| Penalty record under McKenna 14:42 - Mar 7 with 3303 views | TresBonne |
Just off the top of my head, have we missed more than we've scored?! Feels like we barely get given them and then they don't go in when we do! |  | | |  |
| Penalty record under McKenna on 14:52 - Mar 7 with 2943 views | gainsboroughblue |
2/1 scored/missed this season
Al-Hamidi 1/1
Hirst 1/0
4/4 last season
Broadhead 2/1
Chaplin 0/2
Ladapo 1/0
Evans 1/0
Jackson 0/1
1/0 from December 2021-22
Chaplin 1/0 |  |
| |
| Penalty record under McKenna on 14:53 - Mar 7 with 2924 views | GlasgowBlue |
Off the top of my head, we missed:
Chaplin v Sheffield Wednesday
Chaplin v Morecambe or Accrington (I was at both so forget which)
Broadhead v Barnsley
Ali v Bristol City |  |
| |
| Penalty record under McKenna on 14:53 - Mar 7 with 2930 views | TrumptonBlue |
2021/22 8.1.22 A Gillingham - Chaplin C Scored
2022/23 8.10.22 A Morecambe - Chaplin C Missed
2022/23 8.10.22 A Morecambe - Evans L Scored
2022/23 21.10.22 H Derby Co - Jackson K Missed
2022/23 7.1.23 H Rotherham Utd - Chaplin C Scored
2022/23 7.1.23 H Rotherham Utd - Burns W Scored
2022/23 11.2.23 H Sheffield Wed - Chaplin C Missed
2022/23 7.4.23H Wycombe W - Ladapo F Scored
2022/23 18.4.23 H Port Vale - Broadhead N Scored
2022/23 25.4.23 A Barnsley - Broadhead N Missed
2022/23 29.4.23 H Exeter C - Broadhead N Scored
2023/24 11.11.23 H Swansea C - Hirst G Scored
2023/24 14.2.24 A Millwall - Al-Hamadi A Scored
2023/24 5.3.24H Bristol C - Al-Hamadi A Missed
9 scored, 5 missed |  | | |
| Penalty record under McKenna on 14:57 - Mar 7 with 2881 views | RobTheMonk |
| Penalty record under McKenna on 14:52 - Mar 7 by gainsboroughblue |
2/1 scored/missed this season
Al-Hamidi 1/1
Hirst 1/0
4/4 last season
Broadhead 2/1
Chaplin 0/2
Ladapo 1/0
Evans 1/0
Jackson 0/1
1/0 from December 2021-22
Chaplin 1/0 |
Let’s bring Tommy Miller in for a few training sessions haha! |  | | |
| Penalty record under McKenna on 15:02 - Mar 7 with 2836 views | gainsboroughblue |
| Penalty record under McKenna on 14:57 - Mar 7 by RobTheMonk |
Let’s bring Tommy Miller in for a few training sessions haha! |
Indeed. Gone are the days I think when you can have just the one specialised penalty kick taker. Nowadays, there is a good chance they'd have been subbed off when you get one. When it was only one sub on the bench and Warky playing every 90 minutes it was different.
I'm guessing the likes of Ladapo/Jackson taking one apiece was due to the first choice taker being off the field, or maybe even completing a hat-trick or getting one as a confidence boosting goal when the game was already won. | |
| |
| Penalty record under McKenna on 15:06 - Mar 7 with 2800 views | hoppy |
| Penalty record under McKenna on 14:57 - Mar 7 by RobTheMonk |
Let’s bring Tommy Miller in for a few training sessions haha! |
Or Warky... he's around the club all the time. |  |
| |
| Penalty record under McKenna on 15:46 - Mar 7 with 2625 views | Sparky85 |
Would like to see Leif given the pens. All-round set piece specialist
Burns strikes a clean ball too! |  | | |
| Penalty record under McKenna on 16:37 - Mar 7 with 2491 views | Vegtablue |
Will put this here in case anyone wants to know the candidates' records.
Bristol City report by Vegtablue 7 Mar 16:35Davis is performing below his xG as it happens. Maybe the dead-ball nature of penalties would suit much better, but he hasn't shown shooting prowess in open play.
Chaplin's overall penalty record is 4:5. With us he's 5:2, so better, but in the league it's 1:2.
Broadhead's overall record is good, 5:1. With us he's 2:1.
Hirst overall is 8:2. 1:0 with us.
Al-Hamadi is 1:3. Wimbledon took him off penalty duties and we should too.
Our cleanest striker of the ball is Taylor, but he often isn't on the pitch and has only taken 1 penalty before (scored for us in the cup). JCH was penalty-taker at Posh, probably written into his contract!
