Please log in or register. Registered visitors get fewer ads.
Forum index | Previous Thread | Next thread
Bad foul- but if thats a red 14:34 - Apr 20 with 6413 viewsredrickstuhaart

we should have been playing ten men on at least a dozen occasions this season.
1
Bad foul- but if thats a red on 15:01 - Apr 20 with 1192 viewswarky_1970

Bad foul- but if thats a red on 14:52 - Apr 20 by redrickstuhaart

Its not a stamp though is it?

Its a yellow. Clip from behind. See it every week.


He knows he can’t get the ball, the player has his back to him and he deliberately stamps his studs on his achilles. Disgusting challenge, straight red and the cheeky cnt tries to lie and argue his way out of it.

Hit him with a massive club fine. A weeks wages or two at least. Make him train with the kids too. Drop him. He’s a fcking liability.
-11
Bad foul- but if thats a red on 15:01 - Apr 20 with 1202 viewsredrickstuhaart

Bad foul- but if thats a red on 14:57 - Apr 20 by LeoMuff

It’s a tackle that happens multiple times every weekend, I really can’t see how it’s a red.


Exactly. I can see the argument that it should be a red. But it is not the standard that gets applied week in week out.
1
Bad foul- but if thats a red on 15:02 - Apr 20 with 1186 viewsJoey_Joe_Joe_Junior

Bad foul- but if thats a red on 14:52 - Apr 20 by redrickstuhaart

Its not a stamp though is it?

Its a yellow. Clip from behind. See it every week.


Clip from behind? FFS!
0
Bad foul- but if thats a red on 15:02 - Apr 20 with 1178 viewswarky_1970

Bad foul- but if thats a red on 15:01 - Apr 20 by redrickstuhaart

Exactly. I can see the argument that it should be a red. But it is not the standard that gets applied week in week out.


Well we should applaud the ref for being correct then.
-2
Bad foul- but if thats a red on 15:02 - Apr 20 with 1182 viewsJimmy86

Bad foul- but if thats a red on 14:44 - Apr 20 by redrickstuhaart

Ask yourself honestly if that is Saka on Leif rather than vice versa, what the chances of a red card would be.


Don't be so daft! Take the blue tinted specs off and see that challenge for what it was! Christ alive, even Leif knew he'd screwed up, as he was apologising, when leaving the pitch..

It was stupid from Leif.. he gave the ref a decision to make and VAR wouldn't ever overturn that.. Yes Saka reacted like he'd been shot, but that's beside the point... Leif caught him on the achillies and wasn't anywhere near the ball
0
Bad foul- but if thats a red on 15:03 - Apr 20 with 1181 viewspointofblue

Bad foul- but if thats a red on 14:44 - Apr 20 by redrickstuhaart

Ask yourself honestly if that is Saka on Leif rather than vice versa, what the chances of a red card would be.


Don't even have to consider that. Think about Tarkowski's tackle in the Merseyside derby, and that was only a yellow.

Poll: Who would you play at right centre back on Saturday?

0
Bad foul- but if thats a red on 15:03 - Apr 20 with 1175 viewsBluefields

Bad foul- but if thats a red on 14:39 - Apr 20 by LeoMuff

It’s not a red if you are miles away from the ball, never a red in million years badly timed, but not dangerous, yellow all day.


It’s a terrible, dangerous tackle. Clear red. Davis is a long way from making contact with the ball
0
Bad foul- but if thats a red on 15:04 - Apr 20 with 1159 viewsDublinBlue84

Bad foul- but if thats a red on 15:03 - Apr 20 by pointofblue

Don't even have to consider that. Think about Tarkowski's tackle in the Merseyside derby, and that was only a yellow.


A bad decision elsewhere doesn't mean it's not a red card.

Poll: Should Davis have been sent off?

1
Login to get fewer ads

Bad foul- but if thats a red on 15:06 - Apr 20 with 1145 viewsLeoMuff

Bad foul- but if thats a red on 15:03 - Apr 20 by Bluefields

It’s a terrible, dangerous tackle. Clear red. Davis is a long way from making contact with the ball


Completely disagree, outside of the prem that is never a red, in the prem never a red for a bigger side.

