| the disallowed goal 09:05 - Aug 10 with 1627 views | GeoffSentence |
Who was it who asked the question "would that be given as a penalty if it was in the box?" On the commentary
Whoever it was, looking at the penalty Wrexham got you'd have to say, "yeah, probably, good chance it would " |  |
| |  |
| the disallowed goal on 09:13 - Aug 10 with 1559 views | tonybied |
I thought exactly the same after seeing the incident. Don Goodman was probably looking in the wrong direction when that happened. |  | | |
| the disallowed goal on 09:20 - Aug 10 with 1498 views | monty_radio |
| the disallowed goal on 09:13 - Aug 10 by tonybied |
I thought exactly the same after seeing the incident. Don Goodman was probably looking in the wrong direction when that happened. |
Although the Sky compendium of comments probably is slightly ambivalent when it come to the lightly-applied karate chop across the throat. |  |
| |
| the disallowed goal on 10:05 - Aug 10 with 1291 views | TractorFrog |
They often say ‘would that be given as a foul if it wasn’t in the box’ about potential penalties not awarded. You can’t really have it both ways. |  |
| They'd all laugh at me if they knew what I was trying to do. To create a new strain of super-wine in half-an-hour with a fraction of nature's resources and a FOOL for an assistant. 'Bernard Black, he's mad,' they'd say, 'he's insane, he's dangerous.' Well I'll show them! I'll show them all! | | Poll: | Who should start in CM with Cajuste? |
| |
| the disallowed goal on 11:27 - Aug 10 with 1113 views | Benters |
I know this will go against the grain but I thought their disallowed goal was perfectly ok. |  |
| |
| the disallowed goal on 11:30 - Aug 10 with 1094 views | redrickstuhaart |
| the disallowed goal on 11:27 - Aug 10 by Benters |
I know this will go against the grain but I thought their disallowed goal was perfectly ok. |
Its not against the grain, just wrong.
The attacker literally jumps into Greaves' back with no interest in the ball. | | | |
| the disallowed goal on 11:32 - Aug 10 with 1075 views | Benters |
| the disallowed goal on 11:30 - Aug 10 by redrickstuhaart |
Its not against the grain, just wrong.
The attacker literally jumps into Greaves' back with no interest in the ball. |
I’ve just watched it again nothing much in it. | |
| |
| the disallowed goal on 11:33 - Aug 10 with 1059 views | redrickstuhaart |
| the disallowed goal on 11:32 - Aug 10 by Benters |
I’ve just watched it again nothing much in it. |
Literally jumps into his back without an interest in the ball, as Greaves is trying to head the ball.
Clearly impedes, not competing for the ball in any meaningful sense. More significant impact than a two handed push would be- which we would all agree was a foul, I suspect. | | | |
| the disallowed goal on 11:34 - Aug 10 with 1030 views | textbackup |
| the disallowed goal on 11:30 - Aug 10 by redrickstuhaart |
Its not against the grain, just wrong.
The attacker literally jumps into Greaves' back with no interest in the ball. |
After watching it back it was a foul, and the ref got that right.
However, seeing Greaves hit the deck is so common that in real time I thought he’d just gone down way too easy.
Dangerous old game when a defender leaves it to chance for the ref to get the decision right. |  |
| |
Login to get fewer ads
| the disallowed goal on 11:38 - Aug 10 with 1017 views | Benters |
| the disallowed goal on 11:33 - Aug 10 by redrickstuhaart |
Literally jumps into his back without an interest in the ball, as Greaves is trying to head the ball.
Clearly impedes, not competing for the ball in any meaningful sense. More significant impact than a two handed push would be- which we would all agree was a foul, I suspect. |
Can’t see it myself I will watch it again later on my Carlos Fandango telly. | |
| |
| the disallowed goal on 11:43 - Aug 10 with 1004 views | SE1blue |
| the disallowed goal on 11:34 - Aug 10 by textbackup |
After watching it back it was a foul, and the ref got that right.
However, seeing Greaves hit the deck is so common that in real time I thought he’d just gone down way too easy.
Dangerous old game when a defender leaves it to chance for the ref to get the decision right. |
If there’s one thing we’ve learned from the PL, it’s how to win a foul.
There were some nasty ones from Brum, for sure, but I thought we looked for some of weaker ones. |  |
| |
| the disallowed goal on 11:58 - Aug 10 with 942 views | berkstractorboy |
| the disallowed goal on 11:38 - Aug 10 by Benters |
Can’t see it myself I will watch it again later on my Carlos Fandango telly. |
I'm with you Benters, 50/50 on it, there is contact and I am not so sure how much it really impedes him. Tbf I would be livid it it had been blown against us and we went on to put the ball in the net. I also listened to Greaves Sky interview after the match and he said he felt contact, but it didn't to me sound like Greaves thought it as a blatant foul but one you sometimes get for or against you. | | | |
| the disallowed goal on 12:02 - Aug 10 with 908 views | Benters |
| the disallowed goal on 11:58 - Aug 10 by berkstractorboy |
I'm with you Benters, 50/50 on it, there is contact and I am not so sure how much it really impedes him. Tbf I would be livid it it had been blown against us and we went on to put the ball in the net. I also listened to Greaves Sky interview after the match and he said he felt contact, but it didn't to me sound like Greaves thought it as a blatant foul but one you sometimes get for or against you. |
Exactly it didn’t seem that bad did it. | |
| |
| the disallowed goal on 12:05 - Aug 10 with 892 views | TRUE_BLUE123 |
Such a clear foul.