Broadhead and Chaplin were on the pitch when Hirst took his penalty, which was won by Taylor, so my guess is George was the nominated guy prior to his injury.
My first pick would be Moore if on the field. His overall record is 7:2, but he's also 7:0 since his early misses in lower league. He was Cardiff's penalty-taker and scored all 5.
| | | |
Login to get fewer ads
| Penalty record under McKenna on 16:41 - Mar 7 with 2454 views | Vegtablue |
| Penalty record under McKenna on 15:46 - Mar 7 by Sparky85 |
Would like to see Leif given the pens. All-round set piece specialist
Burns strikes a clean ball too! |
Burns' record is 1:0, same as Taylor. Leif is unblemished (0:0). | | | |
| Penalty record under McKenna on 17:03 - Mar 7 with 2400 views | Basuco |
| Penalty record under McKenna on 15:46 - Mar 7 by Sparky85 |
Would like to see Leif given the pens. All-round set piece specialist
Burns strikes a clean ball too! |
I think it was Leif who said in his post match interview that he would not have liked to take the penalty. |  | | |
| Penalty record under McKenna on 17:39 - Mar 7 with 2329 views | hoppy |
| Penalty record under McKenna on 15:46 - Mar 7 by Sparky85 |
Would like to see Leif given the pens. All-round set piece specialist
Burns strikes a clean ball too! |
Wouldn't Burns just whack it? | |
| |
| Penalty record under McKenna on 18:59 - Mar 7 with 2201 views | Vic |
| Penalty record under McKenna on 14:57 - Mar 7 by RobTheMonk |
Let’s bring Tommy Miller in for a few training sessions haha! |
Better still, Warky, who is always in and around the building. |  |
| |
| How about John Wark.... on 19:13 - Mar 7 with 2163 views | Bloots |
| Penalty record under McKenna on 14:57 - Mar 7 by RobTheMonk |
Let’s bring Tommy Miller in for a few training sessions haha! |
...he's usually at matches.
Eh?
Eh? |  |
| Elite Level Poster: Elite Level Supporter: Elite Level Human |
| |
| Penalty record under McKenna on 19:51 - Mar 7 with 2062 views | Swansea_Blue |
| Penalty record under McKenna on 16:37 - Mar 7 by Vegtablue |
Will put this here in case anyone wants to know the candidates' records.
Bristol City report by Vegtablue 7 Mar 16:35Davis is performing below his xG as it happens. Maybe the dead-ball nature of penalties would suit much better, but he hasn't shown shooting prowess in open play.
Chaplin's overall penalty record is 4:5. With us he's 5:2, so better, but in the league it's 1:2.
Broadhead's overall record is good, 5:1. With us he's 2:1.
Hirst overall is 8:2. 1:0 with us.
Al-Hamadi is 1:3. Wimbledon took him off penalty duties and we should too.
Our cleanest striker of the ball is Taylor, but he often isn't on the pitch and has only taken 1 penalty before (scored for us in the cup). JCH was penalty-taker at Posh, probably written into his contract!
Broadhead and Chaplin were on the pitch when Hirst took his penalty, which was won by Taylor, so my guess is George was the nominated guy prior to his injury.
My first pick would be Moore if on the field. His overall record is 7:2, but he's also 7:0 since his early misses in lower league. He was Cardiff's penalty-taker and scored all 5.
|
I saw that earlier and thought it was really interesting, thank you. I was wondering whether Leif would be a good option given his wand of a left foot, but whipping in a cross is different to psyching out a keeper. I hadn’t realised Kieffer’s record was so good - seems like a no-brainer to me when he’s on the pitch. Al Hamadi shouldn’t be anywhere near them based on last night. But despite his miss it felt wrong to me before he took it. He’s stepping up, came on late as a sub, still adjusting, etc. It felt like a bad call at the time, but then we didn’t have an obvious alternative. |  |
| |
| Penalty record under McKenna on 20:19 - Mar 7 with 1962 views | E_I_E_I_E_I_O |
| Penalty record under McKenna on 17:03 - Mar 7 by Basuco |
I think it was Leif who said in his post match interview that he would not have liked to take the penalty. |
I think he was just saying that to be kind to A.A-H. | | | |
| Penalty record under McKenna on 21:06 - Mar 7 with 1863 views | brazil1981 |
A few stats on the subject:
Tommy Miller scored 17 from 17 for Town;
Warky scored 56 from 62.
Generally accepted professional footie rate is around 75%, although recently in Prem it’s been approaching 90%!