The only Muff in Town.
Poll: Lamberts rotational policy has left us....

3
Bad foul- but if thats a red on 15:06 - Apr 20 with 1137 viewsNBVJohn

Bad foul- but if thats a red on 14:40 - Apr 20 by Illinoisblue

Example: five mins before, Enciso is breaking free, is pulled back, clear yellow??? Nope, not given.


It’s difficult to argue the red card.

My greater irritation was exactly this though - deliberately stopping the quick break and no yellow. Disgraceful.
3
Bad foul- but if thats a red on 15:12 - Apr 20 with 1087 viewsleitrimblue

Looked firm but fair to me..
0
Bad foul- but if thats a red on 16:36 - Apr 20 with 953 viewsHerbivore

Bad foul- but if thats a red on 15:01 - Apr 20 by warky_1970

He knows he can’t get the ball, the player has his back to him and he deliberately stamps his studs on his achilles. Disgusting challenge, straight red and the cheeky cnt tries to lie and argue his way out of it.

Hit him with a massive club fine. A weeks wages or two at least. Make him train with the kids too. Drop him. He’s a fcking liability.


You're a liability. Absolute state of you.

Poll: Latest TWTD opinion poll - who are you voting for?
Blog: Where Did It All Go Wrong for Paul Hurst?

10
Bad foul- but if thats a red on 16:43 - Apr 20 with 926 viewsHemelBlue

Bad foul- but if thats a red on 14:36 - Apr 20 by reusersfreekicks

Not a red ever


Deliberate, no possibility of getting neat the ball, putting full force through the back of his standing ankle. People on here saying that is not a red are an embarrassment. Could not be clearer.
-2
Bad foul- but if thats a red on 17:25 - Apr 20 with 862 viewsGeoffSentence

Bad foul- but if thats a red on 14:36 - Apr 20 by OsmansCleanSheet

True, but if that’s an Arsenal player I’d bet my house it would be no more than a yellow.


Enciso had his ankles taken out when breaking earlier in the game. malicious, deliberateand clear. no card.

The ref wasn't the worst we've had by any means, that honour goes to Tim Robinson,but he was quick to give Arsenal any decision and relunctant to give us anything.

Don't boil a kettle on a boat.
Poll: The best Williams to play for Town

4
Bad foul- but if thats a red on 18:48 - Apr 20 with 774 viewsHerbivore

Bad foul- but if thats a red on 17:25 - Apr 20 by GeoffSentence

Enciso had his ankles taken out when breaking earlier in the game. malicious, deliberateand clear. no card.

The ref wasn't the worst we've had by any means, that honour goes to Tim Robinson,but he was quick to give Arsenal any decision and relunctant to give us anything.


Yep, it's the accumulation of all those decisions that could go one way or the other only ever going one way.

Poll: Latest TWTD opinion poll - who are you voting for?
Blog: Where Did It All Go Wrong for Paul Hurst?

0
Bad foul- but if thats a red on 19:01 - Apr 20 with 748 viewsstonojnr

The best part is it annoyed Piers Morgan, alot, both the tackle and the home support for Davis and not Saka post card.

so that was ultimately a great outcome, and Saka is perfectly fine too, so the universe is balanced again :)
1
Bad foul- but if thats a red on 19:13 - Apr 20 with 718 viewsnorfsufblue

Bad foul- but if thats a red on 14:41 - Apr 20 by Chrisd

The only way I judge these decisions is if that happened to one of our players would we expect a sending off? Without doubt. It’s a poor challenge by Davis fullstop.


Yeah....and for comparison the guy sent off for Man Utd.... ref didnt even give a foul, VAR seemed to take do long as looking for a way to avoid a red... i mean yhat was a red on first replay!!... today it just seemed to me the ref wasnt going to give it till he had a guess at how much Saka was crying?... i do admittedly wear very blue tinted glasses. Just think these things " dont" even themselves up in this league! Guess im just disappointed we haven't managed to pull off another incredible achievement
0
Bad foul- but if thats a red on 19:35 - Apr 20 with 695 viewsWickets

Bad foul- but if thats a red on 14:36 - Apr 20 by SWLondonBlue93

If it was the other way round and not given, you'd been screaming about how the officials have it in for us.


