| Ashton's shortlist 20:46 - May 24 with 2207 views | itfc_bucks |
Let's say United or Spurs ditch their managers this summer and go for the left field appointment - they bring in McKenna. Or he decides to leave to do cat yoga, or whatever.
We have a managerial vacancy.
Who is on Ashton's shortlist, do we think? |  | | |  |
| Ashton's shortlist on 20:48 - May 24 with 2182 views | nrb1985 |
Has to be Rohl #1 surely. | | | |
| Ashton's shortlist on 20:53 - May 24 with 2120 views | WestSussexBlue |
Similar appointment I would say.
A young up and coming coach at a well established Premier League club, looking for his own step up to a managerial role. Ashton I’m sure, already has 4-5 that he’s keeping tabs on. | | | |
| Ashton's shortlist on 20:54 - May 24 with 2111 views | Nutkins_Return |
| Ashton's shortlist on 20:48 - May 24 by nrb1985 |
Has to be Rohl #1 surely. |
Agree but think he will be gone by then. I would be very happy with Rosenior personally. Very much in the McKenna mould and talks so well in interviews and always seems to have the full respect and love of players. Also he knows some of squad well and knows the club and I always get the impression has a bit of affinity there (Him and McKenna were on good terms and he wavery respectful to us in interviews). Obviously as well a good manager. He seems to be progressing year on year and done an excellent job in France (which will help with our future European adventures ;)) | |
| |
| Ashton's shortlist on 21:02 - May 24 with 2048 views | Perublue |
| Ashton's shortlist on 20:54 - May 24 by Nutkins_Return |
Agree but think he will be gone by then. I would be very happy with Rosenior personally. Very much in the McKenna mould and talks so well in interviews and always seems to have the full respect and love of players. Also he knows some of squad well and knows the club and I always get the impression has a bit of affinity there (Him and McKenna were on good terms and he wavery respectful to us in interviews). Obviously as well a good manager. He seems to be progressing year on year and done an excellent job in France (which will help with our future European adventures ;)) |
First person I thought of … as I did when kmac looked like going before.
I could imagine kmac going to spurs shortly you know I really could. |  |
| |
| Ashton's shortlist on 21:46 - May 24 with 1825 views | Marshalls_Mullet |
| Ashton's shortlist on 20:53 - May 24 by WestSussexBlue |
Similar appointment I would say.
A young up and coming coach at a well established Premier League club, looking for his own step up to a managerial role. Ashton I’m sure, already has 4-5 that he’s keeping tabs on. |
Quite a high failure rate of those type of appointments.
Was arguably easier to do in L1 with the leagues biggest budget and time. |  |
| |
| Ashton's shortlist on 21:49 - May 24 with 1795 views | DarkBrandon |
| Ashton's shortlist on 21:46 - May 24 by Marshalls_Mullet |
Quite a high failure rate of those type of appointments.
Was arguably easier to do in L1 with the leagues biggest budget and time. |
This is a very good point.
McKenna had half a season to get everything in order (although he improved us immediately).
His replacement would have to hit the ground running. Their advantage would be the excellent squad he’d take over. |  | | |
| Ashton's shortlist on 22:10 - May 24 with 1721 views | Keno |
Cole Skuse with Chambers as assistant
Or Aluko |  |
| |
| Ashton's shortlist on 22:12 - May 24 with 1717 views | bournemouthblue |
No clue if we would go for a name and I appreciate he might have higher aims but Ashton has worked with Dyche before
Not that he really fits the style McKenna has been trying to impart, we could do worse |  |
| |
Login to get fewer ads
| Ashton's shortlist on 22:13 - May 24 with 1710 views | WD19 |
His preferred first choice would probably be himself.
He could put his name on another board in reception. |  | | |
| Ashton's shortlist on 22:31 - May 24 with 1609 views | Bigalhunter |
| Ashton's shortlist on 21:02 - May 24 by Perublue |
First person I thought of … as I did when kmac looked like going before.
