| Rebecca Welch 22:11 - Feb 20 with 6197 views | SitfcB |
Referee for Saturday against MK Dons. |  |
| |  |
| Rebecca Welch on 12:16 - Feb 21 with 1261 views | TractorWood |
| Rebecca Welch on 09:42 - Feb 21 by ITFC_Forever |
In no particular order:
Barnsley (h) - Nothing wrong with Harness' goal.
Charlton (a) - Should have had a player sent off just before half-time.
Fleetwood (h) - Should have been a penalty immediately after we conceded.
Sheff Wed (h) - Should have been a red card for the elbow on Burns.
Sheff Wed (a) - Their second goal miles offside.
Lincoln (a) - Didn't give a penalty when there was three of the same offences they got a penalty for happening at the same time.
That's half a dozen games the ref cost us a win, no matter our own failings. |
Every fan up down the country will have a list of reffing decisions that don't go their way whilst ignoring every decision that has gone their way. It's about reacting, taking your chances, riding your luck and optimising what we can control. |  |
| |
| Rebecca Welch on 12:24 - Feb 21 with 1233 views | GeoffSentence |
She has reffed MK Dons before. They won 4:0 away to Morecambe.
Two other league one games of the seven she has reffed have also ended 4:0, but to the Home side.
She dishes out about 3 yellow cards agame on average.
Last month she reffed a championship game (2-1 away win for PNE at Birmingham) |  |
| |
| Rebecca Welch on 12:27 - Feb 21 with 1225 views | chicoazul |
Morsy nailed on for a red card then. |  |
| |
| Rebecca Welch on 12:42 - Feb 21 with 1202 views | pafcprogs |
| Rebecca Welch on 11:46 - Feb 21 by PhilTWTD |
You missed the foul on Chaplin in the run-up to the first Plymouth goal down there! |
Still not a foul.....he looked for the player and made no attempt to play the ball.
If anything we had a claim for a pen but will settle for the goal from Mumba :)
So Rebecca Welch reffed our win at Birmingham in the cup last season and consensus was she was one of the best refs we had had all season.
I am enjoying the Wednesday fans veering between the absolute certainty off their title win with record points etc and the alleged conspiracy by the EFL to deny them said procession.
Despite your best efforts this is far from done and dusted and I think we will drop some points in the next four ....am hoping that the Fleetwood blip doesn't impact our other so called easy games....we don't seem to have that edge that puts teams away completely until late....be nice to have a three goal cushion at half time one in a while.
Still hoping for Greens /Town 1/2 so come on chaps...get moving :) |  | | |
| Rebecca Welch on 12:45 - Feb 21 with 1198 views | TractorCam |
| Rebecca Welch on 12:42 - Feb 21 by pafcprogs |
Still not a foul.....he looked for the player and made no attempt to play the ball.
If anything we had a claim for a pen but will settle for the goal from Mumba :)
So Rebecca Welch reffed our win at Birmingham in the cup last season and consensus was she was one of the best refs we had had all season.
I am enjoying the Wednesday fans veering between the absolute certainty off their title win with record points etc and the alleged conspiracy by the EFL to deny them said procession.
Despite your best efforts this is far from done and dusted and I think we will drop some points in the next four ....am hoping that the Fleetwood blip doesn't impact our other so called easy games....we don't seem to have that edge that puts teams away completely until late....be nice to have a three goal cushion at half time one in a while.
Still hoping for Greens /Town 1/2 so come on chaps...get moving :) |
Wednesday fans and this agenda is bizarre, given that both our games against them they've been on the end of some fortune from the officials, one of which probably costing us a win. |  |
| |
| Rebecca Welch on 12:53 - Feb 21 with 1174 views | PhilTWTD |
| Rebecca Welch on 12:42 - Feb 21 by pafcprogs |
Still not a foul.....he looked for the player and made no attempt to play the ball.
If anything we had a claim for a pen but will settle for the goal from Mumba :)
So Rebecca Welch reffed our win at Birmingham in the cup last season and consensus was she was one of the best refs we had had all season.
I am enjoying the Wednesday fans veering between the absolute certainty off their title win with record points etc and the alleged conspiracy by the EFL to deny them said procession.