Well yes but we would never have got it !
0
Bad foul- but if thats a red on 20:18 - Apr 20 with 645 viewsBlueForYou

Definite yellow, but didn’t think it should be red. Agree with others, you see that tackle more than once in every game & they always draw a yellow card. If every one of those was a red card we’d be having 9 v 9 or less on the pitch.
1
Bad foul- but if thats a red on 20:24 - Apr 20 with 634 viewsPrideOfTheEast

Not sure that’s fair. Think it’s a red card 2 thirds of the time and all the time if it’s Leif Davis fouling Saka. Shouldn’t Davis have been booked for a foul off the ball shortly beforehand anyway?
0
Bad foul- but if thats a red on 20:28 - Apr 20 with 621 viewsJoey_Joe_Joe_Junior

Bad foul- but if thats a red on 20:24 - Apr 20 by PrideOfTheEast

Not sure that’s fair. Think it’s a red card 2 thirds of the time and all the time if it’s Leif Davis fouling Saka. Shouldn’t Davis have been booked for a foul off the ball shortly beforehand anyway?


Yep on their first goal, don’t think he was trying to hurt Saka but he was clearly frustrated, poor challenge. Also as diving or making a meal of things go he got studs right down the back of his achilles so not sure people can argue he made too much of a meal of it. Was clearly a painful one.
2
Bad foul- but if thats a red on 20:29 - Apr 20 with 619 viewsbluefunk

Bad foul- but if thats a red on 15:01 - Apr 20 by warky_1970

He knows he can’t get the ball, the player has his back to him and he deliberately stamps his studs on his achilles. Disgusting challenge, straight red and the cheeky cnt tries to lie and argue his way out of it.

Hit him with a massive club fine. A weeks wages or two at least. Make him train with the kids too. Drop him. He’s a fcking liability.


I’m beginning to wonder if Davis has done something (or someone) outside football. to incite this level of hatred. Maybe you should go and talk to a professional
1
Bad foul- but if thats a red on 20:29 - Apr 20 with 617 viewsNthsuffolkblue

Bad foul- but if thats a red on 14:41 - Apr 20 by Chrisd

The only way I judge these decisions is if that happened to one of our players would we expect a sending off? Without doubt. It’s a poor challenge by Davis fullstop.


I agree.

I wouldn't expect a red and if they got one I would think that's harsh and know that VAR would overturn it.

I was very surprised VAR didn't get involved and am quite certain they would not have done had the ref given a yellow for it instead.

Poll: How do you feel about the re-election of Trump?
Blog: [Blog] Ghostbusters

0
Bad foul- but if thats a red on 21:45 - Apr 20 with 540 viewsStNeotsBlue

Bad foul- but if thats a red on 20:29 - Apr 20 by Nthsuffolkblue

I agree.

I wouldn't expect a red and if they got one I would think that's harsh and know that VAR would overturn it.

I was very surprised VAR didn't get involved and am quite certain they would not have done had the ref given a yellow for it instead.


It was a red all day long. Foot off the ground, high and not even close to the ball. Amazed at how many are saying it was harsh.
0
Bad foul- but if thats a red on 21:49 - Apr 20 with 520 viewsNthsuffolkblue

Bad foul- but if thats a red on 21:45 - Apr 20 by StNeotsBlue

It was a red all day long. Foot off the ground, high and not even close to the ball. Amazed at how many are saying it was harsh.


It's difficult to tackle without taking your foot off the ground. Unless you are suggesting the contact was 1 foot off the ground which it wasn't. He caught Saka on his heel. It was from behind and late which is why I guess it was given as a red but I maintain still that had it not been given, VAR doesn't ask for a second look. I think it's one that VAR goes with the ref's call either way. I don't think there was much expectation of a red card until the referee produced it.

Poll: How do you feel about the re-election of Trump?
Blog: [Blog] Ghostbusters

1




About Us Contact Us Terms & Conditions Privacy Cookies Advertising
© TWTD 1995-2025