I could imagine kmac going to spurs shortly you know I really could. |
I was going to point out that managing a team in the Champions League would be a hell of a reward for the pitiful run of results he’s presided over in 2025, then I remembered Vincent Kompany…
With their over-inflated sense of self worth, I don’t think Spurs fans would see KM as a high profile appointment worthy of their status.
Even Teflon Levy wouldn’t risk that. [Post edited 24 May 23:28]
|  |
| |
| Ashton's shortlist on 22:51 - May 24 with 1508 views | Bigalhunter |
| Ashton's shortlist on 22:12 - May 24 by bournemouthblue |
No clue if we would go for a name and I appreciate he might have higher aims but Ashton has worked with Dyche before
Not that he really fits the style McKenna has been trying to impart, we could do worse |
Dyche would be a hideous option and totally at odds with what KM has created in terms of ethos and approach to playing attractive football.
It’s only directionless clusterf**ks like WBA that flip between managers who want to play football and dinosaurs, who’d offer Dyche work.
They’ve gone with Mowbray (twice) DiMatteo, Corberan interspersed with the anti-football approach of Allardyce, Pulis, Megson, Ismael and the pragmatic nothingness of Roy Hodgson in the last decade or so.
I’ve never really rated David Moyes that highly, but even he sorted out Dyche’s ugly prehistoric monstrosity at Everton almost immediately. [Post edited 24 May 22:55]
| |
| |
| Ashton's shortlist on 23:27 - May 24 with 1396 views | wrightsrightglove |
Would imagine Anthony Barry will be on the list somewhere, would hope so anyway, a ready made replacement for McKenna | | | |
| Ashton's shortlist on 23:39 - May 24 with 1353 views | cressi |
| Ashton's shortlist on 23:27 - May 24 by wrightsrightglove |
Would imagine Anthony Barry will be on the list somewhere, would hope so anyway, a ready made replacement for McKenna |
Just because it worked in league one and the championship for McKenna I'm not convinced every young coach should get this job when available.
Burley had been at Ayr and colchester and I would like a little bit of experience in the managers role. | | | |
| Ashton's shortlist on 23:43 - May 24 with 1332 views | Bigalhunter |
| Ashton's shortlist on 20:54 - May 24 by Nutkins_Return |
Agree but think he will be gone by then. I would be very happy with Rosenior personally. Very much in the McKenna mould and talks so well in interviews and always seems to have the full respect and love of players. Also he knows some of squad well and knows the club and I always get the impression has a bit of affinity there (Him and McKenna were on good terms and he wavery respectful to us in interviews). Obviously as well a good manager. He seems to be progressing year on year and done an excellent job in France (which will help with our future European adventures ;)) |
He might also have seen some decent players during his time in France?
Actually, no, silly me.
You can only tap into that market once you’ve set up a fully funded overseas network of experienced talent calculators who can identify suitable candidates based on a number of empirical conditions and statistics over 10 years, like Brighton and Brentford…apparently.
Gone are the days when you can just send your assistant coach over to eyeball a promising talent, and, if he reckons he can do a job, ask his agent if he wants to join your club…
Nooo, an unfit Kalvin Phillips who can offer you 40 mins a month, an Aston Villa reserve who didn’t fancy it 5 months earlier, a goalie who got dropped by the relegation fodder that went down a year earlier and a lanky Hull centre half who falls over if the wind is a bit brisk are what you want..
Applying this utter nonsense, Sir Bobby would never have got Muhren & Thijssen. [Post edited 24 May 23:53]
| |
| |
| Ashton's shortlist on 08:16 - May 25 with 872 views | nrb1985 |
| Ashton's shortlist on 23:43 - May 24 by Bigalhunter |
He might also have seen some decent players during his time in France?
Actually, no, silly me.
You can only tap into that market once you’ve set up a fully funded overseas network of experienced talent calculators who can identify suitable candidates based on a number of empirical conditions and statistics over 10 years, like Brighton and Brentford…apparently.
Gone are the days when you can just send your assistant coach over to eyeball a promising talent, and, if he reckons he can do a job, ask his agent if he wants to join your club…
Nooo, an unfit Kalvin Phillips who can offer you 40 mins a month, an Aston Villa reserve who didn’t fancy it 5 months earlier, a goalie who got dropped by the relegation fodder that went down a year earlier and a lanky Hull centre half who falls over if the wind is a bit brisk are what you want..