Despite your best efforts this is far from done and dusted and I think we will drop some points in the next four ....am hoping that the Fleetwood blip doesn't impact our other so called easy games....we don't seem to have that edge that puts teams away completely until late....be nice to have a three goal cushion at half time one in a while.
Still hoping for Greens /Town 1/2 so come on chaps...get moving :) |
I don't think he could play the ball when he was fouled as it was about 20 foot in the air and he was shoved over as he was putting himself between the player and where the ball was going to land. Think VAR would have disallowed it. But ancient history now!
Think you're right, teams will drop points here and there as per Saturday. We need to put in a run of wins over the next three games and pick up a decent haul of points from the tougher games to follow against the likes of Bolton, Barnsley and Derby. |  | | |
| Rebecca Welch on 12:54 - Feb 21 with 1175 views | CobboldCrusty |
Please please please can we not get on the ref's back on Saturday if a contentious decision doesn't go our way. Likewise, if you can face it please call people out if they resort to any sexism to vent their frustrations. Aside from some of the Delia chants, our fanbase are not the worst for sexism but there are always a few idiots. |  | | |
| If there's a contentious decision.... on 13:19 - Feb 21 with 1120 views | Bloots |
| Rebecca Welch on 12:54 - Feb 21 by CobboldCrusty |
Please please please can we not get on the ref's back on Saturday if a contentious decision doesn't go our way. Likewise, if you can face it please call people out if they resort to any sexism to vent their frustrations. Aside from some of the Delia chants, our fanbase are not the worst for sexism but there are always a few idiots. |
....that doesn't go our way, I'll give her just as much grief as I normally would.
Hope that's OK. |  |
| "He's been a really positive influence on my life, I think he's a great man" - TWTD User (May 2025) |
| |
Login to get fewer ads
| Rebecca Welch on 13:30 - Feb 21 with 1100 views | MaySixth |
Little experience of League One and a very high card yellow card rate.
In fact, has never officiated an EFL game without showing a yellow. |  |
| |
| Rebecca Welch on 13:33 - Feb 21 with 1089 views | itfcjoe |
| Rebecca Welch on 13:30 - Feb 21 by MaySixth |
Little experience of League One and a very high card yellow card rate.
In fact, has never officiated an EFL game without showing a yellow. |
Can't be many matches that don't have a yellow in them these days
EDIT - bar Port Vale away every game we have played this season has had a yellow [Post edited 21 Feb 2023 13:37]
|  |
| |
| Rebecca Welch on 13:39 - Feb 21 with 1063 views | Garv |
| Rebecca Welch on 11:46 - Feb 21 by PhilTWTD |
You missed the foul on Chaplin in the run-up to the first Plymouth goal down there! |
Come on Phil. It was laughable from Chaplin and he got what he deserved - egg on his face. |  |
| |
| Rebecca Welch on 13:42 - Feb 21 with 1046 views | Garv |
| Rebecca Welch on 09:42 - Feb 21 by ITFC_Forever |
In no particular order:
Barnsley (h) - Nothing wrong with Harness' goal.
Charlton (a) - Should have had a player sent off just before half-time.
Fleetwood (h) - Should have been a penalty immediately after we conceded.
Sheff Wed (h) - Should have been a red card for the elbow on Burns.
Sheff Wed (a) - Their second goal miles offside.
Lincoln (a) - Didn't give a penalty when there was three of the same offences they got a penalty for happening at the same time.
That's half a dozen games the ref cost us a win, no matter our own failings. |
A lot of those are very debatable, not even sure what the red card offence at Charlton was?
The Barnsley one was ridiculous, I'll give you that.
It also ignores all the debatable decisions, offsides and little bits of luck that have gone in our favour.
Essentially, you're clutching. | |
| |
| Rebecca Welch on 13:42 - Feb 21 with 1045 views | PhilTWTD |
| Rebecca Welch on 13:39 - Feb 21 by Garv |
Come on Phil. It was laughable from Chaplin and he got what he deserved - egg on his face. |
He did what anyone else would do, put himself between the ball and the player, and was fouled. | | | |
| Rebecca Welch on 13:45 - Feb 21 with 1022 views | Plums |
| Rebecca Welch on 22:21 - Feb 20 by xrayspecs |
Not much experience at this level... |
There's only one way to get it... |  |
| |
| Rebecca Welch on 13:53 - Feb 21 with 1008 views | EastTownBlue |
| Rebecca Welch on 13:30 - Feb 21 by MaySixth |
Little experience of League One and a very high card yellow card rate.
