn't as appealing as Anderson on loan.
He's too inconsistent. He lights up Portman Road and then disappears at Accrington. He'll score the Goal of the Season one week and then lose the ball a dozen times the next.
If it was me, it would be:
1. Anderson Loan
2. Patterson Perm
3. Celina Loan
4. Rogers Perm
5. Sakala Perm
6. Celina Perm
7. Twine Perm |  |
| |
| Celina or Twine......with the following conditions on 19:45 - Jun 14 with 1502 views | itfcjoe |
| Celina or Twine......with the following conditions on 19:35 - Jun 14 by TomTheWriter |
I'd go with Elliot Anderson on a season-long loan from Newcastle. Already wanted by Championship sides some guaranteed football goes in our favour
I'd go with Phoenix Patterson for a nominal fee from Waterford. 16 goal contributions from 16 games. 20-years-old where a 'Twine' like season turns a huge profit.
I'd go with Morgan Rogers for a snip from Man City. 19-years-old. V.impressive for Lincoln 2 seasons back, and attainable after limited game with Bournemouth. Again, another that is a low fee with a huge re-sale value if successful.
If you're willing to spend 'Celina' money, I'd go with Fashion Sakala from Rangers. We've an impressive history with Rangers players in the last few years. They are only going in one direction, and they will spend and spend to out-do Celtic. Guaranteed goals from limited starts.
Twine is out of reach for all but 25 sides in England. I love Celina, and if the choice was Celina loan or Celina permanent, I too would vote for Celina on loan once again. But Celina on loan isn't as appealing as Anderson on loan.
He's too inconsistent. He lights up Portman Road and then disappears at Accrington. He'll score the Goal of the Season one week and then lose the ball a dozen times the next.
If it was me, it would be:
1. Anderson Loan
2. Patterson Perm
3. Celina Loan
4. Rogers Perm
5. Sakala Perm
6. Celina Perm
7. Twine Perm |
There's no way I'd be going for someone from the Irish League ahead of him, Patterson wasn't close to cutting it in England - if he comes across he'll be a project not a starter. | |
| |
| Celina or Twine......with the following conditions on 20:06 - Jun 14 with 1468 views | TomTheWriter |
| Celina or Twine......with the following conditions on 19:45 - Jun 14 by itfcjoe |
There's no way I'd be going for someone from the Irish League ahead of him, Patterson wasn't close to cutting it in England - if he comes across he'll be a project not a starter. |
That’s why I want both of the first two I mentioned. Have them in my ‘ideal’ squad list for the season. Anderson is a star talent, and Patterson as you say is a project with a high ceiling.
The attacking midfield position should not be tied up in big fees/big wages. Striker is where the money needs to go, with 80% of teams proving you don’t need money to win games, just heart/fight/desire. | |
| |
| Celina or Twine......with the following conditions on 20:07 - Jun 14 with 1466 views | Parky |
| Celina or Twine......with the following conditions on 19:35 - Jun 14 by TomTheWriter |
I'd go with Elliot Anderson on a season-long loan from Newcastle. Already wanted by Championship sides some guaranteed football goes in our favour
I'd go with Phoenix Patterson for a nominal fee from Waterford. 16 goal contributions from 16 games. 20-years-old where a 'Twine' like season turns a huge profit.
I'd go with Morgan Rogers for a snip from Man City. 19-years-old. V.impressive for Lincoln 2 seasons back, and attainable after limited game with Bournemouth. Again, another that is a low fee with a huge re-sale value if successful.
If you're willing to spend 'Celina' money, I'd go with Fashion Sakala from Rangers. We've an impressive history with Rangers players in the last few years. They are only going in one direction, and they will spend and spend to out-do Celtic. Guaranteed goals from limited starts.
Twine is out of reach for all but 25 sides in England. I love Celina, and if the choice was Celina loan or Celina permanent, I too would vote for Celina on loan once again. But Celina on loan isn't as appealing as Anderson on loan.
He's too inconsistent. He lights up Portman Road and then disappears at Accrington. He'll score the Goal of the Season one week and then lose the ball a dozen times the next.
If it was me, it would be:
1. Anderson Loan
2. Patterson Perm
3. Celina Loan
4. Rogers Perm
5. Sakala Perm
6. Celina Perm
7. Twine Perm |
Fashion Sakala isn’t going to leave Rangers for League One. Played 30 times for them season, they only signed him last summer.
Edit - 30 times is only league games. [Post edited 14 Jun 2022 20:08]
| | | |
Login to get fewer ads
| Celina or Twine......with the following conditions on 20:25 - Jun 14 with 1426 views | TomTheWriter |
| Celina or Twine......with the following conditions on 20:07 - Jun 14 by Parky |
Fashion Sakala isn’t going to leave Rangers for League One. Played 30 times for them season, they only signed him last summer.
Edit - 30 times is only league games. [Post edited 14 Jun 2022 20:08]
|
Only 13 league starts for Sakala, and we know they are going to want to improve to take the title from Celtic. This is the way the top teams act. City sell world class players every season because they go out and buy better (Haaland for Jesus).
He’s a ‘push the boat’ option for a reason. But if you want guaranteed goals that’s the man you go for. 9 goals in 13 starts | |
| |
| Celina or Twine......with the following conditions on 20:35 - Jun 14 with 1416 views | TRUE_BLUE123 |
| Celina or Twine......with the following conditions on 14:42 - Jun 14 by textbackup |
I just don’t see celina and league 1 being a great fit.