Applying this utter nonsense, Sir Bobby would never have got Muhren & Thijssen. [Post edited 24 May 23:53]
|
Ok boomer. | | | |
| Ashton's shortlist on 08:27 - May 25 with 818 views | Kieran_Knows |
Danny Rohl
Carlos Cuesta
Anthony Barry |  |
| |
| Ashton's shortlist on 08:54 - May 25 with 724 views | bsw72 |
| Ashton's shortlist on 23:43 - May 24 by Bigalhunter |
He might also have seen some decent players during his time in France?
Actually, no, silly me.
You can only tap into that market once you’ve set up a fully funded overseas network of experienced talent calculators who can identify suitable candidates based on a number of empirical conditions and statistics over 10 years, like Brighton and Brentford…apparently.
Gone are the days when you can just send your assistant coach over to eyeball a promising talent, and, if he reckons he can do a job, ask his agent if he wants to join your club…
Nooo, an unfit Kalvin Phillips who can offer you 40 mins a month, an Aston Villa reserve who didn’t fancy it 5 months earlier, a goalie who got dropped by the relegation fodder that went down a year earlier and a lanky Hull centre half who falls over if the wind is a bit brisk are what you want..
Applying this utter nonsense, Sir Bobby would never have got Muhren & Thijssen. [Post edited 24 May 23:53]
|
Valid point, after all the international transfer market has hardly changed since 1978 has it?
 |  | | |
| Ashton's shortlist on 10:04 - May 25 with 557 views | wrightsrightglove |
| Ashton's shortlist on 23:39 - May 24 by cressi |
Just because it worked in league one and the championship for McKenna I'm not convinced every young coach should get this job when available.
Burley had been at Ayr and colchester and I would like a little bit of experience in the managers role. |
I think we’ll be after someone who’s coached at the top level because that’s predominantly what McKenna is, a coach first and a manager second. We’ve invested in youth who have been in top academies with a high ceiling and we need someone who can unlock that full potential. Barry fits that profile to me and seems like the most seamless choice in continuing what McKenna has started.
That being said, I might be completely wrong and Ashton and co might have other ideas, or Barry might not have any ambitions to become a manager and be happy being number 2 in the England set up, who knows | | | |
| Ashton's shortlist on 10:14 - May 25 with 516 views | WestSussexBlue |
| Ashton's shortlist on 21:46 - May 24 by Marshalls_Mullet |
Quite a high failure rate of those type of appointments.
Was arguably easier to do in L1 with the leagues biggest budget and time. |
That’s true. | | | |
| Ashton's shortlist on 11:41 - May 25 with 374 views | Rimsy |
Rosenior has the perfect cv for me. Whether he'd come is another matter. |  |
| |
| Ashton's shortlist on 14:08 - May 25 with 183 views | bournemouthblue |
| Ashton's shortlist on 22:51 - May 24 by Bigalhunter |
Dyche would be a hideous option and totally at odds with what KM has created in terms of ethos and approach to playing attractive football.
It’s only directionless clusterf**ks like WBA that flip between managers who want to play football and dinosaurs, who’d offer Dyche work.
They’ve gone with Mowbray (twice) DiMatteo, Corberan interspersed with the anti-football approach of Allardyce, Pulis, Megson, Ismael and the pragmatic nothingness of Roy Hodgson in the last decade or so.
I’ve never really rated David Moyes that highly, but even he sorted out Dyche’s ugly prehistoric monstrosity at Everton almost immediately. [Post edited 24 May 22:55]
|
Moyes is a very good manager in fairness | |
| |
| Ashton's shortlist on 14:33 - May 25 with 105 views | USA |
| Ashton's shortlist on 22:10 - May 24 by Keno |
Cole Skuse with Chambers as assistant
Or Aluko |
@Keno. Eni? [Post edited 25 May 14:36]
| |
| |
| |
By continuing to use the site, you agree to our use of cookies and to abide by our Terms and Conditions.