Record under McK is 64%, so way below average, perhaps a ‘detail’ or ‘fine margin’ he can work on?! [Post edited 7 Mar 21:18]
| | | |
| Penalty record under McKenna on 21:10 - Mar 7 with 1845 views | SouperJim |
Have we ever had someone chip one down the middle? Always seems to me that one's put down the middle have a very high success rate and it's much easier to get right than sticking one firmly inside the post. |  |
| |
| Penalty record under McKenna on 21:20 - Mar 7 with 1794 views | WestStanderLaLaLa |
| Penalty record under McKenna on 21:10 - Mar 7 by SouperJim |
Have we ever had someone chip one down the middle? Always seems to me that one's put down the middle have a very high success rate and it's much easier to get right than sticking one firmly inside the post. |
Sir Marcus to bring up his hat trick at Southampton |  |
| |
| Penalty record under McKenna on 21:33 - Mar 7 with 1745 views | LeoMuff |
| Penalty record under McKenna on 21:06 - Mar 7 by brazil1981 |
A few stats on the subject:
Tommy Miller scored 17 from 17 for Town;
Warky scored 56 from 62.
Generally accepted professional footie rate is around 75%, although recently in Prem it’s been approaching 90%!
Record under McK is 64%, so way below average, perhaps a ‘detail’ or ‘fine margin’ he can work on?! [Post edited 7 Mar 21:18]
|
Most definitely, we are well below average looking at this thread. Quite weird Ali taking it really, love to know how that came about. |  |
| |
| Penalty record under McKenna on 21:45 - Mar 7 with 1691 views | gainsboroughblue |
| Penalty record under McKenna on 21:06 - Mar 7 by brazil1981 |
A few stats on the subject:
Tommy Miller scored 17 from 17 for Town;
Warky scored 56 from 62.
Generally accepted professional footie rate is around 75%, although recently in Prem it’s been approaching 90%!
Record under McK is 64%, so way below average, perhaps a ‘detail’ or ‘fine margin’ he can work on?! [Post edited 7 Mar 21:18]
|
Brilliant record for Miller. Was one of his 17 kicks a re-taken one after the first effort was saved or am I imagining it? | |
| |
| Penalty record under McKenna on 21:46 - Mar 7 with 1664 views | TrumptonBlue |
| Penalty record under McKenna on 21:45 - Mar 7 by gainsboroughblue |
Brilliant record for Miller. Was one of his 17 kicks a re-taken one after the first effort was saved or am I imagining it? |
No, you’re right. He had one saved in that mad 3-4 against Forest but scored the re-take. | | | |
| Penalty record under McKenna on 00:09 - Mar 8 with 1484 views | Garv |
| Penalty record under McKenna on 21:06 - Mar 7 by brazil1981 |
A few stats on the subject:
Tommy Miller scored 17 from 17 for Town;
Warky scored 56 from 62.
Generally accepted professional footie rate is around 75%, although recently in Prem it’s been approaching 90%!
Record under McK is 64%, so way below average, perhaps a ‘detail’ or ‘fine margin’ he can work on?! [Post edited 7 Mar 21:18]
|
What about the one Miller had saved that Pablo tried to bundle over the line, that for some reason got re-taken? (Obviously he scored it). |  |
| |
| Penalty record under McKenna on 05:33 - Mar 8 with 1379 views | franz_tyson |
In terms of technique and hitting a clean ball - I'd go for Chaplin and Davis. Don't think it was right for Al Hamadi to take that pen. Should have been Chappers as he's the senior pro. Just find it odd because Chappers is often trying to fight to take a 25 yard free-kick, yet turns down a penalty. Something needs to be sorted in training as we've got to improve on penalties. If its purely a mental thing - then maybe it's Morsy. Strongest character out there.
For me, Chaplin has the technique. Steer clear of being too fancy - but I'm sure he can pick a spot and hit a ball sweetly. | | | |
| Penalty record under McKenna on 07:31 - Mar 8 with 1268 views | gainsboroughblue |
| Penalty record under McKenna on 00:09 - Mar 8 by Garv |
What about the one Miller had saved that Pablo tried to bundle over the line, that for some reason got re-taken? (Obviously he scored it). |
Darren Bent took that one. I think Miller took over as taker later that season. | |
| |
| Penalty record under McKenna on 08:12 - Mar 8 with 1191 views | Wickets |
| Penalty record under McKenna on 21:10 - Mar 7 by SouperJim |
Have we ever had someone chip one down the middle? Always seems to me that one's put down the middle have a very high success rate and it's much easier to get right than sticking one firmly inside the post. |
Your memory is worse than mine we saw Marcus complete his hat trick against Southampton with a chip down the middle ! On the TV mind you . |  | | |
| |
By continuing to use the site, you agree to our use of cookies and to abide by our Terms and Conditions.