In fact, has never officiated an EFL game without showing a yellow. |
Her yellow card average of just above 3 per a game overall is quite low in comparison to most referees. | | | |
| Rebecca Welch on 14:02 - Feb 21 with 992 views | RobTheMonk |
| Rebecca Welch on 13:42 - Feb 21 by PhilTWTD |
He did what anyone else would do, put himself between the ball and the player, and was fouled. |
I think that there's so much debate about it from our own fans suggests it wasn't a nailed on foul.
For the record, I think it would have been soft if given. |  | | |
| You're thinking of Dickie Davies. (n/t) on 14:24 - Feb 21 with 929 views | Heathlander |
| You're thinking of Dickie Davies. (n/t) on 22:17 - Feb 20 by Bloots |
|
Does she have Dickie Davies eyes? |  | | |
| Rebecca Welch on 14:25 - Feb 21 with 925 views | PhilTWTD |
| Rebecca Welch on 14:02 - Feb 21 by RobTheMonk |
I think that there's so much debate about it from our own fans suggests it wasn't a nailed on foul.
For the record, I think it would have been soft if given. |
I find there's always someone willing to argue against the most blatant of fouls! | | | |
| Rebecca Welch on 14:25 - Feb 21 with 921 views | PhilTWTD |
| Rebecca Welch on 13:42 - Feb 21 by Garv |
A lot of those are very debatable, not even sure what the red card offence at Charlton was?
The Barnsley one was ridiculous, I'll give you that.
It also ignores all the debatable decisions, offsides and little bits of luck that have gone in our favour.
Essentially, you're clutching. |
The handball on the line, I assume. | | | |
| Rebecca Welch on 14:58 - Feb 21 with 856 views | ITFC_Forever |
| Rebecca Welch on 13:42 - Feb 21 by Garv |
A lot of those are very debatable, not even sure what the red card offence at Charlton was?
The Barnsley one was ridiculous, I'll give you that.
It also ignores all the debatable decisions, offsides and little bits of luck that have gone in our favour.
Essentially, you're clutching. |
None of them are debatable - they were all stonewallers. |  |
| |
| Rebecca Welch on 15:46 - Feb 21 with 787 views | pafcprogs |
| Rebecca Welch on 13:39 - Feb 21 by Garv |
Come on Phil. It was laughable from Chaplin and he got what he deserved - egg on his face. |
:)
I am all for partisanship but I was a referee so tend to be of the view that what would you say if it were the other way round.....so if that was Houghton in the Chaplin role and vice versa is it an Argyle le pen?
Not for me ....
Anyway...water under the bridge... | | | |
| Rebecca Welch on 15:49 - Feb 21 with 769 views | GeoffSentence |
| Rebecca Welch on 13:30 - Feb 21 by MaySixth |
Little experience of League One and a very high card yellow card rate.
In fact, has never officiated an EFL game without showing a yellow. |
She averages roughly 3 yellows per game. Is that high? I dunno, never really looked into it before.
I hope some of those are for timewasting. | |
| |
| Rebecca Welch on 23:36 - Feb 22 with 626 views | Garv |
| Rebecca Welch on 13:42 - Feb 21 by PhilTWTD |
He did what anyone else would do, put himself between the ball and the player, and was fouled. |
So he initiated any contact that there ended up being?
Thanks. | |
| |
| Rebecca Welch on 23:44 - Feb 22 with 622 views | Garv |
| Rebecca Welch on 14:58 - Feb 21 by ITFC_Forever |
None of them are debatable - they were all stonewallers. |
Who's to say we even benefit and go on the win the SW and Charlton games with a man advantage?
Or score the penalties we supposedly should have had?
Do you have an issue with the offside goals we've scored? | |
| |
| Rebecca Welch on 23:49 - Feb 22 with 617 views | PhilTWTD |
| Rebecca Welch on 23:36 - Feb 22 by Garv |
So he initiated any contact that there ended up being?
Thanks. |
Are you suggesting he did something wrong? Putting yourself between the opposition player and the ball is pretty basic stuff. | | | |
| |
By continuing to use the site, you agree to our use of cookies and to abide by our Terms and Conditions.