The flashes of brilliance, imo, are few and far between. Twine offers a dead ball quality we don’t currently have too.
Twine for me |
Thats not right regarding Celina.
Him and league one is a good fit, he was brilliant last season, if we had a striker who could finish, his numbers would've been even better. |  |
| |
| Celina or Twine......with the following conditions on 22:22 - Jun 14 with 1341 views | Veggie |
Twine. Realistically the total cost would be nearer £4m. Peanuts if he gets us promoted (twice).
Edit: I know it’s not going to happen. [Post edited 14 Jun 2022 22:23]
|  | | |
| Celina or Twine......with the following conditions on 11:31 - Jun 15 with 1159 views | itfcsuth |
I'm surprised Anthony Scully isn't a name mentioned more for the inside left forward role.
Had another good season in a struggling Lincoln side. 11 goals and 7 assists in the League last time out.
One year left on his contract with the Imps. |  | | |
| Celina or Twine......with the following conditions on 11:47 - Jun 15 with 1126 views | NthQldITFC |
| Celina or Twine......with the following conditions on 11:31 - Jun 15 by itfcsuth |
I'm surprised Anthony Scully isn't a name mentioned more for the inside left forward role.
Had another good season in a struggling Lincoln side. 11 goals and 7 assists in the League last time out.
One year left on his contract with the Imps. |
It's all over the front page... |  |
| |
| Celina or Twine......with the following conditions on 12:12 - Jun 15 with 1101 views | itfcsuth |
| Celina or Twine......with the following conditions on 11:47 - Jun 15 by NthQldITFC |
It's all over the front page... |
Eh? | | | |
| Celina or Twine......with the following conditions on 12:16 - Jun 15 with 1091 views | tractorboy1978 |
| Celina or Twine......with the following conditions on 19:35 - Jun 14 by TomTheWriter |
I'd go with Elliot Anderson on a season-long loan from Newcastle. Already wanted by Championship sides some guaranteed football goes in our favour
I'd go with Phoenix Patterson for a nominal fee from Waterford. 16 goal contributions from 16 games. 20-years-old where a 'Twine' like season turns a huge profit.
I'd go with Morgan Rogers for a snip from Man City. 19-years-old. V.impressive for Lincoln 2 seasons back, and attainable after limited game with Bournemouth. Again, another that is a low fee with a huge re-sale value if successful.
If you're willing to spend 'Celina' money, I'd go with Fashion Sakala from Rangers. We've an impressive history with Rangers players in the last few years. They are only going in one direction, and they will spend and spend to out-do Celtic. Guaranteed goals from limited starts.
Twine is out of reach for all but 25 sides in England. I love Celina, and if the choice was Celina loan or Celina permanent, I too would vote for Celina on loan once again. But Celina on loan isn't as appealing as Anderson on loan.
He's too inconsistent. He lights up Portman Road and then disappears at Accrington. He'll score the Goal of the Season one week and then lose the ball a dozen times the next.
If it was me, it would be:
1. Anderson Loan
2. Patterson Perm
3. Celina Loan
4. Rogers Perm
5. Sakala Perm
6. Celina Perm
7. Twine Perm |
On what basis would Rogers be a low fee? The pre agreed buy option at the end of his Bournemouth loan was £9m. He didn’t enhance his reputation last season but he’s not going to suddenly be leaving for a pittance with two years left on his deal. | | | |
| Celina or Twine......with the following conditions on 12:25 - Jun 15 with 1073 views | itfcsuth |
| Celina or Twine......with the following conditions on 12:16 - Jun 15 by tractorboy1978 |
On what basis would Rogers be a low fee? The pre agreed buy option at the end of his Bournemouth loan was £9m. He didn’t enhance his reputation last season but he’s not going to suddenly be leaving for a pittance with two years left on his deal. |
Agree, would be an expensive one still. Even a mid Championship side like a West Brom would pay £2-£3m for him.
We'd only attract him on a loan. Good player though mind you. [Post edited 15 Jun 2022 12:26]
| | | |
| Celina or Twine......with the following conditions on 12:54 - Jun 15 with 1028 views | Kieran_Knows |
| Celina or Twine......with the following conditions on 12:25 - Jun 15 by itfcsuth |
Agree, would be an expensive one still. Even a mid Championship side like a West Brom would pay £2-£3m for him.
We'd only attract him on a loan. Good player though mind you. [Post edited 15 Jun 2022 12:26]
|
We tried for him at the very last knockings of the January transfer window when it was becoming apparent he was going to be sent back to City, but we couldn't get a deal sorted. |  |
| |
| Celina or Twine......with the following conditions on 13:27 - Jun 15 with 963 views | NthQldITFC |
| Celina or Twine......with the following conditions on 12:12 - Jun 15 by itfcsuth |
Eh? |
Sorry, 90s musical reference; I often just blurt out things that come into my head irl too!
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Road_Rage_(song)
I love this quote 'Ian Hyland gave "Road Rage" a rating of nine out of ten in his review for the Sunday Mirror. He said that if "Matthews sounded any more Welsh she'd be a dragon but this is a very excellent tune in any language."' isn't it? [Post edited 15 Jun 2022 13:32]
| |
| |
| |
By continuing to use the site, you agree to our use of cookies and to abide by our Terms and Conditions.