I would want Greaves to be stronger but not a controversial decision to me |  |
| |
| the disallowed goal on 12:19 - Aug 10 with 823 views | LeoMuff |
| the disallowed goal on 11:58 - Aug 10 by berkstractorboy |
I'm with you Benters, 50/50 on it, there is contact and I am not so sure how much it really impedes him. Tbf I would be livid it it had been blown against us and we went on to put the ball in the net. I also listened to Greaves Sky interview after the match and he said he felt contact, but it didn't to me sound like Greaves thought it as a blatant foul but one you sometimes get for or against you. |
Contact ? He launched himself both feet off the ground into his back, of course it was a foul |  |
| |
| the disallowed goal on 12:20 - Aug 10 with 815 views | redrickstuhaart |
| the disallowed goal on 12:19 - Aug 10 by LeoMuff |
Contact ? He launched himself both feet off the ground into his back, of course it was a foul |
We had red cards and pens against us last season for far less contact... | | | |
| the disallowed goal on 12:20 - Aug 10 with 810 views | berkstractorboy |
| the disallowed goal on 12:02 - Aug 10 by Benters |
Exactly it didn’t seem that bad did it. |
What baffles me more is if he gives the Greaves one as a foul for contact, how when 15 yards away and looking at it with an unobstructed view did he not give the NFL style block on O'Shea.  | | | |
| the disallowed goal on 12:36 - Aug 10 with 759 views | berkstractorboy |
| the disallowed goal on 12:19 - Aug 10 by LeoMuff |
Contact ? He launched himself both feet off the ground into his back, of course it was a foul |
You must have seen a different camera angle to me. I think launch is a little strong. As I say I can see why it was given I am just not of the opinion it's as clear cut as some others like yourself see it. | | | |
| the disallowed goal on 12:39 - Aug 10 with 744 views | LeoMuff |
| the disallowed goal on 12:20 - Aug 10 by redrickstuhaart |
We had red cards and pens against us last season for far less contact... |
Well refs are nothing if not inconsistent but a very clear foul for me. | |
| |
| the disallowed goal on 12:51 - Aug 10 with 701 views | Ftnfwest |
Whatever else the whistle went immediately and before the lob so not a disallowed goal |  | | |
| the disallowed goal on 15:19 - Aug 10 with 479 views | Vic |
| the disallowed goal on 11:30 - Aug 10 by redrickstuhaart |
Its not against the grain, just wrong.
The attacker literally jumps into Greaves' back with no interest in the ball. |
Greaves has his eyes on the ball, Brum player jumps into him and pushes him out of the way so he completely misses the headers. Foul all day long.
Pen was incredibly soft. Let’s remember that when a decision goes the other way! |  |
| |
| the disallowed goal on 16:45 - Aug 10 with 320 views | Wickets |
| the disallowed goal on 11:38 - Aug 10 by Benters |
Can’t see it myself I will watch it again later on my Carlos Fandango telly. |
Yes watch it again he jumps into the back of Greaves both feet off the ground and nowhere near the ball . Obvious foul for me and the Ref to his credit had blown before the ball went in the net . |  | | |
| the disallowed goal on 17:03 - Aug 10 with 271 views | Trequartista |
| the disallowed goal on 11:27 - Aug 10 by Benters |
I know this will go against the grain but I thought their disallowed goal was perfectly ok. |
Palmer made no attempt to get back because the whistle had gone. Had it not been a foul he may have got back to save it. |  |
| |
| the disallowed goal on 17:09 - Aug 10 with 237 views | Nthsuffolkblue |
| the disallowed goal on 15:19 - Aug 10 by Vic |
Greaves has his eyes on the ball, Brum player jumps into him and pushes him out of the way so he completely misses the headers. Foul all day long.
Pen was incredibly soft. Let’s remember that when a decision goes the other way! |
I haven't seen the foul on Greaves so will wait to watch that back but the penalty was absolutely clear. You can argue about whether the rule is right but it is 100% a penalty as the rules stand. Both Davies and Chambers said they called it before the ref even blew for it and laughed at Morrison for suggesting it was anything but one. Davies did add that he doesn't agree with the rule, though. |  |
| |
| the disallowed goal on 17:46 - Aug 10 with 206 views | Chrisd |
| the disallowed goal on 11:27 - Aug 10 by Benters |
I know this will go against the grain but I thought their disallowed goal was perfectly ok. |
I’m with you, nothing in it. A terrific finish too. | |
| |
| the disallowed goal on 17:53 - Aug 10 with 184 views | positivity |
| the disallowed goal on 11:27 - Aug 10 by Benters |
I know this will go against the grain but I thought their disallowed goal was perfectly ok. |
maybe in the '70s, law has changed since then though!
if var had been involved, goal would never have been given either | |
| |
| |
By continuing to use the site, you agree to our use of cookies and to abide by our Terms and Conditions.
